| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Department of Endocrinology and Reproduction (A.P.N.T.), Erasmus University Rotterdam, 3000 DR Rotterdam, The Netherlands; and Department of Physiology (I.T.H.), University of Turku, 20520 Turku, Finland
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-subunit | I. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mutations of genes concerned with hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal function, due to their critical role in the development and regulation of reproductive functions, are understandably very rare and therefore not of major concern within the clinical practice of infertility treatment. However, they form today a class of diagnoses that must be taken into account upon differential diagnostics of aberrant and delayed sexual differentiation and development, as well as infertility. In addition, by displaying distinct phenotypes, these conditions have turned out to be very elucidating with regard to the main facets and certain poorly characterized details of the hormonal control of reproduction. These naturally occurring mutations are often corroborated by genetically manipulated animal models with astonishingly similar phenotypes to those of the human diseases. The same applies to the currently known human mutations of gonadotropin and gonadotropin receptor genes, as well as to their animal models.
Whereas the hormone ligand mutations that have been found to date usually represent loss-of-function mutations (homozygotes or compound heterozygotes have a phenotype), the receptor mutations can be both of the gain-of-function (also heterozygotes have a phenotype) and loss-of-function type. In addition to clear-cut disease-causing mutations, the genome of all individuals is full of small structural variations, polymorphisms, which usually are associated with repeats in noncoding regions of the genome or point mutations within the genes. They may or may not cause alterations in gene function or structure of the encoded protein, and, consequently, often have no clear-cut phenotypic expression. However, subtle changes in function of the encoded protein, with mild phenotypic expression, are also possible in these cases.
| II. Structure-Function Relationships of Gonadotropins and Gonadotropin Receptors |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-subunit and a
hormone-specific ß-subunit that are associated through noncovalent
interactions. The mature
-subunit consists of 92 amino acid residues
and is encoded by a single gene, comprising four exons, which is
localized on chromosome 6q12.21 (Fig. 1
-subunit protein contains 10 cysteines, which are involved in
intrasubunit disulfide linkages and two N-linked glycosylation sites.
Although the ß-subunits confer functional specificity of the
hormones, they show considerable amino acid identity, ranging from 32%
for the LH-TSH pair to 83% for the LH-hCG pair (excluding the
nonhomologous C-terminal extension of hCG). The ß-subunit genes are
located on different chromosomes: the LH/hCGß gene cluster on
chromosome 19q13.32, FSHß on chromosome 11p13, and TSHß on
chromosome 1p13. The LH/hCGß gene cluster consists of one LHß gene
and six hCGß genes and pseudogenes (3). At least five of the hCGß
genes are expressed in choriocarcinoma cells and placenta, but most of
steady-state hCGß mRNAs appear to be transcribed from genes 3, 5, and
8 (4).
|
The crystal structure of deglycosylated hCG (6) has revealed that
the
-subunit and the ß-subunits both contain a so-called cystine
knot structure, similar to some remotely related signaling molecules
such as transforming growth factor-ß (TGFß), nerve growth factor
(NGF), and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF). Each subunit has
elongated shape with two ß-hairpin loops on one side of the central
cystine knot and a long loop on the other side. The noncovalent
interaction between the two subunits is stabilized by a segment of the
ß-subunit that extends like a "seat-belt" around the
-subunit
and is "locked" by a disulfide bridge.
Just as their ligands, the receptors for the glycoprotein hormones have
related structures (Fig. 2
). The
receptors belong to the large family of G protein-coupled receptors,
whose members all have a transmembrane domain that consists of
seven-membrane traversing
-helices connected by three extracellular
and three intracellular loops. The glycoprotein hormone receptors form
a separate subgroup within this large family on the merit of
their large extracellular hormone-binding domain at the N terminus. FSH
and TSH bind to the FSH and TSH receptors, respectively, while LH and
hCG both bind to the same LH receptor. The LH and FSH receptor genes
are located on chromosome 2p21 (7) and 2p2116, respectively (8, 9),
while the TSH receptor is found on a different chromosome, 14q31 (10, 11). The relationship of the glycoprotein hormone receptors to the
other G protein-coupled receptors is indicated by their sequence
homology in the C-terminal half of the receptor. This domain, encoded
by a single, last exon, contains the seven-transmembrane segments and
the G protein-coupling domain. The extracellular domain of the
glycoprotein hormone receptors is encoded by the preceding 9 or 10
exons.
|
-structural units
that may be responsible for the protein-binding function of
ribonuclease inhibitor. The extracellular domain of the glycoprotein
hormone receptors with nine such leucine-rich repeats may have a
similar structure, and this feature was used as an aid in studies of
the interaction of hCG with the LH receptor (15, 16, 17). The leucine-rich
repeat units are flanked by motifs that appear to be structurally
stabilized by cysteine disulfide bridges (17).
In the extracellular domain of the LH and FSH receptors, a number of
potential N-linked glycosylation sites have been identified. There are
six sites in the LH receptor: Asn 99, 174, 195, 291, 299, and 313; and
four sites in the FSH receptor: Asn 191, 199, 293, and 318, although
the last site is not conserved among species (Fig. 2
; the amino acids
in the receptor proteins are numbered by taking the first methionine of
the signal peptide as 1). The role of N-linked glycosylation in
receptor function is not completely elucidated, and some seemingly
contradictory results have been presented. Chemical deglycosylation of
the rat LH receptor, or inhibition of glycosylation by tunicamycin
treatment, did not prevent correct LH receptor folding, hormone
binding, and signal transduction (18, 19). Mutational analysis of the
rat LH receptor revealed a decrease or even complete loss of hormone
binding activity upon elimination of the potential glycosylation sites
at Asn103, Asn178, and
Asn199 (equivalent to
Asn99, Asn174, and
Asn195 in the human), indicating the presence of
functional carbohydrate chains at these positions in the rat ovarian
LH/hCG receptor (20). Additional studies of the rat LH receptor using
more extensive mutational dissection showed that all potential
consensus glycosylation sites are N-glycosylated, but also revealed
that the deleterious effects of the mutated N-linked glycosylation
sites on rat LH receptor function result from the amino acid
substitutions per se, and not from absent glycosylation
(19). In the case of the rat FSH receptor, two of the three
glycosylation sites (Asn191 and
Asn293) are actually glycosylated, and a
carbohydrate at either residue is required for efficient and correct
folding of the receptor (21).
The extracellular ligand-binding domain of the gonadotropin receptors is connected to the transmembrane signaling domain by a hinge region. It is not clear whether this structure has functions other than serving as a connecting peptide, although the part of the hinge region closest to the first transmembrane segment is well conserved between the glycoprotein hormone receptors, suggesting a special role. Interestingly, in the marmoset monkey, exon 10 of the LH receptor gene, although present in the genome, is always completely spliced out from the mature mRNA (22). Exon 10 encodes the N-terminal part of the cystine cluster that is proposed to flank the leucine-rich repeat structure at its C terminus (17). This cluster has a chemokine-like structure, indicating an important function in the LH receptor. Nevertheless, the marmoset LH receptor (22) appears to function normally, suggesting that this cystine motif is not important in this species for receptor action and may act merely as a spacer allowing correct location of the extracellular domain in relation to the transmembrane domain. However, if exon 10 is deleted from the human LH receptor, the transit of the mutated receptor to the cell membrane is hampered (23), and the same is found to occur in a naturally occurring human LH receptor mutation in which the sequence encoding exon 10 is spliced out (Ref. 24 ; see below, Section V.B).
The transmembrane domain with its seven membrane-spanning
-helices,
connected by three extracellular and three intracellular loops, is
similar to the other members of the large family of G protein-coupled
receptors. Evidence has been presented that the transmembrane domain is
sufficient for hormone binding (25), but this report has not been
substantiated by other investigators. A molecular model of the LH
receptor has proposed that some parts of the extracellular loops may
function as contact points for the hormone bound to the extracellular
binding domain and/or to this domain itself, relaying the hormonal
signal to the intracellular face of the receptor (15). Together with
the cytoplasmic parts of the transmembrane
-helices, the
intracellular loops and the C-terminal tail of the receptor form the
interaction domain with G proteins. As with other members of the G
protein-coupled receptor family, the third intracellular loop and the
cytoplasmic tail are most closely involved in G protein coupling and in
the selectivity of coupling to specific types of G proteins (26, 27).
The LH and FSH receptors are mainly coupled to Gs, the G protein that activates the various adenylyl cyclase isoenzymes, resulting in elevation of intracellular cAMP levels. Both of these receptors, however, are also able to activate other signal transduction pathways, and in in vitro experiments with cells isolated from experimental animals (rat, mouse, porcine) or transfected with LH or FSH receptor cDNA (human, rat, mouse), increased phosphatidylinositide turnover, elevated intracellular Ca2+, and activation of mitogen-activated protein kinases have been found (26, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40). Coupling to Gi proteins has been demonstrated for bovine and murine LH receptor (28), while the porcine LH receptor is able to activate Gq/11 and G13 in addition to Gi (32, 41, 42). Further studies will be necessary to elucidate the identity of G proteins coupling to the FSH receptor and to unravel possible species specificity of G protein coupling of either receptor type. The alternate intracellular pathways are in most cases activated at higher hormone concentrations than the cAMP pathway and may depend on high receptor densities (33). Therefore, their physiological relevance often remains unclear, although high serum levels of hCG and LH during pregnancy and around the time of ovulation, respectively, may make use of them.
Upon hormonal stimulation, the LH and FSH receptors desensitize, i.e., the hormonal signal is relayed in a less efficient manner. This process is caused by uncoupling of the receptor from the intracellular transducing G proteins, and by internalization of the receptor, resulting in decreased density of extracellularly exposed hormone binding sites. Most experiments addressing desensitization mechanisms have been carried out with rodents, either in vitro with isolated gonadal cells or in vivo following hormonal stimulation. Incubating purified testicular Sertoli (43, 44) or Leydig cells (45, 46) with FSH or LH, respectively, leads to rapid loss of hormone binding and cAMP response caused by loss of membrane receptors through internalization of the hormone-bound receptors. Similar findings have been made with various ovarian cell models in vitro (47, 48, 49, 50). In most experimental conditions, treatment of animals with LH, hCG, or FSH results in decreased responses of their testicular (51, 52, 53) and ovarian target cells (54, 55, 56). However, these mechanisms are not operative in all tissues. In the human corpus luteum, LH receptors or their mRNA are not lost under conditions of increasing hCG levels (57) or in fetal Leydig cells in the presence of high levels of placental hCG or increased LH secretion by the fetal pituitary (58, 59, 60).
In addition to the loss of receptors through internalization, a reduction in density of gonadotropin membrane receptors can also be caused by decreased receptor synthesis. In cultured immature rat Sertoli cells, a 4-h incubation with FSH or a cAMP analog causes complete disappearance of FSH receptor mRNA, probably through a posttranscriptional process involving a change in FSH receptor mRNA stability (44). Less strong effects of FSH that did not appear to involve mRNA stability changes were observed in another study with rat Sertoli cells (61). In cultured granulosa cells from rat and porcine origin, both stimulating and inhibitory effects of FSH on FSH receptor mRNA have been observed (62, 63, 64, 65). However, these observations may be a reflection of the differentiating actions of FSH on the granulosa cells, rather than rapid sensitization or desensitization effects. In similar culture studies with porcine Leydig cells (66), mouse tumor Leydig cells (67, 68), and rat granulosa cells (69), LH/hCG caused rapid LH receptor mRNA loss. Also in the case of the down-regulation of LH receptor mRNA levels, it remains unclear whether mRNA stability is involved in all cases.
Agonist-induced phosphorylation of G protein-coupled receptors by second messenger kinases such as protein kinase A or by G protein-coupled receptor kinases (GRKs) leads to receptor uncoupling and internalization through a process that involves binding of inhibitory proteins (arrestins) to the receptor and targeting to clathrin-coated pits (70, 71). This process has been best studied for the adrenergic receptors, but it is also involved in uncoupling and internalization of the gonadotropin receptors. Both rat LH and FSH receptors are uncoupled and internalized after stimulation, and subsequent phosphorylation of the C-terminal tail [LH receptor (72, 73)] or the first and third intracellular loops [FSH receptor (74)] has been implicated to play a role in this process. In vitro coexpression of rat LH or FSH receptors with several different GRKs or ßarrestins results in increased uncoupling and internalization, demonstrating the involvement of these proteins in the regulation of gonadotropin receptor function (75, 76, 77, 78). Phosphorylation of the LH and FSH receptors is not always sufficient or necessary for the desensitization processes (42, 79, 80), as is also found for other G protein-coupled receptors (81, 82). Changes in conformation of the receptor may also be important (83).
Recently, two more distantly related members of the glycoprotein hormone receptor family, named LGR4 and HG38/LGR5, were identified from expressed sequence tag (EST) databases based on their similarities to the other family members (84, 85). The most conspicuous difference between LGR4 and HG38/LGR5 and the other family members was found to be the addition of an extra eight leucine-rich repeat in the extracellular domain. LGR4 and HG38/LGR5, whose ligands and function are as yet unknown, show a less strict tissue distribution of expression (LGR4: ovary, testis, adrenal, placenta, thymus, spinal cord, thyroid; LGR5: muscle, placenta, brain, spinal cord) than the LH, FSH (ovary, testis), and TSH (thyroid) receptors (84, 85). Several groups, however, have reported that the LH receptor gene also is expressed in several nonclassical gonadotropin target tissues, such as placenta, brain, adrenal gland, and prostate (86, 87, 88, 89) and in normal and malignant breast tissue (90). However, the physiological significance of this "ectopic" LH receptor expression still remains unclear, since the effects of the absence of LH receptor function found in patients do not indicate effects on other tissues than the gonads, although these observations are limited by the effects of the pseudohermaphroditism or amenorrhea found in such cases (see below).
| III. Normal and Pathological Gonadotropin Function |
|---|
|
|
|---|
During the first phase of sex differentiation, i.e.,
commitment of its direction, two testicular hormones come into play,
signaling the direction of gonadal development to other genital
structures of the developing fetus. The Sertoli cell product
anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH; also known as Müllerian
inhibiting substance, MIS), causes the regression of the
anlagen of the female internal genitalia, i.e.,
the Müllerian ducts, preventing the development of these female
organs in the male. The growth and differentiation of the male internal
genitalia, which develop from the Wolffian ducts and the urogenital
sinus, is stimulated by the androgen testosterone, produced by Leydig
cells of the fetal testis, and in some target tissues by
5
-dihydrotestosterone, a metabolite of testosterone through
conversion by the 5
-reductase enzyme. In the human fetus, after an
initial gonadotropin-independent phase, this activation of
steroidogenesis, as well as Leydig cell growth and differentiation, is
completely dependent on placental hCG. Although the majority of hCG is
secreted to the maternal circulation, its concentration in fetal blood
is high enough to stimulate fetal testicular steroidogenesis (59). The
role of fetal pituitary gonadotropins in the regulation of gonadal
function in utero is apparently negligible. As will be
elaborated below, male development is largely dependent on correct
hormone production by the fetal and postnatal testis. In contrast, the
fetal ovary is hormonally silent and fetal differentiation into the
female direction appears to be totally independent of gonadotropins and
gonadal function. The fetal ovary apparently does not express
gonadotropin receptors (92).
A short period of high gonadotropin secretion after birth in both sexes is probably responsible for the postnatal peak of testosterone measured in baby boys during the first 34 months of postnatal life (93), whereas nothing is known about its possible effects on the ovary. After this postnatal peak, gonadotropin secretion is suppressed to very low levels until the advent of puberty. However, pulsatile release of low levels of gonadotropins, predominately at night, is also found in prepubertal children (94). The prepubertal testes apparently have both LH and FSH receptors, since they show clear testosterone and growth responses to LH/hCG and FSH, respectively (95, 96). In contrast, no data are available on the presence of gonadotropin receptors in the prepubertal ovary. However, also prepubertal ovaries may express gonadotropin receptors, since ovarian follicles of girls with a central activation of the hypothalamus/pituitary start producing estrogens.
Puberty can be envisaged as the second phase of sexual differentiation. Reactivation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis results in increased secretion of LH and FSH from the pituitary, with stimulation of the cognate gonadal target cells. Again, steroid hormone production plays a central role in signaling the maturation of gonadal function to extragonadal tissues. The androgen production of Leydig cells is now activated by pituitary LH and induces the secondary sex characteristics of the adult male. Feminization and attainment of fertility of the female occur under control of estrogens and progesterone, produced by the stimulated ovarian follicles and corpus luteum through combined actions of FSH and LH.
B. Mature function
In the ovary, granulosa cells are the only target cells of FSH
action, thus expressing the FSH receptor, whereas both theca, stromal,
late-stage (luteinizing) granulosa, and luteal cells contain LH
receptors. The known role of FSH in the ovary is to stimulate
follicular maturation, including follicular estrogen production
through aromatization of androgens. LH stimulates androgen production
in theca cells, thus providing substrate for granulosa cell estrogen
production. LH also triggers ovulation, and thereafter maintains the
progesterone production of corpus luteum. In the testis, Sertoli cells
are the target of FSH action and Leydig cells are the target of LH
action. The specific role of FSH in testicular function is still
somewhat unclear, but functions such as stimulation of Sertoli cell
proliferation in the immature testis and maintenance of qualitatively
and quantitatively normal spermatogenesis, through indirect effects
mediated by Sertoli cells, have been proposed. The role of LH is to
stimulate Leydig cell androgen production and thereby to maintain the
endocrine (extratesticular) and paracrine (spermatogenic) effects
of androgens.
The synthesis and secretion of gonadotropins are under positive control of the hypothalamic GnRH (GnRH), and gonadal steroid and peptide (mainly inhibin) hormones exert negative and positive feedback effects on gonadotropin synthesis and secretion, either directly at the pituitary level or indirectly via the hypothalamus, mainly by modulating GnRH secretion. For GnRH to stimulate gonadotropin secretion, it is important that it is released in pulsatile fashion from the hypothalamus to the hypophysial portal circulation. This causes pulsatile secretion of gonadotropins, which is clearer with LH, due to its shorter half-time in circulation. However, the pulsatile mode of gonadotropin action at the gonadal level is apparently not important. Recent studies on male rats, either by follow-up of endogenous LH and testosterone pulses, or by pulsatile treatment with recombinant rat LH, demonstrate that gonadal stimulation is achieved by trains of multiple LH peaks of sufficient size (97, 98). However, the pulsatility of these effects may not be critical in view of effective gonadal stimulation by tonic gonadotropin injections in experimental animals and in humans. The importance of pulsatility in FSH secretion is even less clear, due to its longer half-life in circulation.
This pituitary-gonadal function remains basically similar in the female until menopause, after which estrogen production ceases in the absence of follicles, and gonadotropin secretion increases in the absence of ovarian negative feedback effects. In the male, there is gradual suppression of testicular androgen production and reciprocal increase of gonadotropins upon aging, beyond 5060 yr of age.
A number of diseases at the hypothalamic and pituitary levels can impair the synthesis and secretion of gonadotropins. Aberrations in the hypothalamic regulation of gonadotropin synthesis, of which the best example is the absence of GnRH neurons, can result in Kallmanns syndrome. This syndrome is due to disturbed migration of the GnRH neurons from the olfactory placode to their final location in the hypothalamus. This migration of GnRH neurons is disturbed in the most common X-linked form of Kallmanns syndrome (hypogonadotropic hypogonadism and anosmia) through mutation in the gene of an extracellular matrix protein, anosmin, resulting in disturbance in development of olfactory bulbs and tracts (99). The other causes of abnormally low gonadotropin secretion include craniopharyngioma and a variety of other tumors, infiltrative diseases (e.g., sarcoidosis), trauma, vascular disease, radiation therapy, pituitary infarction, metabolic diseases (e.g., hemochromatosis), and functional causes such as stress and anorexia nervosa (100, 101). Pathologically increased levels of gonadotropins are observed in connection with paraneoplastic gonadotropin secretion, central precocious puberty, and primary hypogonadism (100, 101). We can also include in this category hyperthyroidism associated with pregnancy and trophoblastic tumors, where the highly elevated levels of hCG, due to structural similarity of LH/hCG, TSH, and their cognate receptors, are able to stimulate thyroid function by binding to the TSH receptor (102). More detailed discussion of these conditions is beyond the scope of this review.
A rare condition of suppressed gonadotropin action is caused by disturbance of gonadotropin glycosylation. This step of gonadotropin synthesis normally occurs through action of a group of specific enzymes, which in rare cases are inactivated by mutations. Although the actions of the glycosylation enzymes are not specific for gonadotropins, their mutations nevertheless appear to influence the formation of functionally competent glycoprotein hormones. The condition is called carbohydrate-deficient glycoprotein syndrome, where several different autosomal recessive enzyme deficiencies can result in incomplete glycosylation of plasma proteins (103). The syndrome appears to cause hypergonadotropic hypogonadism in women, where the high circulating levels of immunoreactive FSH have been found to have very low bioactivity (104, 105, 106). Male patients with this syndrome virilize at puberty but display suppressed testicular volume. LH levels and LH action seem to be only marginally, or not at all, affected in the subjects. This syndrome emphasizes the importance of proper glycosylation of gonadotropins for their bioactivity. Although it remains unclear why FSH is more affected than LH, the phenotypic expression of this disease is reminiscent of genetic inactivation of FSH or its receptor (see below).
In addition to the genetic alterations of gonadotropin receptor genes, the topic of the present review, there are also other causes for the end-organ gonadotropin resistance, i.e., hypergonadotropic hypogonadism. The apparent causes include anatomical aberrations of gonadal development and structure in various forms of gonadal dysgenesis and agenesis (107). The most common form of ovarian dysgenesis is Turners syndrome (45, XO), The other forms include diagnoses such as pure gonadal dysgenesis, ovarian steroidogenic enzyme defects, and premature ovarian failure, but their exact pathogenesis often remains open. Testicular resistance to gonadotropins can be caused by various developmental abnormalities. The most common chromosomal aberrations are Klinefelters (XXY) and XX male syndromes, while the other diagnoses include various forms of idiopathic and acquired arrest of spermatogenesis, acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), various neurological diseases, trisomy 21, effects of drugs, radiation, and environmental toxins, autoimmunity, and a number of systemic diseases (108). Gonadotropin resistance of both sexes is also possible, if there are defects in gonadal actions of other circulating hormones or of para- or autocrine effectors (109). However, distinct clinical conditions with disturbances in these functions are not yet known.
| IV. Mutations in Human Gonadotropin Subunit Genes |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-subunit
-subunit gene (110, 111, 112, 113), none of them appear to influence the
encoded amino acid sequence. Some studies (112, 114, 115), though not
all (116), report that particular common
genotypes are
disproportionately represented in DNA derived from trophoblastic
malignancies. Paired normal and tumorous tissues from the same subject
showed similar RFLP patterns, suggesting that particular common
alleles predispose toward a variety of neoplasias, rather than
represent somatic mutations in tumors (115). How exactly common
-polymorphism is related to tumorigenesis remains obscure. It could
be linked to mutation of a neighboring gene with clear causal
relationship to the malignancy, although it may also represent a
spurious association.
The only genetic alteration so far reported in the
-subunit protein
is a single Glu56Ala amino acid substitution in
subunit ectopically secreted by a human carcinoma (Table 1
) (117). This mutated protein failed to
associate with the ßsubunit and appeared to have significantly
higher mol wt than the native
-subunit. It was proposed that the
detected mutation causes altered tertiary structure, self-dimerization,
or altered glycosylation, which could then be responsible for the
ectopic subunits increased size and failure to dimerize with LHß.
|
-subunit gene could
mean that such changes are lethal. In addition to gonadotropins, they
would also affect the formation of CG and TSH. The fact that mice with
targeted disruption of the common
-gene are viable (128) (see below)
speaks against this possibility. However, the mouse, not producing CG,
may not be an adequate model for the human in this respect. The
question about possible presence of common
-mutations and their
phenotypic expression in the human thus remains open.
B. Mutations of the LHß subunit
The only true human mutation of the LHß gene causing total
functional inactivation is that described by Weiss et al.
(118) (Table 1
). The proband was a male, who presented with delayed
puberty at the age of 17 yr. He was a member of a previously identified
kindred with several infertile men (129) and had low testosterone and
high immunoreactive LH serum concentrations. His testosterone secretion
responded normally to exogenous LH and hCG, but in an in
vitro bioassay serum LH was found to be devoid of bioactivity
(130). These findings, together with the occurrence of infertility in
three maternal uncles (with slightly lowered testosterone and increased
LH) and a family history of consanguinity, suggested that the man had
an inherited defect in the structure of LH, although his mother and
sister had no symptoms of reproductive inadequacy. After two years of
testosterone treatment, no sign of spontaneous puberty was seen after
withdrawal of the treatment. Testicular biopsy revealed arrest of
spermatogenesis and absence of Leydig cells. Long-term treatment with
hCG resulted in testicular enlargement, normal virilization, and onset
of spermatogenesis.
Upon sequencing of the LHß subunit gene of the subject, a
homozygous A-to-G missense mutation was found in codon 54, causing a
Glu-to-Arg substitution (118). The subjects mother, sister, and three
uncles were found to be heterozygous for the same mutation. A gene
conversion whereby sequences from the CGß gene are exchanged with or
incorporated in the LHß gene was excluded, which indicated that the
alteration in LHß structure represented a spontaneous germ line
mutation. Coexpression of the mutated LHß gene with normal
-subunit gene in CHO cells resulted in formation of immunoreactive
LH
/ß heterodimers, with no activity in RRA, i.e., the
mutated hormone was devoid of biological activity because of inability
to bind to the LH receptor. In the heterozygous family members, as
expected, the bioactivity of LH was reduced in relation to
immunoreactivity, since half of their LHß was encoded by the mutated
gene.
This rare case clarifies some points about the developmental role of pituitary LH. Since the proband was apparently normally masculinized at birth with descended testes, pituitary LH is not needed for the stimulation of testicular testosterone production in utero. Indeed, testosterone production is initiated autonomously, but becomes subsequently dependent on placental hCG (58, 59), and fetal pituitary LH apparently plays no role in regulation of fetal testicular function. However, the endocrine function of the postnatal testes is critically dependent on pituitary LH secretion, as was demonstrated by the total absence of spontaneous puberty in this subject lacking bioactive LH. It is intriguing that the heterozygous male family members had impaired steroidogenesis and high incidence of infertility despite normal pubertal masculinization. However, since the probands father was an obligate heterozygote, the importance of the heterozygozity for testicular function remains open. The heterozygous women, including the probands mother, were apparently free of symptoms. It is curious that no other human subjects homozygous for this type of mutation have yet been detected. The female phenotype would probably resemble those with inactivating LH receptor mutation (see below). Comparison of these two conditions would elucidate the role of intrauterine LH/hCG action, if any, in ovarian development and function.
C. Genetic variants of LHß subunit
Sequence variability of the LHß chain was observed in early
reports on chemical sequencing of this protein (131), but the existence
of polymorphic alleles of the LHß gene has only been recently
recognized.
Upon testing the applicability of various monoclonal antibodies
(Mabs) for the detection of LH, using the immuno- fluorometric
assay (IFMA) principle, Pettersson and colleagues (132, 133, 134)
described a healthy woman with two children, whose LH was
undetectable using a Mab directed against an antigenic epitope present
only in the intact LH
/ß dimer (assay 1). The womans LH
bioactivity and the ratio of bioactivity to immunoreactivity (using a
subunit-specific IFMA for immunoreactive LH measurement, assay 2) were
normal and in accordance with her normal fertility. Since her TSH and
FSH levels were also normal, indicating no abnormalities in the common
-subunit gene, the LHß gene was sequenced (119, 135). The LHß
gene of the subject was found to represent a genetic variant (V) allele
of the LHß gene, with two missense mutations:
Trp8Arg (TGG -> CGG) and
Ile15Thr (ATC->ACC)
[Table 1
and Fig. 3
(119, 135)].
Recently, the same LHß allele was reported from Japan (120, 136) in
female patients with infertility, and their LH likewise was
unmeasurable with an immunometric assay kit using two Mabs. There is a
complete linkage of the two mutations in all samples so far analyzed
from various populations (135).
|
|
The worldwide frequency of the V-LHß gene has been extensively studied (135, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144), and it appears to be highest in the Northern European populations (allelic frequency > 10%) and, interestingly, in Australian aboriginals (28.3%), whereas lower frequencies are found in Asian populations and American Indians (2.55%). In all ethnic groups with a representative number of observations, the WT and V-LHß alleles are in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. It is curious that such a high variability of carrier frequency as from 0 to >50% (allelic frequency from 0 to 28.3%) can be found for V-LHß. It is tempting to speculate that V-LH has, in prehistoric times, offered reproductive advantage for populations living in untoward external conditions. It also seems that its correlation with various pathologies related to pituitary-gonadal function varies between different populations, and their penetrance is apparently dependent on the genetic background (see below).
Due to its high frequency, more detailed studies on functional effects of V-LH were warranted. Both serum V-LH (137) and its recombinant form (139) are more active than WT-LH in in vitro bioassay, with lower ED50 and about 20% higher maximum effect. In contrast, V-LH shows a clearly shorter half-life in circulation than WT-LH (26 vs. 48 min). As expected, the pulsatile pattern of LH secretion is not altered in carriers of the V-LHß allele (137). This leaves it somewhat open, whether the overall in vivo activity of V-LH is higher or lower than that of WT-LH. V-LH thus seems to be more active at the receptor site but the duration of its action is shorter. Most of the clinical observations indicate that V-LH represents a functionally weaker form of the hormone (see below).
To explain how a hormone with significantly shortened circulatory half-life can maintain grossly normal gonadal function, we hypothesized that its synthesis may be compensatorily enhanced. This would require alterations in the promoter function of the V-LHß gene. Indeed, when the V-LHß promoter was sequenced, a total of eight point mutations were detected within the first 650 nucleotides of its 5'-flanking sequence, and they always segregated with the two point mutations detected earlier in its coding sequence (145). The mutant promoter appeared about 50% more active than the WT promoter upon cell transfection studies, and it also displayed some qualitative differences in response to various hormonal stimuli. Hence, these findings demonstrated an intriguing evolutionary principle: if the function of a protein is altered through mutation in its gene, the change may be compensated for by additional mutations in its regulatory sequences that bring about opposite changes in synthesis of the mutated gene product.
Whether any particular phenotype(s) are related to V-LH is still somewhat unclear. It is also possible that both hetero- and homozygosity for the variant allele could give rise to different phenotypes. If we presume that V-LH represents a potent but short-acting form of LH, and WT-LH a less potent but long-acting form, a combination of both LH forms, as occurs in heterozygotes, could bring about different overall LH action than either of the forms alone. These qualitative differences between actions of WT and V-LH, including differences in their promoter function, provide the strongest evidence for possible phenotypic effects of V-LH. If the differences between the two hormone forms were only quantitative, then they could be fully compensated for by alterations in feedback regulation of LH secretion.
The first reports from Japan described V-LHß homozygosity with recurrent spontaneous abortions (136), menstrual irregularities with infertility (120), and polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) (120, 146). Subsequently, various disturbances in pituitary-ovarian function have also been found in V-LHß heterozygotes (143, 147). Clear findings have not been made in Caucasian populations (137, 148, 149, 150), although in a study on predominately Jewish subjects from the Boston (Massachusetts) area, heterozygous women for V-LHß had a history of frequent use of infertility treatments (D. Cramer and I. Huhtaniemi, unpublished study). In Finland, no association of V-LH was found in women with history of recurrent miscarriages (151).
Heterozygous women for the V-LHß allele have higher levels of serum testosterone, estradiol, and sex-hormone-binding globulin (148), which indicates differences in ovarian LH action between WT- and V-LH. In a multicenter study from Finland, the United Kingdom, The Netherlands, and the United States, with a total of 1,466 subjects, of whom 363 had PCOS and 79 polycystic ovaries without other symptoms of PCOS, it was found that the V-LHß frequency was 5- to 7-fold lower in obese PCOS subjects compared with that in other groups, i.e., lean PCOS subjects and lean and obese controls (24.5% vs. 10.333.3%, P < 0.05) (149). Thus, V-LH may protect obese women from developing symptomatic PCOS, which indicates that the more powerful WT-LH induces the pathological ovarian responses. However, this finding was not corroborated in the UK population, despite similar diagnostic criteria (148, 149). This is in keeping with the multifactorial pathogenesis of PCOS (152) and emphasizes that its pathogenesis in different populations may vary according to genetic background. Even though V-LH may not be directly related to PCOS, determination of V-LH may improve the prediction of risk of PCOS, especially in obese women. Its high frequency in various populations must be kept in mind because many widely used immunoassay reagents do not detect this LH form. One diagnostic criterion for PCOS, the elevated LH/FSH ratio, may remain undetected if such an LH assay is used, as has been emphasized recently (153). Other phenotypic associations with V-LH include the delayed tempo of pubertal progression in boys heterozygous for V-LHß (154), and in elderly men, it was more common in those with low testosterone and high LH concentrations (150). However, larger numbers of observations from various ethnic groups are needed to resolve the role of V-LH in pathologies of gonadal function and infertility.
Hence, there is some evidence for association of V-LH, as a protective or predisposing factor, with various pathologies of LH action. Since findings in various ethnic groups do not always agree, the overall genetic background of the population may be important for the phenotypic expression and penetrance of this relatively mild polymorphic alteration in structure and function of the LH molecule. V-LH may thus be an example of influence of genetic heterogeneity on reproductive functions. Additional polymorphisms affecting reproductive endocrine functions are likely to be found. Interestingly, another polymorphism of LHß, detected recently (Ser102Gly) in Singapore, has also been implicated in female infertility (155).
D. hCGß subunit
Several polymorphisms have been detected in the hCGß/LHß gene
complex by RFLP analysis (156, 157), but whether they result in
sequence differences in LH or hCG has not been studied in detail.
Layman et al. (157) were unable to detect large deletions or
duplications of the hCGß/LHß gene complex by genomic Southern
blotting in patients with suspected disorders of hCG production, such
as recurrent abortion, primary unexplained infertility, and gestational
trophoblastic neoplasia. A very recent study (122) showed that of the
six hCGß genes present in the human genome, the one most highly
expressed, number 5 (158), is highly conserved. Altogether six
polymorphisms were detected in this gene in a random population, and
they were, with the exception of one, either silent or located in
introns. An A-to-G transition in exon 3 of hCG gene 5 was found to
alter the amino acid: Val79 Met (Table 1
). When
the mutated ß-subunit was coexpressed with the common
-subunit
gene in CHO cells, the assembly of the two subunits was found to be
inefficient, although those dimers that did form had normal
bioactivity. This mutation was found in 4.2% of randomly chosen
healthy subjects, but only in heterozygous form. A limited search in
subjects with infertility (n = 41) yielded one additional silent
mutation, but the above mentioned amino acid change was not found in
this population. This may be due to the limited sample size or to the
possibility that the mutation is embryonic-lethal because of
insufficient production of biologically active hCG. Whether the
intronic mutations detected were truly silent, or affected the rate of
transcription or mRNA splicing, remains to be studied.
E. FSHß subunit
A total of five subjects (three women and two men) with different
inactivating mutations of the FSHß gene have so far been described in
the literature (Table 1
). The first mutation reported was a homozygous
2-bp deletion in codon 61 (Val61) of the FSHß
gene in a woman suffering from primary amenorrhea and infertility
(123). The mutation gave rise to a completely altered amino acid
sequence between codons 61 and 86 of the FSHß chain, which was
followed by a premature stop codon, and lack of translation of amino
acids 87111. Consequently, the translated FSHß protein was
truncated and unable to associate with common
-subunit to form
bioactive or immunoreactive
/ß-dimers. The affected woman had
apparently had normal adrenarche, but no menarche or telarche.
Treatment of the patient with exogenous FSH resulted in follicular
maturation, ovulation, and successful pregnancy. Her mother,
heterozygous for the mutation, had suffered from menstrual irregularity
and infertility, but these symptoms were unlikely related to the
mutation, since the heterozygous relatives of other similar patients
have been reported to be free of symptoms (see below).
The second case of inactivating FSHß mutation was also a female with similar phenotype, i.e., primary amenorrhea and poorly developed secondary sex characteristics (126). She had undetectable serum FSH and estradiol, high LH, and absent FSH response to GnRH stimulation test. Upon DNA sequencing, she appeared to be a compound heterozygote for two mutations in the FSHß subunit gene. One was the same as the mutation described by Matthews et al. (123), and the other was a missense T-to-G mutation, causing a Cys51to-Gly transition in the mature FSHß protein. Cells transfected with the FSHß gene carrying this mutation failed to produce immunoreactive FSH, apparently because of the loss of a cysteine critical for formation of proper disulfide bonds, as well as for synthesis and secretion of the hormone. No symptoms were found in the relatives heterozygous for either of the two FSHß mutations of the proband, suggesting that one intact FSHß gene is sufficient to maintain functionally adequate FSH secretion.
In a third female patient with isolated FSH deficiency, reported earlier (159), the cause was originally suggested to be due to circulating FSH antibodies (160). However, the molecular pathogenesis of this case was recently "re-revisited," and it was found to be due to the same homozygous 2-bp deletion as that of the first detected FSHß mutation (124). The FSH antibodies apparently developed in response to treatment with urinary gonadotropins (161), which were recognized as foreign protein by the patients immune system.
The female cases with FSHß inactivation are in good agreement and demonstrate that FSH is necessary for normal follicular development, ovulation, and fertility. Likewise, pubertal development is hampered in the absence of sufficient numbers of later stage follicles to harbor the granulosa cells needed for adequate estrogen production. As will be described below, this phenotype is practically identical to that caused by inactivating FSH receptor mutation.
Very recently, two men with FSHß mutations have been described (125, 127, 162). The report from Sweden by Lindstedt et al. (127, 162) described a 32-yr-old man of Serbian origin with azoospermia and
normal puberty, but with selective absence of FSH. The LH-testosterone
axis of the patient was apparently normal. Genetic analysis
demonstrated a homozygous T-to-C mutation, predicting a
Cys82-to-Arg substitution in the FSHß protein.
The second male, described from Israel (125), was an 18-yr-old man with
slightly delayed puberty, small testes, azoospermia, and plasma FSH
concentration below 0.5 IU/liter. Conspicuously, his testosterone level
was low (4.5 nmol/liter) and LH high (24.5 IU/liter). Upon DNA
sequencing, the same homozygous 2-bp deletion in codon 61 was found as
reported before with the female patients (123, 124, 126). It was
postulated, on the basis of studies on hCG biosynthesis (6, 163), that
in the Cys82Arg mutation, elimination of cysteine
would result in inability to form the first intramolecular disulfide
bond of FSHß. This would then result in abnormal tertiary structure
during FSHß synthesis, with extensive intracellular degradation of
the products, inability to associate with common
-subunit, defective
glycosylation, and finally inability to form biologically active
hormone.
As will be elaborated below, the phenotypes of women with inactivating
FSHß and FSH receptor mutations, as well as the female knockout mice
for FSH ligand and receptor, are in perfect agreement. However, there
is an apparent discrepancy between phenotypes of men with inactivating
FSHß and FSH receptor mutations, which still leaves open the final
word about the role of FSH in testicular function. Since the number of
males with FSHß mutation so far reported is only two, and that of men
with FSH receptor mutation five (164), the information about the role
of FSH in the male that can be obtained from earlier descriptions of
men with idiopathic isolated FSH deficiency can be valuable. These
studies were done at the time when genetic diagnostics was not yet
available. Some of the subjects with "isolated FSH deficiency" had
associated disorders, such as cryptorchidism, hypospadias, omphalocele,
deafness, the olfactory-genital dysplasia syndrome, chromosomal
alterations, autoimmunity, or short stature (160, 165, 166, 167, 168), and
therefore such patients may not be representative of truly isolated FSH
deficiency. However, many of them seem to fulfill the diagnostic
criteria. Those reported in full-length articles are summarized
in Table 2
, together with the two males
with genetic proof of FSHß mutation. In addition, one abstract exists
on isolated FSH deficiency in a male (169).
|
On the other hand, the two men with documented FSHß mutations (see above) were possibly only detected because of their azoospermia and/or delayed puberty. The Swedish patient, unlike some other FSH-deficient men (173), was resistant to FSH treatments for periods of 120 and 210 days (162), which may indicate additional contributing factor(s) to his azoospermia. The Israeli patient, in addition, had Leydig cell hypofunction, not demonstrated in any of the other FSH-deficient subjects, or those with FSH receptor defect (164), indicating the likelihood of an additional FSH-independent pathology of his testicular function.
In summary, the majority of information available indicates that FSH action per se is not mandatory for the pubertal initiation of spermatogenesis and fertility. However, qualitatively and quantitatively fully normal spermatogenesis apparently needs FSH action. The phenotype of men with defective FSH action varies from severe to mild impairment of spermatogenesis, in the face of apparently normal Leydig cell function. The azoospermia found in some of the men may be due to additional contributing factors, and not to truly isolated FSH deficiency. However, it is apparent that additional cases of genetically proven FSH deficiency are needed, before the existing discrepancy between phenotypes of the ligand and receptor deficiency, as well as the animal models with disrupted FSHß and FSH receptor genes (see below), can be resolved. At the moment, it may be warranted to state that treatment of men with idiopathic oligozoospermia and normal to elevated FSH concentration with FSH has no scientific basis, and that prospects of a male contraceptive method based on inhibition of FSH secretion or action are not promising.
| V. Mutations in Human Gonadotropin Receptor Genes |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
-1B adrenergic receptor had shown that changing a single alanine
residue in the third intracellular loop to any other amino acid caused
partial activation of the phosphoinositide pathway in the absence of
ligand (184). In addition, mutations in the mouse MSH receptor gene had
been described that caused dominant fur-color traits as a result of
constitutive adenylyl cyclase activation (185). Indeed, in keeping with
the hypothesis, the first mutations of the LH receptor were identified
in the sixth transmembrane segment (TM6) and the flanking third
intracellular loop (IL3), indicating, as had been found for other G
protein-coupled receptors, that this region of the transmembrane domain
was important for G protein coupling (Fig. 5
|
|
Comparison of the hCG dose-response activity of the receptor mutants and the WT-LH receptor reveals that, in many cases, the mutant LH receptor molecules display a lower response to a maximal stimulatory dose of hCG than the WT receptor (see e.g., Refs. 204, 206, 216). A decreased number of plasma membrane binding sites in cells expressing the mutant receptor molecules may be the reason for such a decrease (27, 190, 205, 210, 211, 213). A low number of cell surface expression may be caused by mutational effects on posttranslational modification and transport of the LH receptor protein (232) or increased internalization of the activated receptors (83, 233, 234, 235). However, a clear correlation between number of binding sites and maximal response is not always present. Comparing WT and two mutant LH receptors, Yano et al. (211) found that although both mutant receptors showed si