| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
The Leslie and Susan Gonda (Goldschmied) Diabetes and Genetic Research Center, Department of Diabetes, Endocrinology & Metabolism, City of Hope National Medical Center, Duarte, California 91010; and Department of Medicine, Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, Torrance, California 90502
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
I. Introduction
II. Physiology of Male Sexual Function
A. Penile structure, vasculature, and innervation
B. Normal penile and testicular size in adult males
C. Local control of penile erection
D. Normal control of male sexual response
E. Penodynamic changes during the male sexual cycle
F. Nocturnal penile tumescence (NPT)
G. Male sexual function and aging
III. Disorders of Male Sexual Function
A. Disorders of desire
B. Erectile dysfunction
C. Disorders of ejaculation
D. Disorders of orgasm
E. Failure of detumescence
IV. Diagnostic Assessment of Sexual Dysfunction in the Male
A. History
B. Physical examination
C. Selective investigations for male sexual dysfunction
V. Treatment
A. Hypoactive or deficient sexual desire
B. Partial or complete erectile dysfunction
C. Disorders of ejaculation
D. Absence of orgasm
E. Failure of detumescence (priapism)
F. Effect of sexual dysfunction and its treatment on quality of life in
VI. Summary and Future Directions
| I. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Significant advances in the understanding of the physiology and pathophysiology of male sexual function, and in methods of its investigation and treatment, have been attained during the past three decades. In the field of physiology, the nature and elements of the normal sexual response have been delineated, and functional activities of all penile structures have been clarified and integrated. The exact role of the various components of the neural system has also become more fully understood. In the field of pathophysiology, estimations of the relative contribution of psychogenic and organic factors to genesis of the various forms of male sexual dysfunction have approached the reality; and many risk factors for development of organic dysfunction have been identified. In the field of physical and laboratory evaluation, many new psychometric, hormonal, vascular, and neurological investigative procedures have been attempted. As a result, sound techniques for accurate prediction of functional and structural changes are now emerging.
This review describes many of these recent advances in the understanding of male sexual function and its disorders. Currently available methods of investigation are outlined and clinical algorithms for their use are presented. Recently developed strategies in psychological, medical, and surgical treatments are also summarized and related to the relevant pathophysiology. It is hoped that information provided in this review will help scientists and healthcare policy makers to develop appropriate and timely strategies to meet current and future demands to prevent and/or alleviate male sexual dysfunction. It is also hoped that material provided in this review will help the reproductive endocrinologist to widen the scope of his or her professional activity from the limited focus on gonadal function to the wider consideration of all inseparable and integrated aspects of human sexual and reproductive capacities.
| II. Physiology of Male Sexual Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The autonomic innervation of the penis is both parasympathetic and
sympathetic (Fig. 2
). The major efferent
parasympathetic pathway originates in the intermediolateral aspect of
the sacral cord (S2S4)
traveling in the pelvic nerve (Nervi Erigentes) to supply a
vasodilating innervation to the corporeal bodies. After the
parasympathetic nerve fibers exit the spinal cord, they run
through the retroperitoneal space in the lateral aspect of the
rectum and bladder, and then pass inferiorly and laterally toward the
prostate and urogenital diaphragm. The cavernous nerve enters the
corporeal body alongside the cavernous artery at the crura of the
corpora as preganglionic nerve fibers. The most likely neurotransmitter
at the synaptic end of these fibers is acetylcholine. The
postganglionic nerve fiber segments terminate either on the vascular
smooth muscle of the corporeal arterioles or the nonvascular smooth
muscle of trabecular tissue surrounding the corporeal lacunae (see Ref.
3 for review). The sacral parasympathetic neurons are chiefly
responsible for the erectile function and are influenced by a
cortical-sacral efferent pathway. The penile erection can be initiated
with a single episode of pelvic nerve electrical stimulation.
Maintenance of erection for an extended period of time without
significant changes in corporeal body blood gases can be achieved with
repetitive stimulation for 4050 sec, with a minimum latency period of
50 sec between each stimulus (3). The sympathetic innervation of
the penis mediates the detumescence after the orgasmic relief, and in
the absence of sexual arousal it maintains the penis in the flaccid
state.
|
Reports on penile volume are limited and have relied either upon the measurement of penile circumference manually (5) or penile cross-section by ultrasound techniques (4, 6, 7). The increase in central obesity may contribute to occasionally reported decrease in penile length with age. There is a loss of tensile strength of the tunica as men grow older, but no loss of the tunica albuginea itself.
Normally, the testis increases in size from 13 cm3 during the neonatal period of life to 1530 cm3 in adulthood. The germ cells and seminiferous tubules represent 90% of the testicular volume while Leydig cells contribute to less than 1%. A normal size adult testis has dimensions of 4.15.2 cm in length and 2.53.3 cm in width (8). Based on the available data, Wessells and colleagues (4) considered adult men with penile length of greater than 4 cm in the unstretched flaccid state or greater than 7.5 cm in the stretched flaccid state or the erect state to have a normal penile length. No parallel suggestions were made for penile girth or volume.
C. Local control of penile erection
Acetylcholine appears to be the neurotransmitter of the
preganglionic parasympathetic neurons. The neurotransmitters for the
short postganglionic neurons have not been fully defined. Acetylcholine
does not appear to influence the contractility of the corporeal smooth
muscle fibers directly, but does so through activation of cholinergic
receptors on the endothelial cells (Fig. 3
). Nitric oxide (NO) has been identified
in the corporeal tissue (9) and is believed to be the
endothelial-derived relaxation factor(s). NO is synthesized from its
precursor, L-arginine, by the enzyme nitric oxide synthase
(NOS). Both constitutive and inducible NOS isoforms are produced in the
cavernosal tissues (10, 11). Constitutive NOS is produced by the
endothelial cells and the nerve terminals, whereas the inducible NOS
appears to be produced by the corporeal smooth muscle cells only.
|
Other noncholinergic parasympathetic neurotransmitters capable of promoting smooth muscle relaxation, and hence the erectile response, include vasoactive intestinal polypeptide (VIP), bradykinin, peptide histidine methionine, pituitary adenylate cyclase-activating polypeptide, helospectin, galanin, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), and prostaglandin E-1 (18, 19, 20, 21). Before the identification of NO in the penile tissue, VIP was thought to be the chief neuromediator of the erectile function; however, VIP was found to colocalize with NOS in penile neurons of rats and humans (22). Its relaxation effect on the corporeal smooth muscle fibers appears to be mediated by the NO-cGMP pathway (23) similar to bradykinins ability to stimulate the endothelial NOS pathway to generate NO (24). However, the exact mechanisms by which other neuropeptides participate in regulation of the erectile function remain to be determined.
Norepinephrine is responsible for regulation of corpus cavernosum
smooth muscle tone via the interaction with
-1 and
-2 adrenergic
receptors (25). Other neurotransmitters capable of promoting smooth
muscle contraction, and hence detumescence, include endothelin-1,
substance-P, PGF-2
, thromboxane A-2, angiotensin II, and calcium
(18, 20, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30). Some of these agents exert their effect through
modulation of the presynaptic
-2 adrenergic receptors. A role for
sympathetic innervation of the penis in mediation of psychologically
provoked erection has been suggested, but the validity of such a belief
was disputed based upon the observation of a full retainment of
erectile capacity in men who undergo bilateral complete sympathectomy
(31, 32). However, the recent in vitro studies demonstrating
the relaxation effect of the ß-2 adrenergic receptor agonist
isoproterenol on noradrenaline-precontracted human penile smooth muscle
cells (33) suggest that, at least in some situations, ß-adrenergic
innervation could participate in the mediation of human erection.
-1 Adrenergic receptors are the preponderant subtype in corporeal
smooth muscles (34) and the deep dorsal penile vein (35), whereas
-2
receptors dominate in the cavernosal arteries (34). However, no
quantitative differences in the prevalence of the two subtypes have
been found in the circumflex veins of either potent or impotent men.
Crowe and colleagues (36) found the greatest density of nerves
supplying the deep dorsal vein and the vasa vasorum to be (in
decreasing order) neuropeptide-Y (NPY), VIP, and
dopamine-ß-hydroxylase-containing nerves. These investigators
proposed that NPY, by its prolonged vasoconstricting effect, may aid in
penile erection, and the vasodilating effect of VIP may be involved in
facilitating the drainage of penile blood during detumescence. A recent
series of in vitro experiments by Segarra and colleagues
(37) using ring segments of human penile dorsal vein has provided
additional evidence for an active role of the deep dorsal vein in the
total penile vascular resistance through the release of NO from both
neural and endothelial elements.
The presence of a critical balance of smooth muscle to connective
tissue has been suggested for the successful veno-occlusion and the
manifestation of erectile response to occur. A potential role for
transforming growth factor ß-1 (TGF-ß1) and PGE-1 in maintaining
this critical balance of smooth muscle/connective tissue and a role for
intracorporeal oxygen tension in regulation of synthesis of these
regulatory factors have also been suggested (38). Thus, neuronal
dysregulation or poor intrinsic compliance of the corporeal smooth
muscle cells could be a significant factor in the pathogenesis of
erectile dysfunction (Fig. 4
) (39).
|
D. Normal control of male sexual response
Sexual stimulation of the human male results in a series of
psychological, neuronal, vascular, and local genital changes. At least
three different classifications for these changes have been described.
Kolodny et al. (40) described a psychosexual response cycle
that consists of four phases: excitement, plateau, orgasm, and
resolution. Table 1
describes neural
pathways, end-organ changes, penile hemodynamic changes, and genital
responses that occur during each phase of this cycle.
|
A third classification focuses on the functional activities during the sexual cycle (43). It adds an initial phase of desire or libido to encompass the sex-seeking behavior, pools together excitement and plateau into a single phase of erection, and splits the orgasmic phase into the physical function of ejaculation and the psychological sensation of orgasmic pleasure. Thus, the normal male sexual response cycle can be functionally divided into five interrelated events that occur in a defined sequence: libido, erection, ejaculation, orgasm, and detumescence. Since the functional classification of the male sexual cycle is the most physically quantifiable one, it will constitute the basis for the following discussion.
1. Libido or sexual desire. Libido is defined as the biological need for sexual activity (the sex drive) and frequently is expressed as sex-seeking behavior. Its intensity is variable between individuals as well as within an individual over a given time. Little is known about the physiological basis of libido. However, previous and recent sexual activity, psychosocial background, brain and spinal cord dopaminergic receptor activation, and gonadal hormones are among the factors that are believed to participate in regulation of male sexual desire.
Several lines of evidence in animal and human males support a role for
central dopaminergic neurotransmission in mediating sexual behavior and
erection (see Ref. 44 for review). Further, testosterone promotion of
copulation appears to be mediated by an increase in dopamine release in
the medial preoptic area, possibly via up-regulation of NO synthesis
(45). A role for dopaminergic activation in stimulation of sexual
behavior in the human is supported by the following observations:
administration of the dopamine agonists apomorphine, bromocriptine, and
pergolide mesylate frequently elicits spontaneous penile erection; use
of the dopamine precursor levodopa is associated with increased libido
(46), return of spontaneous erection (47), or onset of nocturnal
emissions (48) in 2030% of patients with Parkinsons disease who
are treated with this agent; and use of pharmacological agents with
antidopaminergic effects is associated with decreased libido and
erectile dysfunction in up to 50% of cases. However, caution must be
exerted in interpreting some of these data for the following reasons:
lack of consistency in the results of many investigations;
pharmacological agents used may stimulate or inhibit other central
neuromediator systems, including adrenergic, cholinergic, serotonergic,
histaminic, and peptidergic systems; and many neuroleptics increase PRL
secretion, which can decrease libido through inhibition of the
hypothalamic-pituitary- gonadal axis or inhibition of
5
-reductase activity (49).
Evidence for a role of androgens in regulation of sexual behavior in the human male has been reviewed by Mooradian and colleagues (50). Higher serum testosterone appears to be associated with greater sexual activity in healthy older (51) but not younger (52) men. Further, higher testosterone levels may also shorten the latency of erection stimulated by the exposure to erotic material (53), and testosterone replacement in hypogonadal males restores sexual interest (54), shortens latency, and increases frequency and magnitude of nocturnal penile tumescence (NPT) (55). Conversely, withdrawal of androgen therapy in hypogonadal males leads to a decline of libido in 34 weeks (56), and unreplaced hypogonadal men have impairment in spontaneity of erection (56, 57). Despite these androgen deficiency-related abnormalities, hypogonadism does not appear to compromise the ability to achieve erection in response to viewing of erotic films (55, 58).
2. Erection. Erection is the ultimate response to multiple psychogenic and sensory stimuli from imaginative, visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, tactile, and genital reflexogenic sources, which effect several neurological and vascular cascades that lead to penile tumescence and rigidity sufficient for vaginal penetration. Further, erection is associated with significant psychological and physical changes, including heightened sexual arousal, full testicular assent and swelling, dilatation of the urethral bulb, an increase in glans and coronal size, cutaneous flush over the epigastrium, chest, and buttocks, nipple erection, tachycardia and elevation in blood pressure, hyperventilation, and generalized myotonia (40, 59). The local penile changes are effected by a vasodilating parasympathetic discharge subsequent to the central nervous system (CNS) inputs or as a result of reflex action in response to local afferent stimulation of the sacral parasympathetic nuclei.
New data implicating gonadal androgens in modulation of penile erection through local regulation of NO secretion and/or action need to be emphasized. Experiments that have shown castrated rats to have reduced penile tissue NOS content and androgen replacement to restore NOS production and action (60) have cast doubt on the older dogma that androgens act only centrally to modulate sexual libido. Data in which androgens were shown to influence the frequency of nonerotic or "reflex" erection support a role for peripheral androgen actions in the human (61). Moreover, a recent study in rats by Lugg and colleagues (62) implicates dihydrotestosterone and not testosterone as the local modulating androgen of the NO-cGMP pathway. However, the fact that androgens can enhance NPT, but not erection in response to erotic stimuli (61), may suggest the presence of both androgen-sensitive and androgen-insensitive central pathways for erectile control.
3. Ejaculation. The ejaculation phase is controlled by sympathetic innervation of the genital organs and occurs as a result of a spinal cord reflex arc. There is a considerable voluntary inhibitory control over this phase of the sexual response, which consists of two sequential processes. The first process is called emission and is associated with deposition of seminal fluid into the posterior urethra. Simultaneous contractions of the ampulla of the vas deferens, the seminal vesicles, and the smooth muscles of the prostate (43, 63) mediate emission. The second process is the true ejaculation and results in expulsion of the seminal fluid from the posterior urethra through the penile meatus.
Evidence reviewed by Segraves (44) suggests that serotonergic neurotransmission has an inhibitory effect on male sexual function and ejaculation. The inhibitory action of serotonin neurotransmission on ejaculation is likely to be mediated by the serotonergic tracts in the medial forebrain bundle.
4. Orgasm. Both physiological and psychogenic elements contribute to genesis of the orgasmic phase (43, 64). Afferent stimuli that transmit via the pudendal nerve induce the following physiological events: smooth muscle contraction of the accessory sex organs; buildup and release of pressure in the posterior urethra; sensation of the ejaculatory inevitability; contraction of the urethral bulb and perineum; rhythmic contractions of the pelvic floor muscles; semen emission and ejaculation; and finally, the reversal of the generalized physiological changes and sexual tension. Sensory cortical neurons perceive these events as pleasurable. Factors that influence the subjective sensation of orgasmic pleasure include the degree of sexual excitement, recency of sexual activity, and the psychosexual makeup of the individual. It is possible for orgasm to occur without being preceded by the previous two phases of erection and ejaculation. Conversely, contractions of pelvic musculature and ejaculation could occur in the absence of orgasmic sensations.
5. Detumescence. During this phase the penis returns to the
flaccid state. Vasoconstriction of the arterioles and reversal of
events within the contractile corporeal units divert the blood away
from the cavernous sinuses and allow an increase in the venous drainage
of their contents. Initially, the rate of blood outflow increases by
about 10-fold, followed by a progressively decreasing rate until it
reaches the pretumescence level (63) and a period of inhibition to
resumption of erectile and ejaculatory functions. The length of this
refractory phase is dependent upon many variables including age,
physical state, and psychological environment (43, 63, 64). However,
the traditional view that assumes male orgasm is instantly followed by
detumescence and refractoriness has recently been challenged by
reported observations in which some men were multiorgasmic, and the
phenomenon of repeated orgasms without intervening detumescence and
refractoriness was actively learned by some males (65). Local penile
-adrenergic receptor activation is the most important neuromediator
effecting detumescence. Interference with this function through the
-1 receptor blockade may lead to the development of priapism (66).
E. Penodynamic changes during the male sexual cycle
The evidence reviewed above suggests that a fall of resistance
within the corporeal vascular bed and the subsequent increase in
arterial inflow are the major vascular events leading to erection of
the penis (Figs. 4
and 5
) (39, 63, 67). A
dramatic increase in penile arterial blood flow to about 25 to 60 times
that of the flaccid state occurs during the rapid period of tumescence
(63). Pulse Doppler analysis studies with intracavernous vasoactive
drug injections have established that a peak cavernosal artery systolic
flow greater than 25 ml/sec is required for erection to occur (68, 69, 70, 71).
At full rigidity, an increase in penile length of 7.5 cm usually
requires the entrapment of 80115 ml of blood. As the penile volume
increases to near maximum (from <10 ml in the flaccid state to
60
ml in the erect state), the arterial influx declines and plateaus at a
level that is sufficient to keep the penis in the rigid (full erection)
state. Dynamic infusion cavernosometry and cavernosography (DICC)
studies have shown that a fluid flow rate between 5 and 40 ml/min is
required to maintain a normal penis in the erect state (72, 73).
Further, at these minimum flow rates of full erection, the cavernosal
artery occlusion pressure (CAOP) equilibrates with the intracavernous
pressure.
|
F. Nocturnal penile tumescence (NPT)
NPT refers to spontaneous penile erections that occur during the
rapid eye movement (REM) stage of sleep. The phenomenon occurs four to
five times per night at 90-min intervals, and each episode lasts 3045
min. Total NPT time ranges between 90 and 180 min per night and
accounts for 2025% of the total sleep time (67, 74, 75, 76). Ninety
percent of REM sleep episodes are associated with penile tumescence,
with maximum changes in circumference and about 70% of full rigidity.
The number of erectile and maximum tumescence episodes decreases with
age, from 6.8 and 4 per night at age 13 yr, to 3.5 and 1.7 per night at
age 70 yr, respectively. As a result, total tumescence time decreases
by about 25% between these two ages. Most dreams associated with NPT
are not associated with erotic content. Erections on waking usually
represent NPT associated with the last episode of REM sleep and are not
related to bladder fullness (see Ref. 75 for review).
Serum androgen concentrations may have a role in regulation of NPT (54, 55, 58, 77). In addition, studies during waking and sleep in normal
males and in men with erectile insufficiency suggest that
-2
antagonists enhance central arousability of the kind that is androgen
dependent. These studies also suggest that more than one
norepinephrine-mediated system is involved in this process, with
possible contrasting and counteracting effects (77, 78).
A small number of studies have reported on the effect of
pharmacological agents on NPT. Antidepressants and antihypertensives
are the most investigated classes of drugs for their effect on NPT.
Trazodone, an antidepressant with complex pharmacological effects
including serotonin reuptake inhibition, prolongs NPT while it
decreases REM sleep duration (79). In contrast, amitriptyline (a
tricyclic antidepressant) and mianserin (a tetracyclic
-2 receptor
blocker) decrease both the amplitude and duration of NPT (80). Varying
effects on NPT have been seen with different members of the ß-blocker
family (81, 82, 83).
G. Male sexual function and aging
Males reach peak sexual capacity in the late teens. With
advancement of age, a gradual decrease in sexual responsiveness occurs
(84), characterized by a prolongation of the time required to achieve
full erection and decrease in the effectiveness of psychic and tactile
stimuli. The plateau phase is also prolonged, and the maintenance of
erection requires continuing direct genital stimulation. Orgasm and the
feeling of ejaculatory inevitability frequently become less intense.
Penile detumescence occurs more rapidly and the refractory period is
more prolonged. The ejaculatory volume also decreases with age. Recent
studies in rats have shown that advanced age is associated with a
decrease in the number of NOS-containing penile nerve fibers, erectile
response to apomorphine stimulation, and maximum intracavernous
pressure. It is not clear at present whether some of these changes are
related to the age-associated decline in serum testosterone
concentrations.
The effects of age on male reproductive physiology have recently been
reviewed (85). Aging is associated with decreased total serum and
bioavailable testosterone concentrations, decreased testosterone to
estradiol ratio, increased sex hormone-binding-globulin (SHBG) leading
to increased plasma protein binding of circulating testosterone and
decreased testosterone clearance, decreased LH pulse frequency, and
diminished accumulation of 5
-reduced steroids in reproductive
tissues. Some of these changes are related to the increased incidence
of idiopathic hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (86) and/or a decline in
serum levels of GH, insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1), and
dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEA-S) (85). Normally, IGF-I enhances
the Leydig cell response to LH, and DHEA-S provides a precursor for
testosterone production.
Recent studies, such as the Massachusetts Male Aging Study, showed that
between the ages of 40 and 70 yr, serum levels of both free- and
albumin-bound testosterone decrease annually by about 1% (87). Several
studies have confirmed the role of obesity in the decline of androgen
levels in aging men (88). Both age- and obesity-related reduction in
gonadal hormones are caused by a parallel decline in the functional
capacity of the hypothalamic-pituitary axis (88). A decrease in number
of testicular Leydig cells (82) and in their secretory capacity for
testosterone in response to hCG injections (89) in aging men has also
been shown. Recent studies have implicated leptin (the obese
ob gene product) in the development of some of these
abnormalities. Decreased testosterone production with age could be due
to a decrease in dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) and DHEA-S formation
(90) as a result of a differential decrease in the side chain cleavage
(17,20-lyase activity) rather than in the 17
-hydroxylation of the
cytochrome P450C17 enzyme system. This decrease
in 17,20-lyase activity restricts the metabolic conversion of 17-
-
hydroxy progesterone to DHEA and its steroid derivatives, including
testosterone (91).
Korenman and colleagues (92) have suggested that 90% of older men with reduced testosterone concentration have evidence of hypothalamic-pituitary dysfunction as reflected by a low-normal serum LH and reduced LH response to GnRH stimulation. A few other studies have also shown the absence of correlation between erectile dysfunction and testosterone concentration (93). However, since long-standing hypogonadal men usually complain of loss of sexual interest and activity, decrease in seminal emission volumes, loss of nocturnal and morning erections, and loss of energy and sense of well-being, and, since testosterone replacement is associated with improved self-reported libido, sexual potency, and both subjective (56, 57) and objective measures of nocturnal erections (94), severe testosterone deficiency is likely to be the primary cause of sexual dysfunction in many cases of combined hypogonadism and erectile dysfunction.
| III. Disorders of Male Sexual Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) Consensus Development Conference (96) advocated that "erectile dysfunction" be used instead of "impotence" to describe disorders of male sexual function and defined the new terminology as the "inability to achieve an erect penis as part of the overall multifaceted process of male sexual function." However, use of the term "erectile dysfunction" to refer to all aspects of male sexual dysfunction would be inappropriate.
Major advances have been made in the last few years toward
understanding the nature of various forms of male sexual dysfunction
and the possible underlying organic and psychological factors. Table 2
lists the clinical manifestations and
the most common etiological categories for sexual dysfunction in the
male. Identification of the sexual response component central to the
dysfunction can significantly reduce the number of investigations
required to characterize the underlying etiology(s) (97). However, the
exact contribution of each etiological category to the genesis of a
given dysfunction may be difficult to establish, but the knowledge of
its presence is essential to treatment planning.
|
Psychogenic conditions leading to a desire deficiency state in men (previously termed desire inhibition) include psychiatric illnesses such as depression or psychosis, preoccupation with life crisis or grief, maternal transference to sexual partners, gender identity conflicts, and aging-related psychological issues (57, 97, 101). Another form of secondary desire disorder caused by psychological factors is termed "excitement inhibition" and is seen in patients who have sexual drive but cannot maintain excitement. It is commonly seen in patients with performance anxiety due to the fear of sexual failure and the vigilant preoccupation with erection during lovemaking (57, 101). Traumatic employment or marriage-related issues may contribute to diminished self-image and heightened anxiety leading to male sexual dysfunction. A substantial number of patients with affective disorder, chronic depression, and obsessional personality may also develop a desire disorder. A high frequency of sexual dysfunction was also reported in males with schizophrenia (102).
Patients with a primary CNS disease such as partial epilepsy (103), Parkinsonism (104), poststroke (95), and adreno-leukodystrophy (105) may have diminished sexual arousal. The pathogenesis of desire insufficiency in these disorders appears to be multifactorial in origin and includes disease-related hormone abnormalities, physical restrictions, and reduced general well-being.
A critical level of blood androgens is required for the maintenance of normal sexual desire, NPT, and nonerotic penile erections in most men. A certain concentration of androgens is required for initiation and maintenance of spermatogenesis and for maximum stimulation of growth and function of the prostate and seminal vesicles (43, 67). The amount of androgens required for these latter effects is greater than that needed for maintenance of libido.
Not all studies that have examined the relationship between serum testosterone and sexual desire in aging men have reported a robust relationship. Therefore, total or free-testosterone levels may not be an adequate measure of sexual drive, at least in some populations.
A number of pharmacological agents or drugs of addiction could potentially induce libido dysfunction, including antihypertensives (chlorthalidone, guanadrel, guanethidine, methyldopa, reserpine, and spironolactone), psychiatric medications (fluoxetine, barbiturates, clomipramine, and fluphenazine), and others (danazol, digoxin, ethinyl-estradiol, ketoconazole, methadone, niacin, alcohol, diazepam, and marijuana) (99, 100, 106, 107, 108).
Several mechanisms of action exist for drugs commonly associated with male sexual dysfunction. Drugs that create HSD can have sedating effects and/or produce a central neurogenic blockade. Testosterone deficiency and antagonism may also lead to HSD. Medications that produce an elevation in PRL or induce parasympatholysis can manifest erectile dysfunction. Absence of emission and/or retrograde ejaculation can be found in men using antihypertensives, monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors, or antipsychotics due to sympatholysis. Lastly, delayed ejaculation and/or orgasmic dysfunction may occur with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) usage due to serotonergic agonist effects.
Another group of desire disorders with psychological bases is known as compulsive sexual behaviors (CSBs) (109, 110). CSBs constitute a wide range of complex sexual behaviors that have strikingly repetitive, compelling, or driven qualities. They usually manifest as one or more of several aberrant sexual behaviors, including obsessive-compulsive sexuality (e.g., excessive masturbation and promiscuity), excessive sex-seeking in association with affective disorders (e.g., major depression or mood disorders), addictive sexuality (e.g., attachment to another person, object, or sensation for sexual gratification to the exclusion of everything else), and sexual impulsivity (failure to resist an impulse or temptation for sexual behavior that is harmful to self or others such as exhibitionism, rape, or child molestation). Detailed discussion of these disorders is beyond the scope of this review and can be found elsewhere (109, 110).
B. Erectile dysfunction
This is best defined as persistent failure to generate sufficient
penile body pressure to achieve vaginal penetration and/or the
inability to maintain this degree of penile rigidity until ejaculation
(63). Although the exact prevalence of erectile dysfunction in the
United States male population is not known, estimates have ranged from
12% of males above age 18 in the report of Furlow (111) to 2530% of
men between ages 60 and 70 in the surveys of Kinsey and colleagues
(59), Schiavi and colleagues (112), and Diokno and colleagues
(113), and to 52% in the Massachusetts Male Aging Study (93).
The current literature on the relationship between sexual dysfunction and psychiatric disorders in men is not extensive, and much of the older literature is limited by methodological flaws. However, several new studies have established some association between sexual dysfunction and psychological disorders. In the Massachusetts Male Aging Study, male erectile dysfunction was found to be associated with depressive symptoms (odds ratio 1.82) (114). Similar results were reported by at least one other study in which depressed patients with erectile dysfunction had lower libido and were more likely to discontinue treatment for their erectile problem than other patients without depression (115). Further, in the cross-sectional Massachusetts Male Aging Study the incidence of moderate to complete erectile dysfunction was estimated to be nearly 90%, 60%, and 25% in men with severe, moderate, and minimal depression, respectively (114). In addition, older studies have estimated that approximately one-third of all patients with untreated depression have reported sexual dysfunction (116). The association between male erectile dysfunction and panic disorder (117) and perfectionism (118) has also been reported.
Many commonly prescribed pharmacological agents can adversely influence sexual function of the male (107, 108). Antihypertensives, anticholinergics, psychotropics, and many other agents are common causes for erectile dysfunction. The percentage of men with complete erectile dysfunction in the Massachusetts Male Aging Study who were taking hypoglycemic agents (26%), antihypertensive drugs (14%), vasodilators (36%), and cardiac drugs (28%) was significantly higher than the 9.6% observed for the sample as a whole (93). The cause of erectile dysfunction in many of these patients may not be related to the intake of the pharmacological agent but to the underlying disease. Another possibility in the case of antihypertensives is the reduction of blood pressure in the face of penile arterial atherosclerosis (119).
Mechanisms by which medications can induce erectile dysfunction may include central and/or peripheral neurological blockade or stimulation of PRL secretion. Hyperprolactinemia may reduce testosterone concentration and action through a variety of mechanisms including disruption of the anatomic integrity of the hypothalamic-pituitary axis, decreased GnRH expression (120), interference with GnRH action on the pituitary (121), inhibition of gonadotropin secretion (122), and reduction of testosterone conversion to the more active metabolite dihydrotestosterone (123). Hypogonadism has recently been shown to be associated with decreased NO formation and action in the penis, thus reducing erectile capacity (124, 125). Priapism as a mechanism for erectile dysfunction may be invoked by the intake of phenothiazines (e.g., thioridazine and chlorpromazine) (107) or the newer antidepressant trazodone (107, 108). At present, it is not clear whether drugs of addiction such as alcohol, methadone, and heroin reduce sexual potency by influencing the secretion and metabolism of androgens or by the associated deterioration in the general physical and psychological status of the addict (43, 107).
There is convincing evidence that smoking is a major risk factor for the development of erectile dysfunction (93, 126). Recent statistical studies have shown that the relative risk of developing arterial atherosclerosis in the penis, and subsequent erectile dysfunction, is 1.31 for each 10 pack-years smoked (127), and that 86% of smokers have an abnormal penile vascular evaluation (128). Long-term smoking has also caused ultrastructural damage to the corporeal tissue in impotent men (129). Acute vasospasm of penile arteries in response to cigarette smoking, possibly subsequent to excessive release of catecholamines, has also been reported (130). Nicotine and conitine were shown to inhibit steroidogenesis in mouse Leydig cells (131), and long-term passive smoking in the rat has been shown to cause an age-independent moderate hypertension as well as considerable decrease in penile NOS activity and neuronal NOS content (132). Thus, smoking impairs erection through a variety of mechanisms, including enhancing atherogenesis, reduction in testosterone production, inappropriate adrenergic stimulation, and inhibition of local vasodilator(s) release.
The organic causes of erectile dysfunction can be grouped into systemic diseases and endocrine, neurological, vascular, or local penile disorders (43). A variety of advanced states of systemic diseases are associated with sexual dysfunctions (97), including chronic liver disease (133), renal failure (134), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (135), sleep apnea (136, 137), cancer (138, 139), and postorgan transplantation (140). Hepatic cirrhosis and renal failure adversely affect androgen production and/or metabolism.
In addition to deficiency of androgen secretion and/or action that has already been addressed in the preceding section, diabetes mellitus has increasingly been recognized as a major cause for erectile dysfunction (141, 142). Surveys by various investigators suggest that erectile dysfunction occurs in about 50% of diabetic males (97), which is twice the incidence in nondiabetic normal males (111). Moreover, the frequency of erectile dysfunction in diabetics increases with age, from about 25% at age 35 to greater than 70% after age 60, and among diabetic patients with autonomic neuropathy.
Vascular insufficiency is probably the most common cause of organic male sexual dysfunction (67, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147). Atherosclerosis of the large pelvic arteries (common iliac, hypogastric, or pudendal) can lead to inadequate perfusion of the penis. In some instances of unilateral disease, erection is achievable while the patient is in the supine position but is lost upon initiation of active pelvic movements. Shunting of blood from the penis to the hip muscles constitutes the pathogenic mechanism for this "steal" phenomenon (144). Other examples of large vessel disease are Leriche syndrome (143) and penile Raynauds phenomenon (147). In the former condition, impedance of penile blood supply occurs as a result of obstruction of the distal aorta and presents with claudication of lower back, buttocks, and thighs, whereas the latter condition is due to a vasospastic disorder superimposed on borderline penile arterial flow. Alternatively, obliteration of the small vessels of the cavernous tissue is frequently implicated in the diminution of erectile rigidity in aged men and in men with diabetes (67, 141, 148, 149).
Erectile dysfunction secondary to excessive venous leakage is being reported with significant frequency in clinical studies (72, 73, 150). However, studies in animal models and the low success rate of venous ligation surgery in humans (2873% of patients recover their erectile function after surgery) suggest that the primary defect is likely to be related to an abnormal function (incomplete relaxation) of trabecular smooth muscle cells of the corpora cavernosa rather than due to a pathological process inflecting the penile veins themselves (151).
Erectile dysfunction can accompany a variety of acute and chronic central and peripheral nervous system diseases (67, 74, 152, 153, 154). Spinal cord injuries deserve a special comment. Loss of erectile or ejaculatory functions in these conditions depends upon the level and extent of the damage. Upper motor neuron lesions diminish the erectile response to psychogenic stimuli but leave the reflexogenic erections intact. The degree of diminution in psychogenic erections is directly related to the extent of the lesion. In contrast, lower motor neuron lesions abolish the reflexogenic response without altering the psychogenic erections except when the lesion is complete. When the latter occurs, psychogenic erections diminish in about 75% of patients (153, 155).
Penile diseases, such as congenital malformation (156), Peyronies disease (157), priapism (158, 159, 160, 161), phimosis (162), and, rarely, cold abscess (163), may interfere with erectile function. Sporadic reports of congenital anomalies, such as absent communication between the corpora cavernosa (isolated cavernous bodies), corporeal venoocclusive dysfunction, and/or hypoplastic cavernous arteries leading to primary erectile dysfunction, have also been reported (156, 164). Lack of circumcision in older men was reported to be associated with a higher incidence of sexual dysfunction (165).
Genitourinary trauma that results in rupture of the corpora cavernosa or the encapsulating connective tissue sheaths, formation of traumatic occlusion of multiple arteries, posttraumatic aneurysmal dilatation with arteriovenous fistulae, resection of the cavernosal nerves during pelvic surgery, penile schwannoma, or pelvic irradiation can all be causes for erectile dysfunction (158, 159, 160, 161, 162). Radiation exposure has been shown to decrease the number of NOS-containing nerves in the rat penis (166), and regeneration of penile NOS-containing nerves was shown to coincide with the recovery of erectile function in animals with unilateral cavernous nerve injury (167). Such observations suggest that NO pathway abnormalities are involved in the pathogenesis of erectile dysfunction after unilateral cavernosal nerve injury or pelvic radiation in man (10).
C. Disorders of ejaculation
There exists a spectrum of disorders of ejaculation ranging from
mild premature to severely retarded or absent ejaculation. Normally, by
age 17 or 18 yr, 75% of men are able to control their ejaculation
(168). Premature ejaculation is the most common male sexual dysfunction
(169). Several surveys among different populations estimate its
prevalence at 29%, with a range between 1% and 75% depending on the
population and criteria used to define the condition (see Refs.
169, 170, 171 for review). The DSM-VI (98) defines the diagnostic criteria
for premature ejaculation as follows: 1) persistent or recurrent
ejaculation with minimum sexual stimulation that occurs before, upon,
or shortly after penetration and before the person wishes it; 2) marked
distress or interpersonal difficulty; and 3) the condition does not
arise as a direct effect of substance abuse, i.e., opiate
withdrawal. Premature ejaculation and sexual desire disorders were the
frequent reported problems in young adult males with adverse familial
relationship to attachment figures (172). Premature ejaculation was
also found to be associated with anxiety in a recent survey of 789 men
in England (173). Table 2
delineates other common causes of disorders
of ejaculation.
Several classifications for premature ejaculation have been reported. In one, premature ejaculation was classified into primary and secondary disorders (170). Primary premature ejaculation describes persons who, since the beginning of sexual experience, have never been able to control the ejaculatory function, whereas secondary premature ejaculation describes individuals who develop the condition after years of satisfactory sexual activity.
Painful ejaculation has been reported as a side effect of tricyclic antidepressants in at least two patients (174). Psychogenic postejaculatory pain syndrome (PEPS) is a rare sexual disorder of male dyspareunia that was first described in 1979 (175) as a persistent and recurrent pain in the genital organs during ejaculation or immediately afterward. Detailed descriptions of clinical features, pathogenesis, and treatment of this syndrome have recently been reviewed by Kaplan (176).
Ejaculatory pain in the testicular region may result from epididymal congestion after vasectomy (177) or from duct obstruction and/or infection (178), testicular torsion, mass lesion, or prostatitis (179). In some cases, specific etiological factors other than psychological stress cannot be identified (180).
D. Disorders of orgasm
Male orgasmic disorder is defined as a persistent or recurrent
delay in, or absence of, orgasm after a normal sexual excitement phase
during sexual activity (98, 181). The disorder is relatively rare,
occurring in 310% of patients presenting with sexual dysfunction
(181). Table 2
delineates the most common causes of orgasmic
dysfunction.
E. Failure of detumescence
Priapism is a prolonged (>4 h duration) and extremely painful
erection unaccompanied by sexual desire and is often preceded by usual
sexual stimuli. The condition is self- perpetuating and is
characterized by diminished perfusion of the corporeal bodies. When
chronically present, corporeal fibrosis and erectile dysfunction occur.
At least two classifications of priapism have been described (158). The
first is etiologically based and classifies the condition into primary
(idiopathic) and secondary priapism. The latter condition could be
precipitated by causes listed in Table 2
. Of particular note,
drug-induced priapism lasting for more than 48 h frequently leads
to the development of corporeal fibrosis (182), and cocaine-induced
priapism can be refractory to treatment (183). The second
classification is pathophysiologically based and depends on measurement
of penile blood gases and pressures. It classifies priapism into
low-blood flow (ischemic) and high-blood flow (nonischemic) conditions.
In the majority of ischemic priapism cases, erection probably starts
with a normal or high-blood flow state (particularly in cases induced
with intrapenile drug injection) and ischemia ensues when a large
number of emissary veins become occluded. Recent studies in rabbits
(184) showed that acidosis impairs trabecular smooth muscle
contractility, probably secondary to the interference of
[H+] with the intra- and extracellular
mechanisms that regulate homeostasis of [Ca2+].
Since acidosis is an early complication of ischemic priapism, it was
thought that the reduced contractility of trabecular smooth muscle is a
significant factor in the perpetuation of the ischemic state (184). A
variant of high-flow priapism that is caused by perineal or penile
trauma occurs as a result of arterial-lacunar fistula. In this
condition, blood bypasses the helicine artery and passes directly into
the lacunar spaces. Characteristically, there is no pain or tenderness
in this form of priapism, and the penis is incompletely but constantly
rigid with a focal area of high-flow turbulence on color-flow Doppler
ultrasound examination and high-oxygen tension (160). Sexual
stimulation may cause a further increase in penile rigidity.
| IV. Diagnostic Assessment of Sexual Dysfunction in the Male |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A. History
Medical, psychological, and sexual histories are extremely helpful
in providing clues to the underlying cause of the dysfunction and they
reduce the need for an expensive investigation to rule out all possible
etiologies.
1. Medical history. Historical events related to the presence of chronic disease (e.g., diabetes, hepatic failure, renal failure, cardiac failure, advanced pulmonary disease, tabes dorsalis, multiple sclerosis, cerebrovascular accident), use of pharmacological agents (e.g., antihypertensives, antihistamines, antipsychotics, anticholinergics), endocrine disorders (gonadal failure, pituitary tumors, thyroid disease, adrenal disease), prior surgeries (prostatectomy, proctectomy, vascular surgery), and trauma (temporal lobe and spinal cord lesions, blunt pelvic trauma) should all be carefully evaluated. Further, vascular risk factors such as family history of cardiovascular disease, hypercholesterolemia, hypertension, diabetes, cigarette smoking, and pelvic radiation therapy should be inquired about, and, if present, vascular etiology should be highly suspected. Potentially irreversible pathology should be anticipated in patients with evidence for other microvascular disease (peripheral neuropathy, retinopathy, and nephropathy). Patients with neurological disease should be questioned about the temporal relationship between the development of the sexual dysfunction and that of the neurological disorder. Patients suspected for hypogonadism should specifically be assessed for family history of the disease, deviation of adolescence from normality, recent changes in secondary sexual characteristics, symptoms of pituitary dysfunction, history of orchitis, testicular trauma, infertility, or exposure to radiation or cytotoxic agents. Patients should also be assessed for symptoms of thyroid and adrenal diseases.
2. Psychological history. Psychological factors associated with male sexual dysfunction have recently been classified into three categories (95, 188): predisposing factors, precipitating factors, and maintaining factors. Restrictive upbringing, disturbed family relationships, traumatic early sexual experiences, inadequate sexual information, and insecurity in the psychosexual role are among the frequently encountered predisposing factors. Unreasonable expectations, random failure, discord in the relationship, dysfunction in the partner, infidelity, reaction to organic disease, or depression or anxiety are some of the factors that could precipitate the onset of sexual dysfunction. Performance anxiety, guilt, poor communication, loss of attraction between partners, and impaired self-image are among the factors that lead to maintenance of the sexual dysfunction. Affective disorders or character pathology can lead to both precipitation and maintenance of sexual problems. Evidence for the presence of any of these psychological or situational conditions should be carefully assessed. Moreover, it should not be forgotten that the existence of an organic disease does not preclude the possibility of a coexisting psychogenic factor. Such omission could lead to diagnostic difficulties as well as to therapeutic failures.
3. Sexual history. One of the first goals of the differential diagnosis during history taking is to ascertain the nature of the sexual dysfunction. The patient should be asked to describe his problem, the time and manner of onset, its course, its current status, and any associated medical or psychological problems.
Decreased libido should alert the clinician to three probable causes:
endocrinopathy, affective disorder, or relationship discord. A history
of frequent strong erections under any circumstances (during foreplay,
fantasy, or masturbation, with another partner or upon awakening)
indicates that the endocrine, vascular, and neurological systems are
probably intact and that the erectile dysfunction is predominantly
psychogenic. Conversely, historical data indicating the presence of
decreased erectile turgidity in noncoital activities are highly
suggestive of an organic etiology. Moreover, a report of firm sustained
erections during foreplay that are lost after intromission or upon
initiation of pelvic movements might suggest either a psychogenic
etiology or a vascular problem (pelvic steal syndrome). A history of
delayed or retrograde ejaculation is suggestive of a neuropathy or an
adverse drug effect. Premature ejaculation, on the other hand, is more
compatible with a psychogenic dysfunction. Finally, it must be
remembered that absence of orgasmic sensations in patients with normal
erectile and ejaculatory functions is almost always due to psychogenic
etiology, whereas failure of detumescence is usually organic in nature,
which should direct the investigations toward ruling out local penile,
neurological, and hematological etiologies. Table 3
lists other historical events most
useful in differentiating predominantly psychogenic from predominantly
organic erectile dysfunctions.
|
Patients suspected of hypogonadism should be assessed for evidence of muscle development, size and structure of the penis (normal adult penis is >6 cm in length in the unstretched flaccid state, 3 cm or more in width, has normal urethral opening, and no evidence of hypospadias) and size and consistency of the testes and the prostate. Patients with moderate hypogonadism including some with Klinefelters syndrome and many patients with gonadotropin deficiency usually exhibit a decrease in testicular volume from a normal size of 1530 cm3 to a size of 612 cm3 (2.93.7 cm length, 1.82.3 cm width) (189). Patients with severe hypogonadism and many with Klinefelters syndrome usually have infantile size testis of 24 cm3 (2.02.5 cm length, 1.21.5 cm width) (8).
A careful vascular assessment should include the palpation of ankle, femoral, and dorsal penile arteries. Penile systolic blood pressure should be determined with a 3-cm blood pressure cuff placed around the base of the penis and a Doppler stethoscope positioned over each cavernosal artery (67, 99, 143, 185, 186). The penile systolic occlusion pressure is then obtained and compared with that of a brachial artery, and a penile brachial index (PBI) is derived (190, 191, 192, 193). Values greater than 0.7 are considered normal (192, 193). Studies by Chiu and colleagues (193) suggested that PBI is highly diagnostic in patients with evidence for peripheral vascular disease but no other risk factors such as diabetes or current intake of medications with potential adverse effects on the erectile function. The PBI is less predictive in patients with peripheral vascular disease and diabetes, and least predictive in those without peripheral vascular disease, diabetes, or current drug intake. Repeating the measurements after 35 min of gluteal muscle exercise (186) may enhance sensitivity of the test. Reduction in PBI by more than 0.15 is suggestive of redistribution of the blood supply and its shunting away from the arterial penile bed to the gluteal region. Such a phenomenon is characteristic of patients with steal syndrome (144). Further, the significance of a low PBI may go beyond aiding the diagnosis of vasculogenic erectile dysfunction. This is suggested by a prospective study in 130 impotent patients that were followed for 2436 months in which a low PBI (0.65 or less) was shown to predict occurrence of a future major vascular event (myocardial infarction or cerebrovascular accident) (194). Physical signs of muscular atrophy, pallor, and/or loss of hair growth of the lower extremities are also consistent with vascular pathology.
Neurologically, the patient should be evaluated for the presence of motor deficits, changes in deep tendon reflexes, loss of sphincter tone, or decrease in light touch or pinprick sensations, particularly in the genital area. Penile temperature sensation testing could also be performed with the use of alcohol swabs (3). In addition, the bulbocavernosus reflex should be elicited by squeezing the glans penis and assessing the evoked contractions of external anal sphincter or bulbocavernosus muscles (186, 195). This reflex response is clinically detectable in 70% of normal males (186). The more sensitive penile vibration perception threshold testing (3, 152, 185, 186, 196, 197) may be performed to confirm results of the bulbocavernosus reflex. Testing of penile vibration perception threshold is performed by sequentially placing a tuning fork on the glans and bilaterally on midshaft of the penis. Vibration amplitude is then increased until the patient perceives the stimulus. The vibration perception threshold testing is the most predictive sensation testing procedure, but others can also help in evaluating a loss of somatic innervation. The penis should also be examined for evidence of masses or plaque formation, angulation, unprovoked persistent erection, or tight unretractable foreskin.
C. Selective investigations for male sexual dysfunction
A detailed patient history is important in the evaluation of male
sexual dysfunction as it can help suggest the underlying etiology and
narrow the scope of the required investigation for selecting an
appropriate modality of treatment. A thorough physical examination and
brief office-based investigation with assessment of PBI and real-time
penile tumescence may also be sufficient to corroborate the nature of
the problem and to suggest an etiological basis in most male patients
with sexual dysfunction. Once detailed history and physical examination
are completed, focus of the medical investigation can then be shifted
toward confirming the underlying pathophysiological abnormalities and
devising a treatment plan.
Patients with desire disorder, premature ejaculation, and/or
postejaculatory pain require a careful assessment of drug use, possible
underlying hypogonadism, or presence of psychological or psychiatric
conditions (Table 2
). Patients with HSD and absent or retarded emission
or anorgasmia may need to be evaluated for the presence of CNS disease.
Patients with prolonged or painful erection should be evaluated for the
possibility of primary penile disease, hematological disorder, or other
systemic diseases associated with penile complication, or the intake of
pharmacological agents or drugs of addiction that could potentially
cause failure of detumescence.
There remain the majority of patients with sexual dysfunction who present with problems related to erectile insufficiency. The availability of erectogenic agents such as oral sildenafil or intrapenile vasoactive drugs (e.g., PGE1) tempts many treating physicians to use them as a primary therapeutic modality without conducting any specialized investigations. Although this may be suitable for a significant fraction of patients with erectile insufficiency, potential complications from these modalities could be life threatening (in the case of sildenafil when taken together with nitrates), and the possibility of finding a potentially correctable disorder (e.g., psychosexual problem, hypogonadism, treatable chronic illness and/or correctable vascular insufficiency) indicate the need to perform the appropriate investigations. Such investigations are needed for patients at high risk for complications and those who may have experienced complications from the intake of these newly approved erectogenic agents (e.g., changes in vision on sildenafil, systemic symptoms from intraurethral prostaglandin, or penile priapism or fibrosis from intrapenile vasoactive injections) to establish the underlying pathophysiology, and hence to select the proper therapeutic interventions. However, before commencement of such detailed investigations, patients with a clear evidence of chronic organic disease should be evaluated and treated for their primary illness. Those on drug therapy that is likely to be responsible for their erectile problem should have their medications changed or discontinued for a trial period while assessing for the return of potency. Discontinuation of substance abuse before a full diagnostic workup is also required. The remaining group of patients in whom history and physical examination are not conclusive in identifying any specific etiology require an organized multidisciplinary approach involving psychological, endocrine, vascular, and neurological investigations to search for treatable etiological factors. The investigation may also help in counseling patients with uncorrectable etiologies such as microvascular disease or neurological deficits.
1. Psychological evaluations. All male patients presenting
with sexual dysfunction should be evaluated for psychological factors,
even in the presence of an obvious organic etiology. Conversely, the
presence of psychogenic conditions, such as anxiety, anger, guilt, or
marital discord, should not be construed as evidence for a sole primary
causation (101). Initial evaluation can be done by administering a
detailed sexual history questionnaire exploring current sexual
interactions, social and sexual discords, history of sexual abuse or
trauma, gender identity conflicts and preferences, state of mood and
affect, and cultural and religious influences. Such questionnaires are
helpful in identifying psychological contributions to erectile
dysfunction. The coexistence of more than one condition is a frequent
occurrence (97). A well structured psychosocial interview with the
patient alone, and if possible conjointly with his partner, should
follow the administration of any sexual questionnaire to ensure the
most complete understanding of all possible predisposing,
precipitating, and/or maintaining psychological factors. Features
differentiating predominantly psychogenic from predominantly organic
dysfunctions are summarized in Table 3
(67).
Several well established and validated self-administered psychosocial questionnaires have been developed and used to assess the frequency and nature of sexual dysfunction in men, and some have been used to assess the adequacy of response to therapeutic modalities. The questionnaires useful in clinical practice include the Derogatis Interview for Sexual Functioning-Self Report (DISF-SR) (198), International Index of Erectile Function (199), and Florida Sexual History Questionnaire (200). For research purposes, the Derogatis Sexual Functioning Inventory (DSFI) (201) and Leiden Erectile Dysfunction Questionnaire (202) are useful. A general criticism of these inventories is the small number of patient samples used to validate them. Other limitations include the lengthy time required for completion of the questionnaire and lack of accuracy in distinguishing psychogenic from organic causes of sexual dysfunction. They are, however, helpful in assessing the presence of problematic personality features, comorbid affective disorders, and situational factors that may be important in predisposing, precipitating, and/or maintaining the disordered sexual function.
2. Measurement of reproductive hormones. Patients with a
history of decreased libido, diminished secondary sexual
characteristics, developmental disorder, anosmia, headache, visual
disturbance, and drug ingestion, or patients with physical signs
consistent with hypogonadism or androgen resistance, such as abnormal
secondary sexual characteristics, decreased testicular size, or
abnormal testicular consistency, should have bioavailable serum
testosterone and LH measured. Figure 6
describes an algorithmic approach to the work-up and treatment of
patients with hypogonadism.
|
2%)
or includes the larger amount of albumin-bound hormone (2080%).
Recent investigations suggest that both free and albumin-bound
testosterone are biologically available (204). However, measurement of
total testosterone levels should be performed only if the patient is
free of conditions influencing serum SHBG and/or albumin concentration
or binding activities. The free testosterone level calculated from the
total testosterone level and the level of SHBG is an alternative
approach, and the correlations among this calculated index of
bioavailable testosterone and the measured free testosterone by
equilibrium dialysis are high (205).
Patients with primary hypogonadism may provide a history of orchitis or
exposure to radiation or toxins or may exhibit phenotypic signs of
inherited disorders. These patients will have high LH and low
bioavailable-testosterone concentrations (206). Patients with androgen
resistance will present with varying degrees of hypoplastic genitalia,
lack of secondary sexual characteristics, and/or gynecomastia and
feminization. Such conditions are heralded by an elevation in both
total (or bioavailable) testosterone and LH (206). In subtle cases of
androgen resistance, genital skin biopsy for assessment of receptor
number and enzyme activities (5
-reductase and 3
-ketoreductase)
may be required to establish the diagnosis (207).
Patients with secondary hypogonadism and some men with obesity,
advanced age, or reduced testosterone binding to carrying proteins may
have low total testosterone and LH serum concentrations (Fig. 6
) (61, 87, 88, 208, 209, 210). Aging is associated with an increase in SHBG and
consequently a greater reduction in bioavailable than in total
testosterone (87, 90, 92), whereas obesity and certain conditions of
abnormal binding proteins may be associated with more suppression in
total testosterone than in bioavailable or free testosterone (211).
Androgen replacement therapy is usually not required in conditions
associated with normal bioavailable or free but depressed total
testosterone. Serum PRL concentration differentiates between
hyperprolactinemia and other disorders of the hypothalamic-pituitary
axis. In the latter cases PRL is normal or low, but both testosterone
(total or non-SHBG-bound) and LH are usually below their respective
normal ranges. PRL concentrations in excess of 100 ng/ml are frequently
associated with PRL-producing adenomas, whereas lower concentrations
may be seen in drug-induced or in idiopathic hyperprolactinemia (206).
Other conditions of secondary hypogonadism are characterized by normal
or low serum PRL concentration. Further workup of these patients should
be directed toward identification of the primary site of deficiency
(pituitary vs. hypothalamus) since this may influence the
selection of treatment modality.
A recent study reviewed the reproductive hormone parameters in 508 men with sexual dysfunction (212). A normal free fraction of testosterone saved an unnecessary endocrine evaluation in 50% of patients with low total testosterone.
3. Investigation of structural abnormalities of the penis. Several techniques are available for evaluation of structural and functional integrity of the penile tissue. The following is a brief description of some of these experimental methods and their application.
a. Penile imaging.
Structural abnormalities of the penis can
be evaluated by a variety of methodologies based on the nature of the
suspected lesions. Peyronies disease and its effect on penile
vascular competence can be evaluated with color duplex sonography
(213). Arteriovenous malformations and lymphohemangiomas can be
assessed for lesion extent and involvement of adjacent structures with
MRI (145). MRI can also be used to assess for penile ruptures and tears
of the tunica albuginea (214).
b. Penile biopsy.
Percutaneous core biopsy, using 19- and
20-gauge coaxial automatic devices under local anesthesia, has been
developed as a safe and technically easy procedure to perform (215). In
addition, computerized image analysis techniques of smooth muscle and
elastic fibers of the corpus cavernosum tissue samples from normal and
impotent men have been developed.
Corporeal fibrosis may develop secondary to abnormalities in the regulation of normal collagen synthesis and degradation, most likely as a result of chronic ischemia (216). Changes in oxygen tension have been shown to affect human corpus cavernosum smooth muscle cell expression of TGF-ß1 and synthesis of PGE-1 (217). Oxygen tension consistent with blood PO2 observed in flaccidity (30 mm Hg) induce TGF-ß1 expression and suppress PGE-1 synthesis (217, 218). TGF-ß1 is a pleiotropic cytokine that induces connective tissue synthesis and inhibits growth of vascular smooth muscle cells (218), the two principal changes observed in corporeal fibrosis (129).
c. Cavernosal electrical activity.
Single potential analysis
of cavernous electrical (SPACE) activity has been measured in normal
subjects and in patients who had pelvic surgery (including
prostatectomy), spinal cord injury, and long-standing insulin-dependent
diabetes with presumed autonomic neuropathy, as well as smooth muscle
dysfunction (219). This study is done by placing two coaxial electrodes
into the corpora cavernosa, with the tip of one electrode being placed
centrally into each corporeal body. The neutral electrode is placed on
the body surface. The patient is allowed to rest to reduce
stress-induced sympathetic overtone, and single potential signals are
processed using electrophysiological instruments.
4. Penile tumescence monitoring. A variety of procedures are available to assess the involuntary, unconscious penile tumescence that occurs during the REM stage of sleep or the cognitively induced erection that occurs during the exposure to sensual (audio, audiovisual, or fantasy) and/or local tactile (penile vibration) sexual stimuli, which can be used to differentiate between organic and psychogenic erectile dysfunction. Monitoring of penile tumescence after intracorporeal injection of vasoactive drugs has also been used to assess the response to local pharmacological therapies. Changes in penile circumference can be measured in one (midshaft) or two (proximal to the glans and at the base of the penis) locations, using mercury strain gauges (75, 220), electronically controlled constrictive loops (218, 220, 221), Snap Gauges (Timm Medical Technologies, Eden Prairie, MN) consisting of pressure-sensitive plastic strips (222), or simple strips of postage stamps (223). Penile rigidity is assessed either directly using specially designed manual tonometers to measure the pressure required to "buckle" the penis (axial rigidity) (74), or indirectly using electronic dynamometers (224) or constrictive loops (cross-sectional rigidity) (221) during maximum tumescence. Penile rigidity can also be inferred from breakage of three plastic strips incorporated into the Snap Gauge device. The three elements break at degrees of tension corresponding to intracorporeal pressures of approximately 80, 100, and 120 mm Hg, respectively (76, 185, 222). Basic assumptions and limitations of each of these methods are described below.
a. Nocturnal penile tumescence (NPT) monitoring.
This
procedure evaluates the presence or absence of the involuntary
unconscious erections, which normally occur during the REM stages of
sleep, during 13 nights (74, 75, 76). Normal nocturnal tumescence has
been defined as a total night erection time greater than 90 min and an
increase in penis circumference in excess of 2 cm. A change in
circumference of 16 mm or 80% of a full erection is thought to reflect
a sufficient degree of penile rigidity for vaginal intromission (74, 185). Subsequently, a penile buckling pressure of 100 mm Hg using the
manual tonometer, or 100 Penrig (unit used for the electronic
dynamometer), was found to provide a more accurate assessment of the
degree of penile rigidity required for vaginal penetration than the
percentage change in circumference. A buckling pressure less than 60 mm
Hg is thought to be inadequate for vaginal penetration (74). Formal NPT
testing is performed in a sleep laboratory and includes monitoring the
penile circumference and axial rigidity at or near the time of maximum
tumescence, and should be reserved to investigate difficult cases,
e.g., males in whom psychological factors are strongly
suspected but in whom organic factors are questionable or the intake of
pharmacological agents are not identified. An electronic home
device (Rigiscan monitoring device, Timm Medical Technologies) (225)
has been developed to provide continuous recording of NPT and rigidity
(76, 221, 226). The system uses two loops, placed around the base and
tip of the penis proximal to the coronal sulcus, to measure penile
circumference in millimeters. Radial rigidity as measured by the
Rigiscan device was found to correlate with the axial rigidity as
measured by the buckling pressure, and both were related to the
intracorporeal pressure (76). Recently, Rigiscan data analysis
software, in which a 20% increase in base circumference lasting for 3
min or more is counted as an erectile event, has been described by
Levine and Lenting (76).
Very recently, a new electrobioimpedance device was used to determine the number and duration of erectile events and the percentage increase in penile blood venous changes during these events (227). The NEVA System (Urometrics, Inc., St. Paul, MN) consists of a small recording unit that attaches to the upper thigh, and three small adhesive electrode pads that are placed over the hip and on the penile base and glans. A constant nondetectable alternating current is delivered to the tissue, and a potential difference is then measured between the electrodes and converted to impedance. Since impedance changes with variation in blood flow, penile volumetric changes can be calculated from the changing measurement of impedance.
Several pitfalls associated with NPT monitoring, which limit the value of using this investigation as an initial screening test, have been discussed extensively by Levine and Lenting (76) and by Schiavi (228). These pitfalls include 1) the paucity of NPT norms for men older than 65 yr; 2) the lack of validation by an independent method other than NPT monitoring itself for the basic assumption underlying this investigation; 3) the lack of clear objective measures to relate the quality of sleep-associated penile erections to those occurring during usual sexual activity; 4) the presence of psychological factors (e.g., anxiety, depression, or loss of sexual desire) or dreams with anxiety content may influence the occurrence of NPT; 5) the first-night effect that may occur on the first night of sleep laboratory monitoring; 6) sleep abnormalities such as apnea, periodic leg movement, and nocturnal myoclonus can adversely influence the quality of NPT recording; 7) the identification of NPT events is dependent on the arbitrary criterion of the minimum erection time required for an erection episode; and 8) the formal sleep laboratory testing is very costly and involves waking the patient when he has 80% of a full erection to measure the buckling pressure of the penis.
b. Daytime penile tumescence monitoring.
Several adaptations
for NPT monitoring were described to reduce the cost of nocturnal sleep
laboratory testing and/or to improve the diagnostic efficiency of
tumescence monitoring. These include monitoring during the following:
1) morning naps preceded by modest sleep deprivation (229, 230); 2)
audio-visual and/or fantasy stimulation (231, 232, 233); 3) erectile
response to intracavernous vasoactive drug administration with or
without audio-visual enhancement (230); 4) pulse Doppler analysis of
penile arteries with audio-visual enhancement of the erectile response
(234, 235); 5) erotic audio-visual enhancement of the erectile response
to vibrotactile stimulation (236); and 6) affective and cognitive
response to erotic audio and fantasy stimulation (237). However,
several pitfalls of real-time tumescence and rigidity testing in its
present form exist and need to be addressed before a suitable
adaptation for general screening can be recommended. These include the
following: 1) real-time response to erotic stimuli may be adversely
influenced by the psychological factors underlying the dysfunction or
those related to the testing environment itself; 2) content of the
audio-visual material used may not be consistent with the subjects
preference, leading to a reduced or absent erectile response; and 3)
criteria for normal tumescence and rigidity response to real-time
erotic stimulation have not been established or validated.
A careful medical history and physical examination with basic
laboratory tests is currently the recommended initial investigation.
The availability of sildenafil may also provide an inexpensive and
practical first line of therapy, regardless of etiology, and preclude
the need to seek more elaborate testing for many males with erectile
dysfunction. However, this testing procedure could have a significant
role in evaluating some patients with sexual dysfunction, particularly
when psychological factors are suspected as the cause of the problem.
Such patients could initially be evaluated with either a Snap Gauge
band over 13 nights, daytime nap monitoring, or erotic
audio-visual/tactile/fantasy stimulation monitoring (Fig. 7
).
|
a. Pharmaco-penile duplex ultrasound (PPDU).
A duplex scanner
with color-flow imaging capability coupled with spectral-displaying
system and 7.5-mHz linear-array transducer is the optimal instrument
for performing this study (68, 69, 70, 146). Using B-mode ultrasonography
and color- image guidance, the device can assess the penile soft
tissue for the presence of structural abnormalities of the tunica
albuginea such as fibrous plaques or calcifications. It can also define
the arterial tree, measure the diameter of the cavernosal arteries, and
display the Doppler spectrum waveform of blood flow in the cavernosal
arteries. Figure 8
describes an
algorithmic approach to the interpretation of results of the PPDU
investigation.
|
Several pitfalls exist in the interpretation of data provided by the PPDU investigation (70, 146, 238). Some of these pitfalls may be eliminated by meticulous attention to technique, use of color Doppler scanning, and correlation of results with the degree of penile rigidity. Repeated vasoactive drug injections (239) or exposure to visual erotic stimuli may also help to induce complete relaxation of trabecular smooth muscle, and hence, reduce the overestimation of corporeal structural disease. Also, sufficient erectile response, as assessed by a self-reporting instrument (a postinvestigation questionnaire), may help to reduce the false-positive diagnosis of venoocclusive dysfunction by as much as 50% (240). Venoocclusive dysfunction due to smooth muscle dysfunction or venous incompetence can be ruled out using this approach.
b. Dynamic infusion cavernosometry and cavernosography (DICC).
This is a four-phase investigation in which corporeal body pressure at
equilibrium is determined after injection of vasoactive agents
(commonly 4560 mg papaverine and 12.5 mg phentolamine) into one
corpus cavernosum to relax the corporeal smooth muscles (phase I).
Cavernosometry is then performed by infusing the penis with heparinized
saline to raise the corporeal body pressure to 150 mm Hg and
observing the fall in pressure over 30 seconds after cessation of
infusion (phase II). Cavernosal artery systolic occlusion pressure is
measured from the reappearance of the Doppler signal in the cavernosal
artery during the decline in intracorporeal pressure following the
termination of saline infusion (phase III). Finally, cavernosography is
performed by infusing a radiocontrast material into the corporeal
tissue and obtaining radiographic images of the penis and perineum
(phase IV).
DICC is widely accepted as the reference diagnostic technique for evaluation of venoocclusive dysfunction (72, 73, 146). Intracavernous and systemic brachial blood pressure and penile circumference are monitored continuously throughout. Valid DICC testing is dependent upon a complete relaxation of penile smooth muscles with vasoactive drug administration. Failure to achieve such a state due to the patients anxiety, an inadequate dose of vasoactive agent(s), or intrinsic smooth muscle dysfunction may yield false-positive results. False-positive results can also occur with psychogenic erectile dysfunction and in normal controls.
At least two other variations of cavernosometry have been described, including pump and gravity cavernosometry (146). In the latter method, an intravenous infusion set is used instead of the pump, and complete corporeal smooth muscle relaxation is induced with local vasoactive drug(s) injections with or without audio-visual sexual stimulation. Gravity cavernosometry has been considered by several investigators to be more physiological, safer, and cheaper than DICC or pump cavernosometry.
c. Penile angiography.
This study is usually performed in
selected patients before reconstructive vascular surgery. These
patients are usually young men with a history of blunt perineal trauma
leading to a blockage at the origin of the cavernosal artery. Penile
arteriography is not indicated in older men due to low success rates
for penile revascularization among this population. Selective pudendal
angiography is helpful in defining the site of arterial block and thus
in planning the appropriate surgery (241). The sensitivity of
procedures for detecting arterial lesions is in the order of 95%. The
value of arteriography in microvascular disease is limited, as
microsurgical reconstruction is not always feasible. Further, the many
variations of arterial supply to the penis and lack of normative data
may make the interpretation of the study difficult. Lastly, anxiety
related to this procedure may lead to excessive adrenergic discharge
with arterial vasoconstriction and increased potential for
false-positive results.
d. Radionuclear scintigraphy.
Several radionuclear
scintigraphy techniques have been described in the last three
decades (see Refs. 242, 243 for review). Radionuclide techniques
can objectively measure the whole organ blood flow and continuously
monitor penile blood volume changes from flaccidity through various
phases of erection. Radionuclide techniques that continue to evolve
include dynamic penile scintigraphy and dual-radioisotope.
e. Cavernous oxygen tension.
Measurement of oxygen tension of
corporeal blood during flaccidity and during penile tumescence has been
suggested as a method for characterization of cavernous perfusion, and
thus corporeal vascular dysfunction. Aoki et al. (244)
reported a sudden increase in cavernous oxygen tension at the onset of
penile tumescence during visual sexual stimulation. Others (38) have
reported an increase in the corpus cavernosum oxygen tension from
2540 mm Hg in the flaccid state to 90100 mm Hg in the erect state
of the penis. More recently, Knispel and Andresen (245) correlated
changes in cavernous oxygen tension during PGE-1-induced penile
tumescence to peak systolic velocity (PSV) during Doppler
ultrasonography. They found some impotent men to have low cavernous
oxygen tension (measured by new, unbreakable, small-caliber
oxygen-sensitive probes, and defined arbitrarily as <65 mm Hg) despite
normal blood velocity (defined as >25 cm/sec). Thus, a decrease in
oxygen tension may occur as a result of arterial insufficiency and lead
to a decrease in trabecular smooth muscle dysfunction (decrease in
vascular smooth muscle cells and an increase in connective tissue
formation, leading to corporeal fibrosis) in some men with erectile
dysfunction. Such changes are probably mediated by an increase in
TGF-ß1 with a simultaneous decrease in PGE-1 concentrations in
corporeal tissue (see discussion in Section
IV.C.3.b).
6. Neurological investigations. A significant amount of research has been performed over the last few decades to define the role of neurological factors in the genesis of male sexual dysfunction. However, much of the earlier work was restricted to studies of the somatic innervation of the penis. Only recently has significant attention been directed to the role of autonomic disorders in the development of sexual dysfunction. Still, many of the newly developed investigative procedures provide only indirect evidence for the presence of autonomic disturbances, and therefore, these procedures may not accurately reflect the abnormality in autonomic nervous system control of the penis. Presence of autonomic dysfunction in organ systems such as the cardiovascular or urological may signal a similar abnormality in the erectile mechanism of the penis. However, most of the tests have not been adequately validated.
a. Somatic innervation of the penis.
The
somatic sensory innervation is important in the development and
maintenance of normal erection, and the somatic motor innervation plays
an important role in the control of ejaculation. The following provides
a brief summary of available methods for testing the integrity of these
innervations:
i. Vibration perception threshold (biothesiometry): The test provides a biothesiometric screening method for abnormality within the penile sensory afferent pathway. It is performed with a portable hand-held electromagnetic vibration device that has a fixed frequency and variable amplitude of vibrations (3, 197). The loss of, or an abnormal decrease in, vibratory sensation suggests the presence of a peripheral neuropathy.
ii. Dorsal nerve conduction velocity: A sensory deficit of the dorsal nerve may reduce the ability to sustain erections during coitus. The decrease in sensory transmission from the penis is also often associated with ejaculation difficulties (197). Since the penis is a distensible structure and the dorsal nerve of the penis is serpiginous at rest, gentle stretching with a one-pound weight is usually performed to straighten the coiled nerve and permit optimal and more accurate measurement of the conduction velocity (246).
iii. Bulbocavernosus reflex (sacral reflex arc) latency: Bulbocavernosus reflex latency testing determines the time interval required for a reflex arc that utilizes the dorsal penile/pudendal afferent pathway, the S2-S4 spinal cord segment, and the pudendal/perineal efferent pathway. The test may be helpful in documenting suspected sacral nerve root, cauda equina, or conus medullaris lesions (S2S4) caused by multiple sclerosis, spinal cord trauma, spinal cord tumors, and herniated intervertebral discs. Since parasympathetic sacral neurons are anatomically close to the central portion of the pudendal pathways, insults to the somatic innervation at these sites may also cause parasympathetic dysfunction (246). The diagnostic sensitivity of the bulbocavernosus reflex latency measurement has been compared with other testing procedures in several studies (247, 248).
iv. Pudendal nerve somatosensory (genitocerebral)-evoked potential: This test allows the evaluation of the peripheral and suprasacral afferent pathways by stimulating the pudendal nerve at the penis. The evoked waveforms are recorded at various sites within the CNS, but most typically over the conus medullaris and parietal cortex (3, 152). Patients with sacral lesions (distal to the sacral recording electrodes) caused by multiple sclerosis, spinal cord trauma, or tumor may demonstrate prolonged peripheral and total conduction times. However, patients with suprasacral lesions (cephalic to recording electrodes) caused by transverse myelitis, cervical disc disease, tumor, or trauma may have prolonged total conduction time and central conduction time, but normal peripheral conduction time (196). Further, performing both the bulbocavernosus and the pudendal nerve somatosensory-evoked potential testing may allow the evaluation of the different components of the pudendal nerve.
v. Perineal electromyography: The test identifies disturbances in pudendal motor pathways, which may be associated with metabolic or toxic disorders such as diabetes and alcoholism (152). Structural abnormalities of the perineal striated muscles also give rise to abnormal electromyographic recordings. The information obtained can help in assessing the presence of neuropathic defects, the ability to contract the bulbocavernosus muscle voluntarily, and the degree of motor-unit action potential recruitment during a bulbocavernosus reflex or cough (3).
b. Autonomic innervation.
As previously discussed, the
parasympathetic efferent pathways involve the spinal S2S4 segments
and pelvic nerve (Nervi Erigentes), and the sympathetic efferent
pathways involve spinal cord segment T12-L2 and the hypogastric nerve.
Many of the available autonomic testing procedures provide an indirect
measure of the functional state of the autonomic control of the
erectile function. However, autonomic parasympathetic [various forms
of cystometrography, heart rate variability, and pupillary light reflex
latency (249)], and autonomic sympathetic [pupil size adaptation,
histamine and acetylcholine skin tests (250, 251)] innervations hold
the promise for diagnosing various types of autonomic neuropathy that
contributes to erectile dysfunction.
| V. Treatment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
70%) (175). In addition, the course of therapy tends
to be more difficult (175) and the conventional sex therapy techniques
(e.g., sensate focus) have generally been inadequate (175, 181). As a result, many psychosexual therapists have adopted a more
flexible and individualistic approach to treatment. Others have
included cognitive-behavioral therapy, systems approach, script
modification, clinical hypnosis, guided fantasy exercises, and sexual
assertiveness training (181, 253). Cognitive-behavioral therapy
emphasizes the role of thought patterns and beliefs in perpetuating
maladaptive behavior and is useful when beliefs held by the patient or
couple about norms or responses are contributing to the sexual problem
(188). The "systems" approach, on the other hand, targets couple
dynamics and allows sex therapists to assess the extent of using sexual
dysfunction by the couple to maintain a "sexual equilibrium" within
the relationship (i.e., the way sexual dysfunction is used
to regulate intimacy or to allow the share of blame between partners
for the failure of the relationship) (254). Indicators of poor
treatment outcome include lack of spouse motivation, younger age, poor
quality of marital relationship, significant symbolic use of sexual
symptoms as a defense against the underlying conflict(s), presence of
homosexual tendencies, and the presence of major psychopathology and/or
hidden medical problems. Accurate diagnosis of desire inhibition, on
the other hand, was found to improve treatment outcome.
2. Drug therapy.
a. Hormone replacement.
Several studies have examined the
effect of androgen replacement on sexual responsiveness. Studies in
hypogonadal men have clearly demonstrated significant improvement in
libido factors (i.e., sexual motivation/interest) and
spontaneous erections with testosterone replacement even in the absence
of desire deficiency disorders (54, 255, 256, 257). However, the results of
androgen therapy of men with desire disorder without hypogonadism have
been limited and inconclusive (see Refs. 252, 253 for review).
Male sexual dysfunction caused by insufficient androgen levels can be treated by testosterone replacement therapy. Intramuscular injection of long-acting testosterone esters in oil has been the mainstay of androgen replacement therapy in the United States for decades. The two available preparations are testosterone enanthate (Delatestryl, BTG Pharmaceuticals, Iselin, NJ) and testosterone cypionate (Depo-Testosterone, Pharmacia & Upjohn, Peapack, NJ). Although achieved serum testosterone levels are not physiological (high values for several days after the injection and a decline to low values after 10 days), most males with sexual dysfunction obtain therapeutic effects following injection of 100 to 200 mg at 2- to 4-week intervals since administration of these agents every 4 weeks does not maintain serum testosterone levels within normal range for the entire 4 weeks. Hence, other longer-acting testosterone esters, such as testosterone buciclate and microencapsulated testosterone, which potentially could provide more physiological, long-lasting testosterone levels, continue to be evaluated.
Excessive androgen intake may cause a substantial rise in hematocrit levels, especially in men with chronic obstructive lung disease and heavy smokers. It also decreases the serum concentration of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol. Both of these complications could increase the risk for coronary artery disease. Another potential hazard of androgen therapy is the increase in serum prostatic specific antigen (PSA) levels and in prostate volume (see Ref. 258 for review). It is currently not known whether these changes are associated with an increased risk for prostate cancer, although several cases of prostate cancer have been diagnosed after initiation of exogenous testosterone treatment (259). It is important, therefore, that patients undergoing testosterone therapy have baseline rectal examination and baseline PSA measurement performed, and that both studies be repeated at regular intervals.
Testosterone may have a role in the treatment of male frailty with hypogonadism. With careful monitoring because of its potential risks, testosterone supplementation may be considered for improving specific physical and cognitive outcomes in this population.
b. Other pharmacological agents.
Other pharmacological
approaches have included the use of various centrally acting agents
(see Refs. 44, 106, 252, 260 for review). However, controlled
studies on the use of these agents in treatment of isolated HSD have
not been widely reported, and many of the currently available drugs are
not selective and can alter the neurotransmission of more than one
receptor type. Generally, administration of the dopamine agonists
apomorphine, bromocriptine, and pergolide, or the dopamine precursor
levodopa (44, 45, 48, 106, 261), have been associated with increased
libido. Cabergoline (Dostinex, Pharmacia & Upjohn) is a new long acting
dopamine agonist (262) that is expected to have a similar effect. Also,
the antidepressants bupropion and nomifensine have been shown to
increase libido in some studies (263). A noradrenergic mechanism of
action has been advanced to explain the libido-enhancing effect of
bupropion (260). Studies with the serotonergic agents trazodone (264),
venlafaxine (265), and fenfluramine (266) have also shown an increase
in sexual desire, and in the case of trazodone, there was no
correlation between the improvement in libido and the changes in mood.
Venlafaxine and its metabolite O-desmethylvenlafaxine are
potent inhibitors of norepinephrine and serotonin reuptake but weak
inhibitors of dopamine reuptake (267). More specific serotonergic
agents, however, are generally considered to have an inhibitory
neurotransmitting effect in the control of sexual drive (see Refs. 44, 106, 260 for review).
3. Other specific therapies.
It has been recognized
increasingly that men with primary CNS diseases such as partial
epilepsy (103, 268), Parkinsonism (104), poststroke (269), and
adreno-leukodystrophy (105) have diminished sexual arousal. Proper
counseling and rehabilitation of patients with strokes may lead to an
improvement in libido and other sexual disorders (269). Thus, although
desire disorders in primary CNS disease may be multifactorial in
pathogenesis, treating the primary CNS disease, by itself or in
conjunction with other treatment modalities, may well help to recover
the sexual libido.
B. Partial or complete erectile dysfunction
Treatment of male erectile dysfunction should be individualized
and in all instances directed at the identified etiologies (Tables 4
, 5
, and 6
).
The majority of patients do have systemic diseases and therefore should
receive effective treatment for their primary illness and proper
counseling regarding the causal relationship, if any, between the
underlying disease and the manifestation of erectile dysfunction. The
United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study Group (270) found that the
proportion of type 2 diabetic patients with impotence did not differ at
12 yr across intensive therapy and conventionally treated groups.
However, a more recent study has shown that hemoglobin A1c levels,
which measure long-term glycemic control, to be an independent
predictor of erectile function even after adjusting for peripheral
neuropathy in a group of type 2 diabetic males (271). In comparison
with men with good metabolic control, Fedele et al. (272)
found the odds ratios for erectile dysfunction were 1.7 and 2.3 in
diabetic men with fair and poor glycemic control, respectively.
Generation of superoxide anions and inactivation of NO are involved in
the pathophysiology (273).
|
|
1. Psychological and behavioral counseling. In the past,
behavioral and psychodynamic sex therapies and psychoanalysis have been
employed as the sole therapeutic intervention in patients with a
predominant psychogenic condition. More recently, however, many of
these psychological treatments were proposed as adjunct
therapeutic interventions together with specific medical treatment in
patients with predominant organic disease (274). Conversely, in certain
well chosen cases of psychogenic erectile dysfunction, medical
therapies (Table 4
) may effectively be used as an adjunct to sex
therapy. As discussed earlier, the psychological treatments comprise a
wide range of theoretical and practical approaches that have been
advocated and used (188, 252). However, there appear to be no clear-cut
differences among the different types of therapy, with most producing
positive results lasting for at least 6 months (275). Core elements of
the Masters-Johnson psychoeducational approach to sex therapy (276)
have been retained by many newer schools because of the higher
incidence of patient misinformation about sexual function (277).
Psychotherapy has been provided to the male patient alone or more
effectively to the couple. A young age of onset of sexual dysfunction
for the man, a young age of his partner, a shorter duration of the
relationship together, and not being married are all associated with a
higher acceptance of couple psychotherapy (278). Treatment of single
men frequently reveals intense performance anxiety that prevents them
from getting involved in intimate relationships (188). The cognitive
strategies are especially useful with single men because of their high
degree of dysfunctional attitude toward the problem, and because of
their willingness to accept a rational, informative approach without
focusing on feelings (279). Treatments that address the patients
interpersonal difficulties result in a significantly better outcome
than approaches that focus on problems in sexual functioning alone
(280). Recent evidence suggests that sexually dysfunctional couples are
generally more distressed than sexually satisfied couples, and the
sexually dysfunctional couples appear to address relationship conflicts
with somewhat polarized roles characterized with an "avoid
vs. engage" pattern (281). Thus, significant relationship
conflicts may require the adoption of more individualized treatment
approaches. Favorable treatment outcome is likely to depend upon many
factors, including absence of concurrent psychopathology, minimal
partner discord, willingness of partner to participate in therapy, high
motivation, short duration of impairment, and lack of gender identity
conflicts or homosexual tendencies. Psychosexual techniques that
include setting of realistic couple goals, periodic psychosexual
therapy follow-up, continual utilization of nonintercourse pleasuring
sessions, and initiating intimacy dates have been advocated as relapse
prevention strategies (282). Further, two recent studies suggested that
behavioral techniques such as pelvic floor muscle rehabilitation with
physical exercises and electrical stimulation may help in regaining the
erectile function in patients with and without venoocclusive disease
(283, 284). Physiotherapy may be particularly effective in treating
patients with venoocclusive disease due to dysfunctional corporeal
smooth muscle fibers, such as that due to sympathetic overtone.
Hypnosis, but not acupuncture, was also shown to be superior to placebo
in treating patients with sexual dysfunction and no detectable organic
etiology (284).
2. Drug therapy.
a. Systemic medications.
i. Reproductive hormones: Treatment of hypogonadism should depend upon
its etiology and whether or not fertility is desired. Several dopamine
agonists are currently available for treatment of patients with
hyperprolactinemia not caused by drug ingestion, including the widely
used relatively short-acting bromocriptine (Parlodel, Sandoz
Pharmaceuticals, East Hanover, NJ) (206), and the more recently
approved short-acting pergolide mesylate (Permax, Eli Lilly and Co.,
Indianapolis, IN) (285) and the long-acting cabergoline (Dostinex,
Pharmacia & Upjohn) (262) preparations. Patients with primary or
secondary hypogonadism should be treated with androgen replacement
except when fertility is desired (257, 286). Patients with pituitary
hypogonadism who desire fertility may be treated with gonadotropin
replacement (hCG-hMG) (287), whereas those with hypothalamic
hypogonadism may have the option of treatment with GnRH as well (288).
Patients with other endocrine dysfunctions should be treated for their
primary disease, as androgen therapy has no role in these conditions.
ii. cGMP PDE inhibitor: Sildenafil (Viagra) is a novel oral agent with selective inhibiting activity of PDE-isozyme-5, the major isozyme responsible for clearance of cGMP from human cavernous tissue (13). Such an effect potentiates erections during sexual stimulation. The overall efficacy of sildenafil, estimated from the responses obtained in more than 3,000 men who participated in clinical trials, is approximately 70%. Patients with diabetes mellitus (289) and some of those with neurological dysfunction (289), spinal cord injuries (290), prostatic surgery (291), and pelvic irradiation (292) may have lower response rates, between 35% and 67%. Several other studies have reported on the safety and efficacy of this agent in treating male erectile dysfunction (289, 290, 291, 292, 293, 294, 295, 296, 297). Safety and tolerability data from a series of double-blind, placebo-controlled studies and from 10 open-label extension studies of sildenafil in the treatment of erectile dysfunction were analyzed by Morales and colleagues (295). The most commonly reported adverse events were headache, flushing, dyspepsia, and priapism (298); however, the rate of drug discontinuation due to adverse effects was comparable to that of placebo (295).
Sildenafil has a potential for drug-drug interaction with nitrates and
NO donors and could cause a drop in systemic vascular resistance and
hypotension (299). For example, significant interaction has been
observed in clinical studies with a drop in systolic pressure >25 mm
Hg in subjects receiving sublingual glyceryl trinitrate (500 µg) and
sildenafil (25 mg, three times daily) (300). Physician-prescribing
guidelines issued by the American College of Cardiology/American Heart
Association (ACC/AHA) have recommended extreme caution with the use of
nitrates within 24 h of sildenafil ingestion and recommended that
sildenafil not be used within 24 h of taking a nitroglycerin
preparation; in addition this drug should not be used by men with
certain cardiovascular conditions, liver or kidney disease, and by
those taking medications that may prolong sildenafils half-life
(e.g., erythromycin or cimetidine) (301). Males with
known or suspected coronary artery disease may benefit from an exercise
test to determine whether resumption of sexual activity with use of
sildenafil is likely to be associated with an increased risk of
myocardial ischemia (301). However, retrospective analysis of the
concomitant use of antihypertensive medications (ß-blockers,
-blockers, diuretics, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, and
calcium antagonists) in patients taking sildenafil did not indicate an
increase in the reports of adverse events or significant episodes of
hypotension compared with patients treated with sildenafil alone (302).
Thus, the available data support the view that oral sildenafil
significantly improves erectile function and is well tolerated in
appropriate patients with erectile dysfunction and ischemic heart
disease who are not taking nitrate therapy (302).
Sexual activities are likely to be associated with increased cardiac risks in patients with ischemic heart disease due to the increase in cardiac work load, as reflected by the increase in heart rate and blood pressure. Analysis of the adverse events related to sildenafil use posted by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), as of early 1999, revealed that 70% of 128 patients in question had one or more risk factors for cardiovascular or cerebrovascular disease, including hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, cigarette smoking, diabetes mellitus, obesity, or previous cardiac history (298). Thus, caution should also be taken if sildenafil is to be used by patients with prior cardiac history or patients with one or more cardiac risk factors, and by those who are taking multiple antihypertensive medications (297). When appropriate, a symptom-limited maximal exercise electrocardiogram examination may be performed to predict patients at risk for ST segment depression during coitus (296). This cautious approach is warranted, particularly in view of the reported case of acute myocardial infarction that occurred 30 min after ingestion of sildenafil in a patient with no clear risk factors for ischemic heart disease (303).
Sildenafil also has a weak inhibiting effect on PDE-6 in the retina. Since long-term human data on retinal changes in patients receiving sildenafil is not yet available, caution is also recommended in prescribing this agent to patients with significant preexisting retinal abnormalities or inherited retinal disease such as retinitis pigmentosa.
Studies using other type 5 PDE inhibitors in animals (Zaprinast, Rhone Poulenc Rorer, France) (304) and humans (IC351/Cialis, Lilly-Icos LLC, Indianapolis, IN) (305) are appearing. Conclusions regarding the specificity and efficacy of these agents are currently awaited.
iii. Vasodilator agents: Although the interest in the use of vasoactive agents in management of erectile dysfunction has surged recently, evidence for the effectiveness of these agents in patients with etiologies other than psychological factors remains tenuous. With the exception of yohimbine most of the available studies were performed on a small number of patients, with ill-defined etiologies. The studies underscore the need for development of new selective receptor modulators. The following is a brief description of available agents.
Yohimbine: Yohimbine (e.g. Yocon, Palisades
Pharmaceuticals, Tenafly, NJ; Yohimex, Kramer Laboratories, Inc.,
Miami, FL ) is an indole alkaloid obtained from the bark of the
African tree, Pausinystalia yohimbine. Since it has an
-2
adrenoceptor blocking action, it was initially thought to facilitate
erectile function via a sympatholytic effect, similar to its chemical
relative reserpine. More recently, it was suggested that yohimbine
facilitates erections by blocking central
-2 adrenoceptors and
produces an increase in sympathetic drive and firing rate of neurons
within the brains noradrenergic nuclei (306). It has also been
suggested that yohimbine is active at other CNS receptors, including
some serotonergic and dopaminergic subtypes (306). However, several new
studies (see Ref. 307 for review) have shown yohimbine to induce a rise
in blood pressure and plasma norepinephrine, suggesting that it also
exerts peripheral adrenergic actions. Placebo-controlled studies have
suggested the effectiveness of yohimbine (usually in doses of 4.5 to 6
mg three times daily) in treating erectile insufficiency due to
psychogenic or mild organic etiology. The return of complete or partial
erections in these studies ranges from 3371% (308). A recent
meta-analysis study of seven therapeutic trials with yohimbine found it
to be superior to placebo in treatment of erectile dysfunction (309).
However, poor therapeutic effects of yohimbine were reported in several
other studies, particularly in patients with clear organic etiology
(310, 311). The combination of yohimbine with other agents such as
trazodone produced higher response rates in patients with psychogenic
impotence, with 56% of patients continuing to draw clinical benefit
after 6 months of treatment (312). Delquamine is another new agent with
a selective
-2 adrenoceptor antagonist property that shows promising
therapeutic effects in treating impotence. It is currently undergoing
evaluation in multicenter trials (313).
Phentolamine: Phentolamine (Vasomax) induces relaxation of corpus
cavernosum erectile tissue by direct antagonism of both
-1 and
-2
adrenergic receptors and by indirect functional antagonism via a
nonadrenergic, endothelium-mediated effect, possibly through NO
synthesis activation (314). To date, phentolamine has been used mainly
as an adjuvant to other intracavernous vasoactive agents (see below).
However, recent limited studies have suggested the possibility of its
oral or sublingual use for management of erectile insufficiency.
Systemic administration of phentolamine may exert a central antianxiety
effect in addition to the local vasodilatation effect on the corpus
cavernosum. Alcohol abolishes the effect of buccal administration of
this agent, which should also be avoided in patients with severe
ischemic heart disease (306).
Isoxsuprine: Isoxsuprine (Vasodilan, Geneva Pharmaceuticals, Broomfield, CO) is a ß-2 adrenoceptor agonist that causes vasodilatation by direct stimulation of vascular smooth muscle. It is commonly used as an adjuvant therapy for patients with peripheral vascular disease. Further studies are needed to clarify the role of agents with ß-2 receptor stimulation properties in the treatment of male erectile dysfunction.
Pentoxifylline: Pentoxifylline (Trental, Hoechst-Roussel, Somerville, NJ) is a xanthine derivative agent that is widely used in management of intermittent claudication. Pentoxifylline has two major therapeutic effects: an increase in flexibility of red blood cells and a vasodilatation property. Korenman and Viosca (315) used oral pentoxifylline (400 mg three times daily) in a double-blind placebo-controlled study of 18 impotent men with mild to moderate penile vascular insufficiency. Fourteen men were able to reestablish the erectile function on pentoxifylline therapy. Further, the majority of patients had significant improvement in penile-brachial index. Patients with advanced diabetes mellitus, however, did not respond to pentoxifylline.
Other agents: Limited new studies have attempted the use of an oral PGE-1 derivative (Limaprost, Ono Pharmaceuticals, Japan) (316), and the NO donor L-arginine (317) to treat patients with erectile insufficiency with a subjective response rate ranging from 3045%. In a study examining the effect of dietary supplementation of L-arginine on penile erection and penile NOS content and activity in the aging rat, serum and penile levels of L-arginine were found to increase by 64148% in treated animals as compared with controls.
A number of herbal remedies have been used by native healers, mostly in Eastern countries, as oral treatment for erectile dysfunction and have recently been reviewed (318). Placebo- controlled clinical trials examining the efficacy and safety of these agents are currently scarce, and much of the available evidence is unsubstantiated. Careful scientific studies examining the safety and efficacy of these naturally occurring remedies in animals and human subjects must be performed and evaluated before the use of any agent can be accepted.
iv. Centrally acting drugs: The use of centrally acting agents to target specific neuronal centers responsible for regulation of the erectile function provides an attractive therapeutic option, particularly for treating patients without local vascular disease or significant peripheral neuropathy. However, the studies are hampered by the lack of clear identification of the various receptor subtypes participating in regulation of erectile function, the relative contribution of each to the overall functional mechanisms, agent selectivity for the receptor subtypes, and the small number of patients involved in the reported studies. The following is a brief summary of recently described agents.
Trazodone: Trazodone (Desyrel, Mead Johnson Pharmaceuticals,
Evansville, IN) is a triazolopyridine derivative that influences
-adrenergic, dopaminergic, and serotonergic functions and indirectly
stimulates corporeal smooth muscle relaxation. Its therapeutic use for
management of erectile function remains controversial, since two recent
controlled studies have failed to show a significant improvement in
erectile function above that of placebo (319, 320). A retrospective
study, however, suggested that trazodone produces significant
improvement in the erectile ability in 78% of patients less than 60 yr
of age who have no known risk factors for erectile dysfunction. It is
likely that major therapeutic effects of trazodone on libido and
erectile function is mediated by a central effect through inhibition of
serotonin reuptake and an increase in serotonin stimulation of 5-HT-1c
receptor (321). This appears to be at variance with the loss of libido
induced by serotonin interaction with other receptor subtypes (322).
Additional evidence suggests that trazodone may aid erectile function
through
-adrenoceptor blockade and the subsequent reduction in the
sympathetic tone (323). Improved libido, improved erectile function,
prolonged erection, and priapism have been reported in about 200
patients who were treated for depression with trazodone (323, 324). As
a single agent, it may restore erectile function in up to 60% of
patients and is superior to placebo (325). A simultaneous use of
trazodone with yohimbine has been advocated by some (312, 313).
Apomorphine: Apomorphine (Spontane/Uprima, TAP Pharmaceuticals, Deerfield, IL) alkaloids are naturally occurring dopaminergic agonists that may have been responsible for the psychotropic effects of waterlily tubers reported by the ancient Egyptians and the Maya (306). When administered subcutaneously, apomorphine induces bouts of yawning and penile erection in animals and humans (313). It has been used clinically to induce emesis, sedation, and more recently to treat refractory on-off oscillations in Parkinsons disease. In some of these instances a significant improvement in the erectile function was noted (326). Its effects on sexual function appear to be due to central dopaminergic activities that lower the response threshold for erectile and ejaculatory reflexes (306) and, at least in rats, are mediated by the sacral parasympathetic and thoracolumbar sympathetic pathways (327). Administration of apomorphine (0.25 to 1.0 mg sc) in placebo-controlled studies was shown to induce erection in approximately 60% of men with psychogenic impotence (328). Its effect on erectile function may be potentiated by visual sexual stimulation (329). A new sublingual controlled absorption preparation of apomorphine (at doses of 3 and 4 mg) was shown to induce erection in about 65% of a small sample of 12 patients with erectile insufficiency not due to organic etiologies (330). Bromocriptine, a dopamine receptor agonist, may offer another therapeutic modality for apomorphine-responsive men (331).
Naltrexone: Naltrexone (ReVia, DuPont Pharmaceuticals Co., Wilmington, DE) is a long-acting opiate antagonist. Naltrexone (2550 mg daily) was reported to produce a full return of erectile function in six patients (332). Further, in two other placebo-controlled studies, naltrexone (50 mg daily) was shown to increase the frequency of morning erection and successful coital attempts (333) and to completely restore the erectile function in 20% of patients (334). The combination of opioid receptor blockade with yohimbine may increase the rate of return of erectile function over that obtained with the use of opiate antagonists alone (335).
Fluoxetine: Fluoxetine (Prozac, Dista Products Co., Indianapolis, IN) is a highly selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor that produces sexual side effects in up to 16% of patients receiving the agent for treatment of depression (336). However, case reports of priapism have been reported with the use of fluoxetine. Mechanisms proposed to explain the conflicting sexual stimulation and inhibition effects of fluoxetine and other SSRIs include selective blockade of 5-HT receptor subtypes, partial agonist/antagonist neurotransmission, and/or receptor down-regulation with subsequent activation of central serotonin release (306). As a significant lengthening of the ejaculatory reflex is commonly seen with SSRIs, these agents are better suited for treatment of premature ejaculation (see below).
b. Local vasoactive agents.
i. Intracavernous injections: Intracavernous injection therapy of male
erectile dysfunction with vasoactive agents has recently been
extensively reviewed (306, 322, 326, 337, 338). The following is a
brief summary of the pharmacological effects and the reported clinical
experience with these agents (also see Table 5
).
Papaverine: Papaverine is an opium alkaloid without the clinically recognized narcotic effects. It has a direct relaxing effect on smooth muscle tone via the nonselective inhibition of cyclic nucleotide PDEs, which results in the accumulation of cAMP and cGMP (339). It also blocks the voltage-dependent calcium channels, reduces calcium influx, and inhibits the release of intracellular calcium stores. These effects may directly relax the corporeal arterioles, sinusoids, and veins (322, 337). Papaverine is acidic in solution (may precipitate at pH >5), is slowly cleared from the corporeal tissue, has a plasma half-life of 12 h, and is metabolized by the liver (337). Injections of papaverine alone produce a full erection in about 3557% of patients, depending on dose used and the underlying pathology (see Ref. 337 for review). Papaverine has been used at doses ranging from 3 mg to more than 100 mg, with the onset of response occurring at 10 min to 30 min, and the duration of erection ranging from 30 min to more than 240 min. Patients with underlying arterial disease tend to require higher doses and have a low rate of erectile response. In contrast, patients with neurological disease require small amounts and experience a more lasting response, on occasion requiring corporeal drainage (159, 161, 340).
Side effects associated with papaverine injections are both systemic and local (322, 337). Systemic effects may include peripheral vasodilatation, hypotension, reflex tachycardia, and elevation in liver enzymes. Hemodynamic complications may be more pronounced in patients with venoocclusive dysfunction and are reported to occur in 1% to 8% of patients. Local adverse effects include fibrosis and priapism. Fibrosis occurs in up to 20% of patients and is thought to result from repeated local shear trauma or repeated chemical injury from the low pH of injected solution. Priapism has been reported with more frequency in patients with neurological or psychological etiologies than in patients with vasculogenic impotence. In addition, papaverine-induced erection was found to decrease penile sensitivity as assessed by the perception of vibratory tactile stimulation at two different locations on the underside of the penis (341). Since many of these patients have reduced penile sensitivity at base line (possibly subsequent to neuropathy), intracavernous papaverine injection may augment such an abnormality.
PGE-1: PGE-1 (alprostadil) is a metabolite of arachidonic acid and is
found in high concentrations in the seminal vesicle and seminal plasma.
Injectable PGE-1 is available as a sterile solution (Prostin VR
Pediatric, The Upjohn Co., Kalamazoo, MI) or as sterile powder
(Caverject, Pharmacia & Upjohn; and Edex/Viridal, Schwarz Pharma, Inc.,
Milwaukee, WI) (342). Only the latter formulation is currently
FDA-approved for management of erectile dysfunction. It is available in
10-, 20-, and 40-µg dose-level packaging. PGE-1 is a potent smooth
muscle relaxant and vasodilator in man. It also has an
-2 adrenergic
blocking effect and hence has the potential of reducing sympathetic
overtone in patients with psychogenic erectile dysfunction. Local
metabolism of PGE-1 within the corporeal tissue has also been suggested
(343). Systemic blood levels of PGE-1 and its metabolites are
significantly lower between 7 and 20 min after its intracavernous
injection in patients who exhibit an erection as compared with those
who do not (344), suggesting that retention of PGE-1 and its
metabolites within the corporeal tissue is an important factor in the
development of erectile response. The overall erectile response to
prostaglandin intracorporeal injections is about 70% (345). Pain is
the most common side effect, occurring in 1380% of patients and is
dose-related. Possible causes of pain include high acidity of solution,
local secretion of other vasoactive substances, and/or direct
activation of pain receptors by PGE-1 (306). Reduction in the
perception of pain could be achieved by adding 7.5% sodium bicarbonate
or procaine 20 mg to the injected solution (346, 347), and by slow
administration (348). Other side effects associated with PGE-1
injections include local corporeal hematoma or ecchymosis (8%),
prolonged erection to between 4 and 6 h (5%), priapism of greater
than 6 h (1%), penile edema (2%), and fibrosis (2.3%) (349).
Long-term efficacy and safety of PGE-1 intracavernous self-injection were determined in several studies (350, 351, 352). The rate of dropout from treatment was 47% after 3 yr (351) and 67% after 4 yr (350). Patient satisfaction with their erection increased from approximately 23% without injections (351) to 6791% with injections (351, 352). Reported side effects in one 4-yr study (352) were as follows: prolonged erection >6 h occurring during the first year in 1.2% of subjects; penile pain caused by the injected agent in 29% of subjects during year 1, declining to 12.1% by year 4; hematomas in 33.3% of subjects in year 1 that also declined to 12.1% by year 4; and fibrotic penile alteration (nodules, plaques, deviations) in 11.7% of subjects with spontaneous healing in 48%.
Phentolamine: Phentolamine is an
-1 and
-2 adrenoceptor blocker.
It has a weak erectile-promoting effect when used alone. However, when
used in combination with papaverine and/or PGE-1, it potentiates their
erectile effects (353, 354, 355). By blocking the
-receptors,
phentolamine helps to reduce the vasoconstrictive effects of the
sympathetic innervation of the corporeal arteries, and thereby aids in
the erectile response. Adverse effects related to its use include
orthostatic hypotension and tachycardia.
NO donors: Linsidomine (SIN-1) is a metabolite of the antianginal drug molsidomine and acts by releasing NO from the endothelial cells nonenzymatically. It also hyperpolarizes the cell membrane through influencing the sodium-potassium pump and thereby rendering it less responsive to adrenergic stimulation (322). Linsidomine injection at a dose of 1 mg produces usable erection in about 70% of patients (356) and full erection in up to 50% of patients (357). Linsidomine does not appear to be associated with priapism (306).
Other agents and vasoactive drug mixtures: Administration of moxisylyte
(Mox or Thymoxamine, a competitive postsynaptic
-1
receptor-selective antagonist), has been shown to produce an adequate
erection in 85% of patients, with very low incidence of side effects
(358). In comparative studies, PGE-1 was shown to be more effective in
producing full penile rigidity than moxisylyte. Very recently,
nitrosylated
-adrenergic receptor antagonists,
SNO-moxisylyte (NMI-221) and SNO-yohimbine (NMI-187),
were shown to relax endothelin-induced contraction of human and rabbit
corpus cavernosum strips in organ chambers to a greater extent than
their respective parent compounds (359). Thus, nitrosylated
-adrenergic receptor antagonists may have a therapeutic role in the
treatment of erectile dysfunction by acting as NO donors as well as
-receptor blockers (359).
VIP is a potent vasodilator and smooth muscle relaxant. However, its injection as monotherapy in man was not shown to produce adequate erection (340). Combined VIP and phentolamine preparations (e.g., Invicorp, formerly known as Vasopotin, Senetek PLC, Napa, CA) have recently been shown to produce a response rate ranging from 66.5% to 75% compared with 1218% for placebo.
CGRP leads to cavernous smooth muscle relaxation and penile erection (306, 360). It has been used as an addition to other vasoactive agents, such as PGE-1, to treat patients not responding to a papaverine-phentolamine combination (360).
Trazodone is an antidepressant associated with priapism as a side
effect (324). Intracorporeal administration of trazodone was shown,
like other
-blocking agents, to be much less effective in initiating
penile erections than direct smooth muscle relaxants (361).
The mixture of papaverine with phentolamine has been extensively used to induce therapeutic erection since 1985 (362). It has been shown to be superior to papaverine alone in inducing erection (65% vs. 36%), particularly in geriatric patients (363) and in those with organic dysfunction (362). However, both of these populations tend to require larger quantities (50% or more) of these vasoactive agents than the younger population or those with psychogenic or neurogenic impotence (see Refs. 322, 337 for review).
Another popular mixture of vasoactive drugs includes papaverine (1530 mg/ml), phentolamine (0.55.0 mg/ml), and PGE-1 (8.33500 µg/ml) and is used in quantities ranging from 0.1 ml to 0.75 ml per injection. In some instances, atropine (3 mg/ml) and/or normal saline (up to 2.4 ml) is added to the tri-mixture (306, 322, 337, 364, 365). The clinical efficacy of the tri-mixture has been documented in several studies. For example, Goldstein and colleagues (365) used a mixture of papaverine, 22.5 mg/ml, phentolamine, 0.83 mg/ml, and PGE-1, 8.33 µg/ml, to salvage 62% of nonresponders to either PGE-1 monotherapy or therapy with a mixture of papaverine and phentolamine. Several other studies showed rates of response ranging from 6692% (see Refs. 306, 322, 337 for review). Lower incidence of prolonged erection was also reported for the tri-mixture as compared with papaverine alone, papaverine-phentolamine combination, but not for PGE-1 monotherapy.
Several other complications have been reported in patients receiving intracavernous vasoactive drugs. Fibrotic nodules seem to occur more frequently with papaverine monotherapy [5.4% of 1,573 patients from different series reviewed by Junemann and Alken (340)] than with PGE-1 [ranging from occasional cases of Peyronies-like plaque in up to 3% (366), and Upjohn Co.], or with the tri-mixture [none to 4.2% (367, 368)]. Higher incidence of nodules with increasing duration of therapy with any vasoactive agent has also been suggested (364). The trauma from the repeated administration of vasoactive drugs is more likely to be responsible for the local fibrotic reaction of the tunica albuginea than the drug causing a generalized corporeal fibrotic effect (337). Other rare complications of intracavernous vasoactive injections include local infections (369), hepatotoxicity with the use of papaverine/phentolamine mix in patients with history of alcohol abuse (370), penile shaft hypopigmentation with the use of PGE-1 (371), and accidental breakage of needles in the penile shaft (372).
Home therapy programs of intracavernous vasoactive drugs require careful patient education and training on the use of the lowest effective dose. The latter should be determined by the treating physician and allied in a careful dose titration investigation. Of patients who start on a home-injection therapy program, only 5080% continue to use it long-term. Frequently cited reasons for the dropout include loss of efficacy, loss of interest, fear of complications, lack of sexual spontaneity, resumption of spontaneous erections, and favoring other forms of therapy (337, 338). The most likely cause for the resumption of spontaneous erection is the resolution of performance anxiety. In addition, an increase in arterial peak flow velocity may occur in some patients (373).
Several other agents were evaluated for local induction of penile
erection either alone or with one or more of the well established
drugs. These agents include atropine (374), adenosine (375), enprodyl
tartrate [available in France as a separate agent or as a mixture with
papaverine under the trade name Vadilex (376)], and
-melanocyte
stimulating hormone analog (377). Additional data on the efficacy and
safety of these compounds are currently awaited.
Two new, rather unusual, permanent delivery systems for intracavernous vasoactive drug therapy have been described. In the first, a small cannula is surgically inserted at the penile scrotal junction into the corporeal tissue, and a connected reservoir is placed in a small pouch between the testes. The reservoir is filled with a mixture of phentolamine and verapamil. The system was implanted in eight patients with organic impotence and was reported to be functional in all patients after an average follow-up duration of 13.3 months. In the second system, a 1-cm square window is created in Bucks fascia and tunica albuginea and covered with a piece of the deep dorsal vein of the penis. The penile skin overlying the window is marked with India ink and the patient is instructed to apply the vasoactive drug (nitroglycerin) to this area.
ii. Topical applications: The success in treating erectile dysfunction with intracavernous injection of vasoactive drugs has generated high interest in topical application of these substances. Vasodilating agents used include nitrates (nitroglycerin, isosorbide dinitrate), PGE-1, papaverine, minoxidil, aminophylline, and co-dergocrine (378, 379, 380, 381, 382, 383, 384). In general, achieving a functional erection with topical application of these agents has been limited, with more success in patients with psychogenic and neurogenic disorders than in those with vascular problems. Topical application of nitroglycerin has been reviewed by Anderson and Seifert (382). Reported data on the topical application of PGE-1 are limited (306, 385, 386). Kim and colleagues (380) examined the efficacy of 15% and 20% papaverine base gel applied to the scrotum, perineum, and penis in 20 men with organic impotence in a placebo-controlled nonblind study. Full clinical erection was observed in only 3 of 17 patients with mean duration of 38.7 min. The same patients developed erection after topical application of placebo, but with a mean duration of 8.0 min.
Major side effects reported by the patient and/or his sexual partner with the topical application of vasoactive agents include headache and a drop in blood pressure and heart rate. Several precautionary measures are suggested to reduce the incidence of such adverse effects, including careful selection of patients and treatment agents, limiting the topical application to 26 h before intercourse, intake of acetaminophen before the topical application, use of latex condom to protect the partner (see Ref. 382 for review).
iii. Urethral applications: Both PGE-1 (alprostadil) and PGE-2 (dinoprostone) are used as intraurethral treatments of erectile insufficiency. Transurethral alprostadil (MUSE, Vivus, Inc., Mountain View, CA) treatment of men with erectile dysfunction is approved in the United States. The observation that approximately one-third of patients responding to transurethral PGE-1 in clinical setting fail to do so at home has been consistent among many studies (387, 388). When accounting for this, the overall in-home response rate for transurethral PGE-1 use is approximately 40%. Moreover, at least two studies have reported even more disappointing results with transurethral PGE-1 (389, 390).
3. Nonsurgical devices.
a. Vacuum pump.
The first vacuum erection device was patented
in 1917 and, with some minor modifications, still remains the prototype
(391). The device usually consists of a wide clear plastic barrel that
is placed around the penis and sealed against the pubic region. Air in
the barrel is then vacuumed with the aid of a manual or a
battery-operated pump attached to its free end. The vacuum causes
expansion of the penis and reduction in the pressure within the
cavernous sinusoidal spaces. With increased negative pressure within
the barrel, penile blood inflow increases and the erect-rigid state is
attained. Maintenance of the latter state is achieved by placing a
constrictive rubber band at the base of the penis (some constrictive
rings such as the "Soft Touch" by Mission need to be mounted first
in advance of vacuuming). Vacuum is then released and the barrel is
removed. Most devices incorporate a safety valve to prevent creation of
high negative pressure, and consequently penile injury. Duration of
erections induced by this method should not be extended beyond 30 min
because of the development of ischemia. Generally, these devices are
used as a noninvasive method of treatment for patients with vascular
and/or neurological erectile dysfunction. Table 6
summarizes the
advantages and disadvantages of these and other erection-enhancement
therapies.
Several follow-up studies have attempted to evaluate the efficacy and the acceptability of this method of therapy for erectile dysfunction (392). The vacuum constrictive device was found to be particularly effective in patients with partial impotence (392). A few other follow-up studies corroborated these results and suggest a stable use of the device by more than 60% of patients who are able to apply it successfully (392, 393). Thus, the vacuum device is likely to be an effective treatment for erectile dysfunction in the majority of appropriately selected patients.
b. Constrictive ring.
The few medical devices available are
usually sold as part of the vacuum device kit. Intuitively, the
constrictive ring is likely to be the only external device needed for
management of erectile dysfunction in patients with mild to moderate
venous leakage and no coexisting significant arterial insufficiency.
Under adequate sexual arousal, such patients should have enough penile
arterial inflow to achieve the erect state. As expected, however, the
erection is not maintained due to lack of venous occlusion and the
decline in the high arterial inflow associated with the initial phases
of the erectile cycle. Thus, simple constriction of venous return after
attainment of full penile erection may be all that is needed to treat a
significant number of men with isolated venoocclusive dysfunction. Of
available medical devices, two rings deserve noting: the "Soft
Touch" ring from Mission Pharmacal Co. (San Antonio, TX), and the
"Pressure Point" ring from Osbon (Augusta, GA). The "Soft
Touch" ring consists of a rubber plate with a narrow central neck
protruding vertically approximately 0.5 inch. Using an application
cone, the plate is placed against the males body with the projecting
neck portion wrapping around the base of the penis. The plate
facilitates the removal of the ring without entangling the pubic hair.
The "Pressure Point" rubber ring, on the other hand, includes a
V-shaped section on the ventral segment to reduce the obstruction to
flow of semen in the urethra. In addition, the ring incorporates two
internally protruding portions at the dorsolateral junctions to exert
more focal pressure at these locations and consequently restrict the
venous outflow more efficiently.
Pervasive influence of shame and demoralization regarding erectile problems rather than the ineffectiveness of treatment can be a major cause for the failure of these therapeutic methods. Thus, careful, explicit, extensive, and concrete explanations and instructions of treatment options must be given to the patient at the time of treatment selection. In addition, patient education and training must be reinforced during several follow-up visits if these or any similar methods of treatment are to succeed.
4. Surgical treatment.
a. Arterial revascularization.
About 40% of patients with
impotence have evidence of abnormal arterial flow, and approximately
12% of these may have aortoiliac disease due either to aneurysms or
occlusive disease (394). Generally, these conditions are amenable to
surgical correction, and about 60% of these patients recover
spontaneous erectile function postoperatively (394). Most men with
major vessel disease, however, rarely present with impotence.
Conversely, the majority of impotent patients with arterial disease
have pathological changes in the small vessels of the penis.
Technically, the corrective surgeries for such smaller vessels are
challenging and reported outcome varies significantly (Table 6
).
Several recent reviews have indicated that the success of these
operations depends upon correct patient selection as well as on correct
choice of the operative technique (395, 396). Patients younger than 50
yr, with no history of diabetes, with less than two risk factors for
atherosclerosis, and who are not tobacco users are more likely to have
a higher rate of successful outcome (397). Complications of penile
revascularization surgery include pain, altered sensation, shortening
of penile length, glans hyperemia, and graft failure (396). The NIH
Consensus Development Conference on Impotence, held in 1992,
recommended that surgical revascularization of the penis be considered
experimental and be performed only by expert surgeons and as part of
clinical investigation (96).
b. Venous ligation.
Initial recovery of erectile function
(successful intercourse without adjunctive therapies) within the first
6 months of the surgery has been reported in 60% to 70% of patients
(398, 399, 400, 401, 402, 403, 404, 405, 406, 407, 408, 409). However, the long-term success rate of penile vein ligation
is poor, with only about 20% of patients able to have normal
intercourse more than 1 yr after surgery (410). Patients with distal
penile shaft leakage (402), younger age, and lack of concomitant
arterial disease or significant crural leak appear to have a higher
rate of lasting recovery (405). Thus, the recurrence is unacceptably
high and occurs mostly within the first 24 months of surgery. This has
led many investigators to conclude that psychological factors and not
significant hemodynamic changes are responsible for much of the initial
improvement reported after the venous ligation (395). Complications of
this procedure include shortening of the penis, penile deviation, glans
numbness, and wound infection. More thorough attention to the presence
of functional venoocclusive disease and the use of other therapeutic
modalities such as psychosexual counseling, pelvic-floor exercises,
constrictive ring, and vasoactive drugs should be considered in
managing patients with venous dysfunction.
c. Repair of penile structural abnormalities and augmentation
phalloplasty.
Common congenital structural anomalies of the penis
include micropenis, hypo- and epispadias, and penile curvature (395).
Micropenis and hypo- and epispadias are usually corrected with a
penile-lengthening operation. In addition to infection and other common
surgical complications, penile lengthening procedures have the
potential for several specific problems, including recurrent penile
shortening related to reattachment of ligaments; a hump deformity of
genitalia due to advancement of the thick hair-bearing lower abdominal
skin onto the dorsal shaft; injury to the corporeal bodies or the
neurovascular bundle; loss of penile elevation during erection; and
patient disappointment due to unrealistic expectations (411).
Webbing of skin at the penoscrotal junction can be congenital or may occur as a result of overresection of the ventral skin during circumcision. The web can be removed by performing a Z-plasty or V-Y advancement at the penoscrotal junction (411). Likewise, penile swelling due to lymphedema can occur with or without an associated lymphatic disorder of the lower extremities. Surgical excision of the lymphedematous tissue may be beneficial if treatment of the underlying cause is not successful in resolving the condition (395).
Penile curvature occurs as a result of the presence of congenital anomalies such as chordee, disproportionate length or elasticity of the tunica albuginea, short urethra, or subsequent to an acquired disorder such as Peyronies disease or phimosis. Surgical removal of ellipsoid segments (Nesbit), removal of diamond-shaped segments (Nesbit-Kalami), double cross-over (plication), and horizontal closure of longitudinal incision (incisional) are some of the corporoplasty procedures used to correct penile curvature (412, 413). Lengthening of the shortened penis caused by Peyronies disease using venous grafting and daily stretching with a vacuum erection device has recently been reported in four patients (414). Phimosis is usually adequately treated with circumcision regardless of the age of the patients.
Phalloplasty to increase the penile girth has been attempted by either
injecting deposits of fat cells (obtained by liposuction) in the space
between dartos fascia (the most superficial fascial layer) and Bucks
fascia (a deeper, dense fascial sheath that anchors the penis to the
symphysis pubis), or more effectively by inserting dermal-fat graft
strips directly above the tunica albuginea (see Ref. 411 for review).
Fat cell injection is associated with uneven aggregation and lipolysis,
frequently with only 30% of injected fat surviving after 1 yr.
Dermal-fat grafts are more lengthy procedures but have the
potential of producing a more lasting effect, frequently with
circumference increase of 1 to 2 inches (Table 6
).
d. Phallic reinnervation.
The development of microsurgical
techniques and free tissue transfers hold the promise of success for
phallic reinnervation. At present this procedure is performed mainly as
a part of the total phallic reconstruction in patients with severe
micropenis, penile trauma, or those transsexuals undergoing
female-to-male conversion (415). In these procedures, the major
sensory nerve of the donor free flap is usually coapted to the
pudendal nerve. Preliminary results in seven total phalloplasty
patients, evaluated at one or more years postoperatively by Gilbert and
colleagues (415), showed an encouraging return of tactile and erogenous
sensibility despite the presence of high vibratory thresholds and slow
bulbocavernosus reflexes.
e. Penile prosthesis.
Penile prosthetic devices offer an
acceptable therapeutic modality for patients who fail vasoactive drugs
and vacuum-constrictive device therapies and who are not candidates for
vascular reconstruction procedures. Devices are placed by creating an
adequate space within the tissue of each cavernosal body, followed by
implanting a prosthetic erectile element. When applicable, the two
erectile elements are linked to a pump that is implanted into the
scrotum, and a fluid reservoir that is implanted into the scrotum, the
pelvis, or the abdominal cavity. More than 15 different devices have
been marketed since the early 1970s and can be classified broadly into
three categories (416, 417, 418): semirigid or nonarticulating malleable;
self-contained articulating rod or unitary inflatable; and, two- or
three-piece fully inflatable implants. Several factors must be
considered when selecting a prosthetic device for a given patient,
including penile size, presence of intracorporeal fibrosis, the
patients manual dexterity, and the expectation of the patient and his
partner. An excellent review of the various models and the advantages
and disadvantages of each penile prosthesis has recently been published
by Mulcahy (416). A summary of features of each class of
prosthesis is also presented in Table 6
.
Long-term results of penile-prosthetic implants have recently been reviewed by several investigators (416, 417, 418). Generally, modern devices appear to have a long-term mechanical failure rate of approximately 5%. Patient satisfaction over long periods of follow-up approximates 80%, and that of the partner is slightly lower (between 60% and 80%). Many investigators reported enhancement of sexual and nonsexual relationships between the partners after placement of prosthesis. A common dissatisfaction is the lack of penile length. Proper patient and device selection and patient and partner counseling before surgery are of paramount importance if complications and patient dissatisfaction with results are to be kept at a minimum. Other complications associated with placement of penile prostheses, in addition to device failure, penile shortening, and patient dissatisfaction, include acute and delayed infections, destruction of the cavernosal tissue, and possible silicone particle migration to regional lymph nodes. It should be emphasized, however, that so far there has been no immunological disease in men receiving this treatment that is proven to be related to placement of the implant.
5. Tissue and molecular engineering in treatment of erectile dysfunction. Several new observations are promising for new therapeutic modalities of erectile insufficiency using molecular biology techniques. Recently, a number of vascular endothelial mRNA isoforms were shown to be expressed in the rat and human penis (419). Enhancing the expression of this growth factor in the cavernous tissue may emerge as a form of gene therapy for vasculogenic erectile dysfunction. Similarly, seeding of human corporeal smooth muscle cells and endothelial cells on biodegradable polymer scaffolds has led to the formation of cavernosal tissue when implanted in the subcutaneous space of athymic mice in vivo (420). Such observation suggests the possibility of corporeal tissue reconstitution by tissue engineering technology. A creative way to grow an autologous penile implant was also reported by the same group of investigators (421). Penile reconstruction using engineered autologous chondrocytes, seeded on biodegradable polymers to create cartilage structures, has been attempted in the rabbit penis. Such technology may be used to create autologous penile prostheses, avoiding the complications associated with the use of foreign materials. Moreover, immunophilins (a group of cellular proteins that mediate nerve regeneration) were shown to promote the regeneration of NOS-containing penile nerves and erection recovery after cavernous nerve crush injury in rats (422), an observation that suggests a possible role for immunophilins in treating male erectile dysfunction associated with penile nerve injury or disease. Another approach to treatment of erectile insufficiency due to neuropathy may involve the use of K+ channels somatic gene (naked pcDNA/hSLo cDNA) inoculation into the corporeal tissue. Such a possibility is suggested by experiments in which a single intracorporeal injection of this gene restored the streptozotocin-induced decline in erectile capacity in rats in vivo (423), and in which the expression of the transcript was largely confined to the original tissue of injection (the penis) at time points greater than 24 h after inoculation (424). Moreover, the isolation of prostaglandin receptors EP2, EP3I, EP3II, and TP (425) and the isolation of caveolin-1 and caveolin-3 (inhibitors of NOS activity) (426) in the human corporeal tissue may help in designing new therapeutic approaches for management of erectile insufficiency and priapism, respectively. Lastly, the use of recombinant human superoxide-desmutase may prove to be effective as a nonsurgical topically applied treatment for Peyronies disease (427). Thus, these novel strategies hold great promise for the development of physiological management approaches for a very sensitive form of human male inadequacies.
C. Disorders of ejaculation
1. Premature ejaculation.
a. Psychological and behavioral counseling.
An array of
individual, conjoint, and group therapy approaches using various
behavioral strategies has been used in psychosexual treatment of
premature ejaculation (Table 4
). In 1956, Semans (428) described the
basic procedure for the stop-start technique. With this method, a man
is repeatedly brought to high levels of arousal and then stimulation is
stopped just before ejaculation begins. Subsequently, Masters and
Johnson (429) adapted this technique to a start-stop-squeeze sequence
in which the penis is squeezed proximal to the frenulum, by the man or
his partner, immediately upon stopping of stimulation. Both techniques
are usually employed in a graduated fashion, starting with
masturbation, to partner manual stimulation, vaginal containment
without thrusting, and ultimately, active thrusting intercourse.
Several other additions have been suggested to these techniques,
including pulling down on the scrotum, or performing the Valsalva
maneuver when approaching the ejaculatory inevitability (430).
Psychosexual-behavioral therapy for premature ejaculation can also be
delivered in group format (431), through bibliotherapy (432), or as a
multimodal holistic framework therapy (433). In the latter method,
therapy is formulated after evaluating the individual patient from
different perspectives that include behavior, affect, genital
sensation, imagery, cognition, interpersonal relationship, and use of
drugs or biological modifiers in response to the sexual problem.
The combined use of psychosexual-behavioral therapy and
pharmacological agents (see below) has also been advocated for the
difficult-to-treat cases in some studies (434). In addition, the use of
pelvic-floor muscle rehabilitation with exercise training,
electrostimulation, and biofeedback to help patients gain control of
ejaculatory latency has also been advocated (435).
Although initial rates of success of psychosexual-behavioral therapy have been very high, more recent rates are more modest and range between 60% and 90% (436). Further, these rates are not sustainable and may fall to 25% 3 yr after therapy (436). Such observations are not surprising since many of the studies have pooled patients with different premature ejaculation categories (primary and secondary), age groups, levels of general and sexual anxiety, sexual experiences, and somatic vulnerabilities (such as tactile and/or CNS hypersensitivities) (436). Future therapeutic trials of patients with premature ejaculation should account for these factors and more thoroughly explore the effect of combined behavioral-pharmacological treatment.
b. Drug therapy.
i. Serotonergic antidepressants: Several recent scientific articles and reviews have addressed the use of serotonergic drugs in treating patients with premature ejaculation (106, 437, 438). Data earlier than 1995 on the use of clomipramine were reviewed by Althof (438) and by Harvey and Balon (106). These data indicate that clomipramine at doses from 25 to 50 mg is effective in prolonging intravaginal intercourse to at least 2 min in about 70% of men, compared with a 10% improvement in patients treated with placebo. Further, a study by Segraves et al. (439) suggested that the intake of clomipramine could be limited to the day of intercourse. The minimum time between drug ingestion and maximum ejaculatory control, however, has not yet been fully established. The mechanism(s) by which clomipramine retards the ejaculatory latency is not totally clear. Clomipramine is a tricyclic antidepressant, which also acts centrally at the 5-HT-2 receptor to inhibit serotonin reuptake and thus promotes serotonin activities. However, some studies have suggested that it increases the sensory threshold for stimuli in the genital area (440), possibly through inhibition of the adrenergic receptors in the peripheral sympathetic system (441). The effect of clomipramine on sexual function is not always consistent, and both spontaneous orgasms and ejaculation (442) and anorgasmia (443) have been reported to occur in some patients. Painful ejaculation is another possible side effect of clomipramine (442).
Selective serotonin uptake inhibitors, including sertraline (Zoloft), fluoxetine (Prozac), and paroxetine (Paxil) have also been used to treat premature ejaculation (444, 445, 446). Similar to clomipramine, these agents also have the potential for inducing variable effects on sexual function, including spontaneous orgasms and ejaculation, anorgasmia, or painful ejaculation (see Refs. 260, 443, 437 for review).
ii.
-Adrenergic receptor blockers: The use of
-adrenergic
receptor blockers to delay premature ejaculation is based on the
understanding that the sympathetic nervous system is responsible for
the peristaltic movement of the seminal fluid through the male genital
tract. Preliminary studies (447) suggest that the effectiveness of
-blockers in treating premature ejaculation is close to that seen in
the treatment of benign prostatic hyperplasia (448). However, the final
assessment of the role of
-receptor blocking agents in treating
premature ejaculation must await the results of large well controlled
trials to examine both efficacy and safety of long-term use.
iii. Local anesthetics: Very limited data are available on the use of topical anesthetic preparations in treatment of premature ejaculation. The onset, depth, and duration of dermal analgesia provided depend primarily on the duration of application. Generally, the topical anesthetic creams are applied to the glans penis and penile shaft under occlusive cover (condom) for at least one half-hour before the sexual encounter. Dermal analgesia reaches its maximum at 23 h, and persists for 12 h after removal.
2. Absent or retarded ejacu1ation.
a. Modification of inciting drug therapy/other
agents.
Retrograde ejaculation results from damage
to the sympathetic innervation of the ejaculatory system and bladder
neck. Such a condition may follow spinal cord or cauda equina injury,
retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy, radical prostatectomy, or extensive
abdominal surgery. It can also be associated with diabetic autonomic
neuropathy or with intake of
-adrenergic blocking agents. A
nerve-sparing surgical technique or adequate control of hyperglycemia
may guard against the development of such a complication. Moreover,
patients in whom retrograde ejaculation is traceable to the ingestion
of
-adrenergic drugs may benefit from trial with alternate classes
of medications. Similarly, patients with bladder neck incompetence due
to injury may be considered for surgical reconstruction, although the
success of this procedure is usually limited. The majority of patients
with established dysfunction may not, however, have an existing
modifiable condition. Such patients could be considered for therapy
with either an
-adrenergic agent (e.g., ephedrine or
midodrine) or imipramine (a tricyclic antidepressant of the
dibenzazepine group of compounds). Generally, restoration of successful
antegrade ejaculation with these agents is possible in approximately
30% of patients with diabetic neuropathy or postretroperitoneal
lymphadenectomy (449, 450, 451).
b. Electrostimulation and vibratory
stimulation.
Courtois and colleagues (153) used
physiological recording techniques to study the remaining sexual
function in men with spinal cord injury. They found 100% of
individuals with high spinal lesions maintained the erectile response
to reflexogenic stimulation, and up to 90% of those with lower spinal
lesions maintained the erectile response to psychogenic stimulation.
Patients with lesions of the conus terminals also maintained 100% of
natural emission in response to psychogenic stimulation. The results of
this and other similar investigations (452) suggest that men with
spinal cord injury frequently underestimate their sexual capacity.
However, in many cases attained erections may not be adequately
sustained for a successful intercourse to take place (452).
Quantitation of organic and psychogenic contributions to the
pathogenesis of sexual inadequacy in these patients may require
detailed neurophysiological and psychometric studies (453) in order to
develop an appropriate treatment strategy. Available treatment
modalities include cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy, local or
systemic erection-promoting drugs, vacuum devices, and penile implants.
3. Postejaculation pain. Since the etiology of postejaculation pain is primarily a psychogenic one, the treatment of this disorder relies entirely on psychosexual and behavioral intervention (176). Organic causes of postejaculatory pain, i.e., chronic prostatitis, should be ruled out before beginning behavioral intervention therapy. In the behavioral therapy approach, the patient is provided with insight into the cause of his disorder and assigned with specific behavioral protocol in which he attempts to ejaculate under conditions that are conducive to muscle relaxation. In addition, the patient is cautioned not to attempt to delay his ejaculation and is allowed to use erotic fantasy to distract himself from the obsessional focus on control of ejaculation. Patients who are severely anxious and unable to relax sufficiently in response to behavioral methods may benefit from a benzodiazepine agent such as diazepam (Valium, 2 to 5 mg, Roche, Indianapolis, IN) or lorazepam (Ativan, 1 to 2 mg, Wyeth-Ayerst, Philadelphia, PA) administered one half-hour before ejaculation to induce a state of muscle relaxation (176).
D. Absence of orgasm
1. Modification of inciting drug therapy/other agents. Since
the most common etiology of anorgasmia is the intake of pharmacological
agents (such as the selective serotonin uptake inhibitors, the
tricyclic antidepressants, or the monoamine oxidase inhibitors),
regaining of the orgasmic sensation may be achieved with
discontinuation of the inciting drug and, when possible, substitution
with an alternate psychotropic (Table 4
). Another therapeutic strategy
is to discontinue intake of the inciting agent temporarily for 1 or 2
days of each week during which sexual activity could be contemplated,
i.e., a drug holiday.
2. Psychological counseling. The objective of psychosexual treatment of orgasmic inhibition is to modify the patients tendency for the obsessive focusing on his preorgasmic sensations and the fostering of pleasure-avoidance and erotic fantasy-abandonment behavior during sexual activity (40, 429). The objectives of therapy can be achieved through implementation of a multiple-step treatment plan. Treatment usually starts with instruction on self-stimulation to orgasm under conducive circumstances while being distracted from his usual obsessive self-observations by external inputs from audio, visual, or imagery sources. This first phase of therapy is aimed at reducing the shared-sex-induced anxiety. Once the patient becomes orgasmic with self-stimulation, presence and then participation of the partner are gradually introduced. Psychotherapy is also provided to help the patient resolve his underlying conflicts (40, 429).
E. Failure of detumescence (priapism)
1. Modification of inciting intracavernous or systemic/other
factors drug therapy. Prolonged erection is a small but
significant risk in patients treated with intracorporeal injections of
vasoactive drugs. Patients receiving this form of therapy should be
adequately counseled on the risk of priapism and advised on the use of
minimum effective dose of chosen agent(s) (Table 4
). Younger
individuals, and patients with psychogenic and/or neurogenic impotence,
usually exhibit a satisfactory erectile response to small doses of
vasoactive drugs, and they are at higher risks for development of
priapism than patients with vascular insufficiency (158, 159, 161, 340, 454). Mild cases of prolonged erection may be treated with oral intake
of
-receptor agonists such as pseudophedrine 30 mg once or twice at
30-min intervals. Also, the ß-receptor agonist terbutaline has been
used orally to treat priapism of less than 4 h in traumatic
paraplegic patients (161). More severe cases of priapism extending for
more than 4 h usually require corporeal aspiration and irrigation
with a solution containing heparin (5,000 U/liter) and epinephrine (1
mg/liter) (337). Another method is to aspirate 1020 ml of blood from
the corpora with a 19-gauge needle, followed by injection of
phenylephrine beginning with doses of 200 µg every 5 min and
increasing to 500 µg if necessary. This appears to be effective in
resolving erections of less than 12 h duration (337).
Phenylephrine doses of 500 µg in 2 ml saline have also been injected
into the corpus cavernosum every 15 min without aspiration until
detumescence is achieved (455). Other adrenergic agonists such as
norepinephrine, ephedrine, and metaraminol have been used to stimulate
corporeal vasoconstriction and to reverse priapism. All these agents
can cause significant increase in blood pressure, and use of
metaraminol was reported to cause death in two cases (456).
Occasionally, prolonged priapism (usually of more than 36 h
duration) due to vasoactive drug injection requires the surgical
placement of an arterio-venous shunt (159, 161, 182, 340). This will
cause a venous leakage and possible failure of response to future
vasoactive drug injections.
Priapism that is associated with systemic drug ingestion such as phenothiazines and trazodone should be treated with drug dose reduction, or when possible with drug substitution. Patients who are on illicit drugs such as cocaine should be counseled with rehabilitation programs. Cocaine-induced priapism can be a high-flow variant that is refractory to therapy. In some cases treatment of cocaine-induced priapism may require shunt placement or even partial penectomy (183).
Arterial high-flow priapism, which is caused by arterial-lacunar fistula and is characterized by delayed onset of a constant, painless, nontender erection after blunt trauma, can be treated with mechanical compression, surgical resection of the fistula, and ligation of the internal pudendal or cavernous arteries, selective internal pudendal arteriography with transcatheter embolization, or with watchful waiting. The latter two modalities have recently been reported to be associated with excellent rates of long-term resolution and restoration of erectile function (454, 457).
2. Treatment of inciting systemic disease. Management of priapism associated with systemic diseases such as sickle-cell anemia, leukemia, multiple myeloma, Fabers disease, or amyloidosis, and those associated with inflammatory conditions such as tularemia or mumps, should first be directed toward the primary disease. Patients with sickle-cell disease or trait should receive oxygen, hydration, alkalinization, and if necessary, transfusion. Patients with malignancy infiltration of the penis may benefit from irradiation, and those with leukemia usually respond to chemotherapy. Systemic infection should be treated with the appropriate antibiotics (159).
3. Medical treatment of Peyronies disease.Treatment of structural penile diseases depends upon the nature of the underlying disease. Peyronies disease can be self-limiting in many cases and may not require therapeutic intervention. Medical treatment is suitable in the acute phase (<12 months) of the disease when the plaque is unstable. Oral therapeutic agents may include vitamin E, p-aminobenzoate (Potaba, Glenwood, Inc., Tenafly, NJ), colchicines, or tamoxifen. Generally, use of these agents could be useful in patients with mild to moderate disease and is associated with 3050% reduction in plaque size and/or shaft deformity. In addition, erection-associated pain is reduced by 60% to 80% (see Ref. 458 for review). Other forms of medical therapy may include local or systemic glucocorticoids and the intralesional injection of a collagenase or a calcium channel blocker (e.g., Verapamil). These locally administered agents appear to have approximately the same therapeutic effects as the systemic medications. Medical therapy may help patients with moderate disease, whereas surgical correction is the treatment of choice for those with severe penile deformity.
4. Surgical repair of primary penile disease. Excision of the plaque and grafting procedures (e.g., Nesbit procedure, corporeal plication, synthetic material, or autologous grafting) are preferred in young patients with well defined Peyronies plaques, and insertion of a penile prosthesis is best suited for older patients and those with extensive fibrotic changes (458). Treatment of priapism should be directed at the identifiable etiology. When indicated, surgical intervention may help to preserve the subsequent erectile function (459). Phimosis, balanitis, and balanoposthitis usually respond to local measures or circumcision (460).
F. Effect of sexual dysfunction and its treatment on quality of
life in affected men
It was not until very recently that any investigation attempted to
evaluate health-related quality of life in men with erectile
dysfunction either before or after institution of any specific therapy.
Quality of life measures of men were evaluated by the Massachusetts
Male Aging Study and found to highly relate to their adequacy of sexual
functioning (461). Loss of sexual function after radical prostatectomy
was found to be more commonly perceived as a major health problem by
112 Australian men and was more likely than urinary incontinence to
adversely affect health-related quality of life (462). A significant
correlation between marital interaction and sexual function has also
been observed in men with sexual dysfunction attending urology clinics
(463).
Long-term prospective follow-up studies evaluating outcome and associated factors in men with erectile dysfunction are also emerging. A follow-up study of 4.1 yr of 107 patients that received either sex therapy (31 patients), self-injection of vasoactive drugs (34 patients), prosthesis implant (21 patients), or no therapy (28 patients) found that, despite an increase in overall rate of penetration, coital frequency did not change and many patients were dissatisfied with the quality of their sex life (464). However, the successful treatment of erectile dysfunction has been shown to be associated with improvement in quality of life. Such a conclusion is supported by several studies in which the Duke Health Profile was used to assess the effect of therapy with PGE-1 on health-related quality of life and found a clear impact of treatment on emotional well-being of the patients (350). Collectively, these studies support the contention that restoring normal erectile function has a positive impact on quality of life.
| VI. Summary and Future Directions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The realization of the complexity of sexual physiology is increasingly dictating the interdigitation of the expertise of multiple disciplines, including endocrinology, radiology, neurology, urology, and psychology, to provide effective investigative and therapeutic interventions. The role of the primary care physician remains pivotal in determining the presence and magnitude of the sexual difficulties, undertaking some of the preliminary evaluations, and assisting in instituting suitable therapeutic interventions. Detailed hormonal, neurological, vascular, and psychometric evaluations and the subsequent specific hormonal, surgical, and/or psychological therapies should be deferred, however, to the multidisciplinary specialized centers that are capable of undertaking such tasks.
Lastly, much of the attention in the future should be directed to a number of developmental areas. These include characterization of the physiological importance of a number of vasoactive and neuroactive peptides and amines recently found in the penis; simplification and standardization of techniques used in assessing penile structure and function; and establishment of safety and efficacy of newly developed diagnostic and therapeutic drug interventions. The use of androgen supplementation of men with erectile difficulties and low-normal bioavailable testosterone should be reexamined, particularly in view of the new data implicating androgens in local regulation of penile NOS production and action. Moreover, more work is needed to advance and refine the development of new therapeutic approaches such as the use of topically applied vasoactive agents, more selective phosphodiestrase type-5 inhibitors, and gene therapy interventions in the treatment of erectile insufficiency.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-adrenoceptor
subtypes. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 33:243279[Medline]
-1- and
-2-like adrenoceptors in human isolated
deep dorsal vein of the penis. Br J Pharmacol 89:493P (Abstract)[Medline]
-2 adrenoceptor antagonist on erectile function in the
human male. 2. The erectile response to erotic stimuli in men with
erectile dysfunction, in relation to age and in comparison with normal
volunteers. Psychopharmacology (Berlin) 115:471477[CrossRef][Medline]
-2 adrenoceptor antagonist on sleep and nocturnal
penile tumescence in normal male volunteers and men with erectile
dysfunction. Psychosom Med 57:345356
-subunit of the glycoprotein hormones in men. J Am
Geriatric Soc 39:353358[Medline]
-reductase deficiency and disorders of the androgen receptor. J
Clin Invest 74:14961508
2-Adrenergic and
opiate receptor blockade. Synergistic effects on anxiety in healthy
subjects. Arch Gen Psychiatry 43:10371041
-adrenergic receptor antagonists as potential agents
for the treatment of impotence. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 290:121128
-1 Blockade pharmacotherapy in
primitive psychogenic premature ejaculation resistant to psychotherapy.
Eur Urol 28:126130[Medline]
-Adrenergic drugs in retrograde ejaculation. Fertil Steril 25:817820[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. Yang, J. Wang, Y. Chen, Z. Sun, R. Wang, and Y. Dai Effect of Caffeine on Erectile Function via Up-Regulating Cavernous Cyclic Guanosine Monophosphate in Diabetic Rats J Androl, September 1, 2008; 29(5): 586 - 591. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Lamas, C. J. Lowenstein, and T. Michel Nitric oxide signaling comes of age: 20 years and thriving Cardiovasc Res, July 15, 2007; 75(2): 207 - 209. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. M Setter, J. L Iltz, J. E Fincham, R K. Campbell, and D. E Baker Phosphodiesterase 5 Inhibitors for Erectile Dysfunction Ann. Pharmacother., July 1, 2005; 39(7): 1286 - 1295. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Vignozzi, S. Filippi, M. Luconi, A. Morelli, R. Mancina, M. Marini, G. B. Vannelli, S. Granchi, C. Orlando, S. Gelmini, et al. Oxytocin Receptor Is Expressed in the Penis and Mediates an Estrogen-Dependent Smooth Muscle Contractility Endocrinology, April 1, 2004; 145(4): 1823 - 1834. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Jesmin, C. N. Mowa, N. Matsuda, A.-E. Salah-Eldin, H. Togashi, I. Sakuma, Y. Hattori, and A. Kitabatake Evidence for a Potential Role of Estrogen in the Penis: Detection of Estrogen Receptor-{alpha} and -{beta} Messenger Ribonucleic Acid and Protein Endocrinology, December 1, 2002; 143(12): 4764 - 4774. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |