| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Laboratory on Thymus Research (W.S.), Department of Immunology, Oswaldo Cruz Institute, Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, 21045900 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; and CNRS UMR 8603 (M.D.), Université Paris V, Hôpital Necker, 75015 Paris, France
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In addition to their role in thymic cell proliferation and apoptosis, hormones and neuropeptides also modulate intrathymic T cell differentiation, influencing the generation of the T cell repertoire.
Finally, neuroendocrine control of the thymus appears extremely complex, with possible influence of biological circuitry involving the intrathymic production of a variety of hormones and neuropeptides and the expression of their respective receptors by thymic cells.
| I. Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| II. The Thymic Microenvironment and Its Role in T Cell Differentiation |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Importantly, although thymocyte proliferation and differentiation persist throughout life, they diminish with aging. Older thymuses are significantly atrophied and have fewer thymocytes than younger ones. However, even in humans, the adult thymus is still active in terms of delivering mature T lymphocytes to the periphery of the immune system (6, 7).
A. Intrathymic T cell differentiation: general comments
From the entrance of T cell precursors into the thymus to the exit
of mature cells from the organ, a vast body of interactions promotes
the complex process of T cell differentiation. This differentiation
involves regulation of the expression of various membrane proteins. A
key membrane protein is the T cell receptor (TCR), which in the cell
membrane is physiologically coupled with a molecular complex, termed
CD3. Additional accessory molecules, including CD4 and CD8, as well as
CD25 and the proteoglycan CD44, are useful to define stages of
intrathymic T cell differentiation.
The TCR is a heterodimer formed by an
ß- or a 
-chain
configuration. Although 
+ thymocytes are
the first to appear in the thymus with ontogeny of the organ, in the
adult organ, around 99% of TCR+ thymocytes
express TCR
ß and only 1% are 
T cells. A major point in
intrathymic T cell differentiation is that, after gene rearrangements,
any of the TCR peptide chains are generated, resulting in a large
diversity of TCRs bearing distinct peptide specificities. This complex
but well understood phenomenon is beyond the scope of this article but
is reviewed in detail in recent publications (8, 9, 10).
The CD3 complex is an assembly of polypeptidic chains physically associated with the TCR. This association, together with the fact that CD3 bears cytoplasmic domains capable of phosphorylation, provides the intracellular signal transduction pathways necessary for TCR-driven T cell activation. Such activation follows ligation with a peptide presented by molecules of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) expressed on the membranes of nonlymphoid cells. This ligation is favored by the accessory molecules CD4 and CD8, which are transmembrane glycoproteins that interact with class II and class I MHC molecules, respectively.
CD25 is the
-chain of the interleukin 2 (IL-2) receptor, and when it
is expressed together with the ß- and
-chain, the receptor
acquires high affinity for IL-2, thus favoring IL-2-driven thymocyte
proliferation. The proteoglycan CD44 is a receptor for hyaluronic acid,
and to a lesser extent for fibronectin and collagen. As seen below, it
is associated with thymocyte migration events and is also considered a
marker for T cell activation (11).
Cytofluorometric combined analysis of these markers proved to be useful
in defining intrathymic T cell differentiation. The most immature
thymocytes express neither the TCR/CD3 complex nor the accessory
molecules CD4 or CD8 and thus are called double-negative thymocytes.
Nevertheless, we can determine differentiation steps within the
double-negative compartment by distinguishing the cells on the basis of
their CD25 and CD44 expression. Thymocyte precursors that recently
entered the thymus, in addition to being
TCR/CD3-CD4-CD8-,
are also CD44+CD25-. As
they differentiate, these immature cells acquire CD25 on the cell
membrane, becoming
CD44+CD25+, and then
sequentially lose CD44 and CD25. The whole double-negative compartment
represents about 5% of total thymocytes. Thymocyte maturation then
progresses with the acquisition of both CD4 and CD8 markers, generating
the so-called CD4+CD8+
double-positive thymocytes. These cells are the most common in the
thymus, comprising 80% of total thymocytes. In the double-positive
stage, TCR genes are rearranged. In differentiation of
TCR
ß-bearing cells, the ß-chain-related genes are rearranged
first followed by the
-chain genes. At this stage, TCR is expressed
in low density on the cell membrane. Thymocytes that do not undergo a
productive TCR gene rearrangement (i.e., that will not
ultimately generate a peptide chain expressed on the cell membrane) die
by default through apoptosis. By contrast, those expressing productive
TCR will be able to react with peptides presented by molecules of the
MHC, expressed on the membranes of nonlymphoid cells. This interaction
will determine the positive and negative selection events, crucial for
normal thymocyte differentiation. Positive selection allows the
differentiation step whereby an immature, short-lived,
CD4+CD8+ thymocyte escapes
from programmed cell death and becomes a mature, long-lived,
CD4+ or CD8+ single
positive cell. This is a highly stringent process, sparing only a small
proportion of the CD4+CD8+
population. Positive selection also coincides with lineage commitment:
the decision to become a CD4+ or
CD8+ single positive thymocyte, as a function of
the class of MHC molecule with which the TCR can interact. Negative
selection in the thymus is the screen for establishing self-tolerance
in the T cell repertoire, promoting deletion of T cells that might
potentially be autoreactive to self-proteins. As illustrated in Fig. 1
, positive selection events begin earlier in CD3+
double-positive cells, whereas negative selection takes place in both
double-positive and single-positive thymocytes (Reviewed in Ref. 8).
|
ß-bearing cells. For a basic
description of intrathymic T lymphocyte differentiation, see Ref. 8 ,
and to see this process in more detail, consult other recent reviews
(9, 10).
It is noteworthy that thymocyte differentiation occurs as cells
migrate within the thymic lobules. As seen in Fig. 2
, top
panel, most of the immature thymocytes, including those bearing
the phenotypes
CD3-CD4-CD8-
and
CD3+CD4+CD8+
are cortically located, whereas mature
CD3+CD4+CD8-
and
CD3+CD4-CD8+
cells are found in the medulla, being those that will normally leave
the organ to populate the T cell-dependent areas of peripheral
lymphoid organs (5).
|
B. Cellular interactions involving the thymic microenvironment
Several kinds of heterotypic interactions occur
between differentiating thymocytes and microenvironmental cells. As
mentioned above, one key cellular interaction involves the TCR/CD3
complex, expressed by differentiating thymocytes, with class I or class
II MHC products on the microenvironmental cell membranes, complexed
with a given endogenous peptide to be recognized, in the context
of CD8 or CD4 molecules, respectively. The avidity of the resulting
interaction is a determinant for positive vs. negative
selection. Thymocytes with high avidity are negatively selected and are
also deleted by apoptosis. This leads to the death of large numbers of
potentially harmful autoreactive T cells. By contrast, a small
percentage of thymocytes with intermediate avidity for recognition of
MHC self-peptides appears to be rescued from death and is positively
selected. Positive selection appears to be essentially conveyed by
thymic epithelial cells (TEC) whereas negative selection can occur in
the context of hematopoietic-derived DC, but also of TEC (5, 13).
In addition to the TCR/MHC-peptide interaction, the thymic microenvironment can influence the process of thymocyte migration/differentiation via other types of heterotypic membrane interactions. For example, TEC express classical membrane adhesion molecules such as ICAM-1 (intercellular adhesion molecule 1) and LFA-3, which respectively bind to LFA-1 and CD2 present on thymocytes (14, 15, 16). Moreover, TEC-thymocyte interactions can be mediated by ECM ligands such as fibronectin and laminin and their corresponding integrin receptors VLA-4/VLA-5 and VLA-6 (17, 18, 19). In fact, it is possible that ECM provides a complex macromolecular substrate onto which thymocytes migrate within the organ, following an ordered pattern as if on a conveyor belt (20). More recently, biochemical and functional evidence was provided that TEC communicate with each other by gap junctions, which are formed by proteins of the connexin family and allow direct passage of low molecular weight substances between adjacent cells (21). Microinjection of low molecular weight fluorochromes also revealed functional gap junction-mediated TEC-thymocyte interactions. Based on further findings that have appeared in the literature, we recently postulated that gap junctions may correspond to a novel route for cell-cell communication in the immune system (22).
Thymic microenvironmental cells can influence thymocyte differentiation
and proliferation by means of soluble polypeptides. Both TEC and DC
produce the cytokine IL-1, which stimulates thymocyte proliferation
(23). Actually, various cytokines can be produced by thymic epithelium,
including IL-3, IL-6, IL-7, IL-8, granulocyte colony-stimulating
factor, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor, transforming
growth factor-
, transforming growth factor-ß (TGF-ß), leukemia
inhibitory factor, and stem cell factor (24, 25).
IL-7, in particular, has been proven to be crucial for thymocyte differentiation. For example, it was shown to promote rearrangement of the TCR genes by enhancing the production and activity of recombinases (26). In conjunction, IL-7-/- as well as IL-7 receptor-deficient mice display a severe reduction in lymphoid development, whereas the transgene incorporation of IL-7 in nude mice induces T cell development (27). In addition to IL-7, SCF (also termed c-Kit ligand) is necessary for early thymocyte differentiation. When fetal thymuses of spontaneously SCF-deficient mice are grafted into normal wild-type recipients, the number of CD3-CD4-CD8- is more than 10 times lower than in wild-type grafts (27).
In addition to classical cytokines, chemokines are also thymic microenvironment-derived secretory products important in thymus physiology. Chemokines correspond to a family of small polypeptidic molecules that control directional migration of leukocytes (reviewed in Ref. 28). Among others, one chemokine, the stromal cell-derived factor (SDF) is highly expressed in the thymus, being produced by stromal cells, particularly in the subcapsular region (29). In keeping with this topography, SDF preferentially attracts immature CD4-CD8- and CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Conversely, another chemokine, MIP3ß, exerts chemoattraction for mature single positive thymocytes (30). This is in keeping with the differential expression of corresponding chemokine receptors in distinct CD4/CD8-defined stages of thymocyte differentiation.
This leads to the notion that several paracrine circuits involving
TEC-derived factors are likely to have differentiating thymocytes as
targets. In addition to producing cytokines, TEC secrete chemically
defined thymic hormones, including thymosin-
1, thymopoietin, and
thymulin (31, 32, 33), that can also act upon the general process of
thymocyte maturation (reviewed in Refs. 34, 35, 36). For instance,
thymulin, a nonapeptide whose biological activity depends on its
coupling to zinc (37, 38), is able to enhance thymocyte proliferation
and to induce several T cell markers and functions (reviewed in Refs.
34, 35, 36, 39). The circulating levels of thymulin achieve maximal
values early in postnatal life and decline with age (40). More
recently, it has been shown that thymulin secretion follows a circadian
rhythm, peaking during the night (41). The general characteristics of
thymulin and its effects on the immune system are summarized in Table 1
. For recent reviews on the various
thymic hormones, see Refs. 34, 35, 36 .
|
(IFN-
), which can induce MHC class II expression by
cultured TEC (42, 43, 44) as well as the expression of ECM ligands and
receptors, with consequent modulation of TEC-thymocyte adhesion (44, 45). Figure 3
|
Macrophages and DCs are hematopoietic-derived cell types and quantitatively are a minor component of the thymic microenvironment. Dendritic cells are preferentially located in the medulla and at the corticomedullary junction of the thymic lobules, whereas macrophages are distributed throughout the lobule (5); they both express MHC class II molecules and can interact with differentiating thymocytes via membrane proteins and cytokines, including IL-1.
Concerning the constitution of the intrathymically generated T cell repertoire, there is strong evidence that dendritic cells of the thymic microenvironment are involved in determining negative selection of the T cell repertoire by thymocyte deletion (13). In contrast, a role for macrophages in negative selection remains to be conclusively demonstrated.
C. Heterogeneity of the thymic epithelium: the thymic nurse cell
complex
The thymic epithelial network is a rather heterogeneous
tissue in terms of morphology and phenotype, and cells in different
locations within the thymic lobules may be responsible for influencing
specific steps in T cell maturation (46). One cortically located
lymphoepithelial complex, the thymic nurse cell (TNC), has been
isolated in vitro. TNCs are lymphoepithelial multicellular
structures formed by one TEC, which in mice can harbor 20200
thymocytes (47), and are located in the cortical region of thymic
lobules (48, 49). Most intra-TNC lymphocytes bear the
CD4+CD8+ double-positive
phenotype (50), although immature double-negative as well as mature
single-positive cells can also be found. Interestingly, TNCs may create
special microenvironmental conditions for thymocyte differentiation
and/or proliferation, and within this complex distinct interactions
apparently occur, including those mediated by soluble products, gap
junctions, ECM, and MHC/TCR (reviewed in Ref. 51). Self-antigens appear
to be presented to thymocytes within TNC (52), and intra-TNC lymphocyte
apoptosis has recently been reported (53, 54). Once settled in culture,
TNCs spontaneously release thymocytes, and TNC-derived epithelial cells
can reconstitute lymphoepithelial complexes after being cocultured with
fetal thymocytes (55). Thus, TNCs constitute an in vitro
model of thymocyte migration within the TEC context (18, 19, 45, 51, 56).
Other experimental models have been used to dissect the sequence of acquisition/loss of differentiation markers, as well as their respective roles in intrathymic T cell differentiation. A significant contribution was the generation of genetically engineered mice (57). The in vitro model of fetal thymus organ cultures (FTOC) is also used to study intrathymic T cell differentiation. By day 14 of gestation, only immature CD4-CD8- thymocytes are seen, whereas after a 14-day culture of the thymic lobes, differentiation has progressed with the generation of CD4+ or CD8+ single-positive mature cells (58).
As detailed below, the various intrathymic cellular interactions as well as the in vivo and in vitro experimental models summarized above can be regarded as potential targets for control by hormones and neuropeptides.
| III. Neuroendocrine Control of Membrane Interactions Between Thymocytes and Microenvironmental Cells |
|---|
|
|
|---|
secretion and in the number of cells expressing the
corresponding mRNA was observed in vitro (6- to 10-fold more
cells in GH-treated patients than in controls). In the same study, it
was demonstrated that such effects require the presence of autologous
antigen-presenting cells. Given the enhancing effect of GH upon IFN-
production, together with the cytokine-induced up-regulation of MHC
class I and class II expression (42, 43, 44) and the role played by
adhesion molecules of thymic microenvironmental cells in MHC-TCR
interactions (45, 55), we suggest that the MHC-mediated influence on
thymocyte differentiation may be modulated by fluctuations in GH. This
suggestion remains a working hypothesis and should be tested in
specifically designed experiments. More direct evidence, recently reported by Sacedon and co-workers (61, 62, 63), showed an effect of glucocorticoid hormones. Thymic dendritic cells treated in vitro with dexamethasone exhibited a slight, yet consistent, increase in the membrane expression of MHC class I molecules. This seems to be specific to class I, since no effect was observed on the expression of MHC class II gene products.
The same research group showed earlier expression of MHC class I and II molecules during thymus ontogeny in rat fetuses whose mothers had been previously adrenalectomized (52). It should be noted that before full development of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis, circulating glucocorticoids in the fetus are strictly of maternal origin. Thus, what these experiments tell us is that absence of circulating glucocorticoids in early fetal life accelerates intrathymic MHC expression. Although in this particular work double labeling for simultaneous detection of MHC and cytokeratin was not reported, the micrographs, showing MHC labeling in the whole microenvironmental network, led us to think that the thymic epithelial network may include MHC expression. This idea is supported by the authors finding of earlier detection of other known markers for TEC differentiation in fetal thymuses derived from adrenalectomized mothers.
Thus, the findings discussed above argue in favor of hormonal regulation of MHC expression by the thymic microenvironment. Yet, formal demonstration of a hormonal regulation of MHC expression by TEC is still lacking. Nor has the possible influence of hormones and neuropeptides on intrathymic MHC expression been approached in terms of its consequences on MHC-TCR interactions.
B. Extracellular matrix-mediated TEC-thymocyte interactions are
hormonally modulated
Initial studies revealed that the intrathymic production of
ECM proteins, including fibronectin, laminin, and type IV collagen, was
enhanced in vivo in mice injected with hydrocortisone;
thickened ECM-containing fibrils were observed in both cortical and
medullary regions of the thymic lobules as early as 24 h
posttreatment. In the protocol of a single dose injection, this effect
was transient, being progressively reversed in parallel with thymocyte
expansion. Additionally, augmented amounts of such ECM components were
detected in mouse TEC cultures treated with glucocorticoid hormone
(64), indicating that the effect of hydrocortisone enhancing ECM in the
thymus represents direct activity on the thymic epithelium. Similar
results were obtained with sex steroids (64). At variance with these
data, however, it was reported that the levels of fibronectin
[measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA)] in human TEC
culture supernatants were not altered after hydrocortisone treatment
(65). Considering that this steroid hormone was also shown to enhance
ECM receptor on the TEC membranes (18), it is possible that the lack of
modulation in the supernatant derives from the augmented levels of the
ECM bound on the TEC surface stimulated by hydrocortisone, which would
then mask the levels in the culture supernatants.
In a further study, long-term treatment (30 days) with T3 in mice also yielded changes in the intrathymic distribution profile of ECM proteins, with an increase in thin ECM fibrils (thus differing from the thick fiber pattern seen after glucocorticoid injection), particularly in the cortical region of thymic lobules. Again, such an effect seems to be direct upon TEC, since enhanced ECM production was also seen when T3 was added to cultures of a murine TEC line and to TNC-derived TEC preparations (66). More recently, similar results were obtained in vitro when various TEC cultures were subjected to PRL, GH, or insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) (56). It should be pointed out that, regarding the in vitro models mentioned above, not only were the amounts of fibronectin and laminin enhanced by various hormone treatments, but also was the expression of their corresponding receptors, VLA-5 and VLA-6 (56, 66).
Since thymocyte-TEC adhesion is at least partially mediated by ECM
ligands and receptors, we also tested the various hormones cited above,
corticosteroid, thyroid, and pituitary hormones, for their ability to
modulate such heterotypic cellular interaction. All enhanced the degree
of thymocyte adhesion to cultured TEC. Furthermore, regarding pituitary
hormones (56), the hormone-induced enhancement of TEC-thymocyte
adhesion was abrogated by monoclonal antibodies specific for each
hormone or its corresponding receptor, and also by various anti-ECM or
anti-ECM receptor antibodies (Fig. 4
).
|
C. Are inter-TEC gap junctions under neuroendocrine
control?
Very recent data indicate that gap junctions mediating
communication between adjacent TEC can also be under hormonal control.
Decreased cell coupling between adjacent TEC (ascertained by diffusion
of intracellularly injected low molecular weight fluorochrome) was seen
when cultures were treated by the sex steroids testosterone,
progesterone, and estrogen, as well as by the pituitary hormones ACTH
and GH, and the neuropeptide calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) and
substance Y (67, 68). Conversely, results from our laboratory indicate
that vasointestinal peptide (VIP), a neuropeptide that increases
intracellular cAMP, enhances inter-TEC cell coupling (69). Similar
enhancement was seen when cultures were treated with glucocorticoid
hormones, an effect that was significantly abrogated by the use of the
glucocorticoid receptor antagonist RU486 (70). Nevertheless, a
systematic survey to determine which hormones and neuropeptides
modulate gap junction opening between adjacent TEC and between TEC and
thymocytes has not yet been made. Nor are data so far available
concerning putative neuroendocrine control of connexin expression
by TEC.
| IV. Thymic Endocrine Function and Cytokine Secretion by Microenvironmental Cells Are Controlled by Hormones and Neuropeptides: The Paradigm of Thymulin |
|---|
|
|
|---|
, IL-6, and IL-7 (71). The production of IL-1
and IL-1ß by bovine nonepithelial thymic microenvironmental cells
in vitro was increased by exogenous GH and by PRL (72). It
was further shown that secretion of IL-6 is also up-regulated by GH or
by PRL treatment, an effect that could be abrogated by the use of the
IL-1 receptor antagonist. This indicates that hormonal effects on
microenvironmental cell-derived IL-6 secretion are at least partially
exerted through the IL-1 production pathway. Autocrine/paracrine
control of cytokine production by the thymic microenvironment appears
to involve TEC-derived neuropeptides as well. Martens and colleagues
(73) demonstrated that the constitutive production of both IL-6 and LIF
(but not IL-1ß) by primary cultures of human TEC was enhanced when
monoclonal antibodies to oxytocin were added to the cultures. This
strongly suggests that the secretion of these TEC-derived cytokines is
partially under the control of oxytocin. Together, the findings discussed above strongly favor the notion that cytokine production by the thymic microenvironment is under neuroendocrine control. Nonetheless, such a notion should be cautiously viewed since corresponding in vivo data are still lacking. In this respect, evaluation of cytokine production by the microenvironmental cells in mice genetically engineered for hyperproduction or lack of hormones or neuropeptides will be certainly worthwhile. The same is true for more precise analysis of IL-7 and of SCF production by thymic microenvironmental cells under various hormonal fluctuations.
B. Thyroid and pituitary hormone status modulates
thymulin secretion
The concept of neuroendocrine control of thymic secretory
substances has been particularly developed with regard to the
production of the thymic hormone thymulin. In a first series of studies
we demonstrated that in vivo treatment with
T3 enhanced thymulin secretion by mouse TEC, and
that an opposite effect was seen if the animals were treated with
propiothiouracil, an inhibitor of thyroid hormone synthesis (74). These
results were confirmed by others (75). In aging mice, injection of
T4 increased thymulin serum levels to values
found in young individuals (75). In humans, it was shown that patients
with hyperthyroidism exhibit higher levels of circulating thymulin,
whereas in hypothyroidism the opposite was observed. In both
situations, adequate therapy brought thymulin serum levels within
normal range (76).
Experiments using TEC cultures showed that the stimulatory effect of thyroid hormones upon thymulin secretion was due to a direct action of the hormone on the epithelial cells (66) and depended on de novo synthesis of thymulin, since it could be abrogated by cycloheximide (77).
Pituitary hormones were also shown to be potent up-regulators of thymulin secretion. For instance, experimental hyperprolactinemia induced by repeated PRL injections increased thymulin levels in both young and old animals. Conversely, administration of bromocriptine, an agonist of the dopamine receptor, which inhibits PRL biosynthesis, promoted a consistent, dose-dependent decrease in thymulin production (78). These results, obtained in mice, are in keeping with data derived from hyperprolactinemic patients bearing pituitary adenomas, who present abnormally high thymulin serum levels (79).
Fluctuations in GH levels also modulate thymulin secretion. Initial studies revealed that dwarf mice exhibit a precocious decay in thymulin levels (80). This is in keeping with more recent data showing that hypophysectomy in rats yielded a profound, although transient, decrease in thymulin serum levels (81). Similarly, low thymulin levels accompanied deficient GH production in children, whereas GH treatment consistently restored this thymic endocrine function, as early as 24 h after injection (82, 83). Moreover, GH treatment induced an increase in thymulin serum levels that correlated with the amounts of circulating IGF-I. In acromegalic patients, high thymulin serum titers also correlated with high IGF-I serum levels (84).
It is noteworthy that the enhancing effects of PRL and GH on thymulin secretion were directly obtained by treating murine or human TEC cultures and were abrogated by corresponding antihormone antibodies (78, 84). In vitro GH effects were abrogated by anti-IGF-I or anti-IGF-I receptor antibodies, thus incriminating TEC-derived IGF-I as a mediator of the GH effects upon TEC (84). This was further supported by findings that both anti-IGF-I and anti-IGF-I receptor antibodies were also able to block GH-dependent enhancement of TEC-thymocyte adhesion (56).
In addition to the effects observed with classical peptidic hormones, we found that endogenous opioids, namely ß-endorphin and Leu-enkephalin, can up-regulate thymulin secretion by cultured TEC (85). In vivo experiments to confirm this notion are still lacking, however. Nor are data available to define whether other neuropeptides influence thymulin secretion.
C. Effects of adrenalectomy and gonadectomy on thymulin levels
The effects of adrenal and gonadal steroids on thymulin secretion
appear to be rather more complex. One of the experimental strategies to
approach this issue is ablation of the adrenals and/or gonads. When a
single surgery (adrenalectomy or gonadectomy) was performed, we
observed in both male and female mice a transient fall in thymulin
serum levels that lasted 1 month, peaking 1 week postsurgery, and then
progressively returning to normal. More impressive, adrenalectomy +
castration resulted in a long-term decrease in the levels of
circulating thymulin that persisted until 3 months postsurgery, being
followed by gradual restoration to normal levels by 6 months after
surgery (86). Interestingly, in both single and double surgical
procedures, an increase in the intrathymic content of thymulin was
seen. Concomitant to the sustained low levels of the thymic hormone in
these experimental conditions, an endogenous low molecular weight
thymulin inhibitor was transiently detected in the mouse sera, with
concentrations peaking when thymulin levels were lowest. Although the
biochemical nature of such a thymulin inhibitor was not defined, its
appearance was thymus dependent, since it was not found in mice
undergoing thymectomy before adrenalectomy + gonadectomy (86). This
series of experiments, although not conclusive, pointed to a rather
complex mechanism involved in in vivo steroid hormone
influence upon thymic hormone production, possibly comprising other
biological circuits, including the hypothalamus-pituitary axis.
This possibility led us to study the influence of steroid hormones on murine and human TEC cultures, and we observed that physiological concentrations of glucocorticoid hormones, estradiol, progesterone, or testosterone, enhanced thymulin release into the culture supernatants. This effect was abrogated when TEC were simultaneously incubated with a given steroid hormone plus the specific antagonist of the corresponding hormone receptor (87).
In view of these findings, it is possible that the transient in vivo increase in the intrathymic contents of thymulin observed after adrenalectomy and/or gonadectomy corresponds to a TEC response to the fall in circulating levels of biologically active thymulin, secondary to the appearance of its natural inhibitor. Such a feedback circuit with increase in thymulin production had been previously shown in mice treated with antithymulin monoclonal antibodies (88).
D. Is there an autocrine/paracrine circuitry controlling thymulin
secretion?
That in vivo treatment of mice with antithymulin
monoclonal antibodies resulted in an increase in the intrathymic
content of the hormone suggested that the level of circulating thymulin
could influence its rate of secretion. Similarly, in keeping with these
findings, we noted that incubation of cultured TEC with antithymulin
monoclonal antibodies resulted in increased numbers of
thymulin-containing cells (89). Conversely, thymulin release into TEC
culture supernatants can be down-regulated by exogenous addition of the
hormone itself.
Interestingly, IL-1, which is also produced in vivo and in vitro by TEC, is able to stimulate in vivo zinc uptake by the thymus (likely to be due to the increase in metallothionein biosynthesis by the epithelial cells), thus up-regulating thymulin secretion in vitro (90, 91).
Altogether, the data discussed above clearly indicate that the general control of thymulin secretion may be very complex, involving distinct biological circuits whose overall balance will dictate the amounts of thymulin to be secreted at a given moment. Due to this apparent complexity, it is predictable that compensatory loops may be triggered when one or more thymulin-controlling axes are disturbed. This would explain why in some experimental situations, fluctuations in thymulin serum levels are transient.
E. Thymic hormones modulate endocrine glands and neuroendocrine
circuits
The concept of bidirectionality between the neuroendocrine and
immune systems can also be applied to analysis of thymic hormones,
since these substances modulate the production of hormones and
neuropeptides of the hypothalamus-pituitary axis and some of their
target endocrine glands.
Initial experiments revealed that neonatal thymectomy promotes developmental atrophy of female sexual organs (92). One might argue that such an effect could reflect an autoimmune process rather than a direct action of thymic hormones on the neuroendocrine system. This assumption is based on the fact that perinatal thymectomy in BALB/c mice induces autoimmune disease (93). Nevertheless, in the experiments supporting this view, thymectomy was performed on day 3 postnatally, when the thymus has already released a significant amount of thymocytes (initiated on the day of birth). By contrast, in the former experiments, thymectomy was carried out at birth, thus before colonization of peripheral lymphoid organs by T cells. Moreover, as detailed below, it has been shown that production of sex steroids is enhanced in vivo and in vitro by a single thymic hormone, thymulin.
In addition to the action on sexual organs, thymectomy at birth promoted a decrease in the number of secretory granules in acidophilic cells of the adenopituitary (94). This is in keeping with data showing that athymic nude mice exhibit significantly low levels of various pituitary hormones, including PRL, GH, LH, and FSH (95).
Regarding the effects of thymic peptides, it was shown that thymosin-ß4, when perfused intraventricularly, stimulates in vivo LH and its hypothalamic-releasing hormone LHRH (96). A similar stimulation of LH release was obtained with thymulin in perifused or fragmented pituitary preparations (97, 98). Another thymosin component, the MB-35 peptide, also enhanced PRL and GH production (99). In vivo studies in children showed that administration of thymopoietin increases GH and cortisol serum levels (100). Moreover, thymopentin (the synthetic biologically active peptide of thymopoietin) enhanced in vitro the production of POMC derivatives such as ACTH, ß-endorphin, and ß-lipotropin (101). Thymulin exhibited a similar in vitro stimulatory effect on perifused rat pituitaries, enhancing the release of GH, PRL, and, to a lesser extent, TSH (102). With regard to its effect on GH release, it has been shown to be age-dependent, being less efficient in pituitary cell cultures derived from senescent animals (103). The same study showed that this effect of thymulin is mediated by calcium influx, as well as cAMP and inositol phosphate (103). However, contrasting results were reported using short-term cultures of pituitary fragments: a consistent increase in ACTH secretion after in vitro thymulin treatment, with no changes in GH levels but a significant inhibition of PRL release (98).
Thymosin-
1 was apparently able to down-regulate TSH, ACTH, and PRL
secretion in vivo, although effects on GH levels were not
detected (104). Interestingly, these inhibitory effects seem to occur
through hypothalamic pathways, since production of corresponding
releasing hormones by hypothalamic neurons was also decreased after
in vitro treatment of medial basal hypothalamic fragments
with thymosin-
1 (105).
In addition to affecting the hypothalamus-pituitary axis, thymic
hormones may act directly on its target endocrine glands (Fig. 5
). In vitro experiments
showed that thymulin can modulate gonadal tissues. Proliferation of
oogonia from fetal rat ovaries, as well as gonocytes from fetal rat
testicles, was consistently increased in the presence of thymulin
(106, 107, 108). At least regarding the expansion of male germ cells in the
same culture system, thymulin-inducing proliferative effects were
largely prevented by TGF-ß1 (109).
|
1
or thymulin, thus suggesting the involvement of other TEC-derived
hormone(s) or cytokine(s), which have not yet been identified.
At variance with these results are the recent data showing that
in vivo injection of thymulin in mice enhanced circulating
progesterone levels, which is likely to account for the delay in the
vaginal opening seen in thymulin-treated animals (111). In keeping with
this finding, studies conducted in boars showed that thymulin increases
testosterone levels in vitro and in vivo,
enhancing the secretion of testosterone in short-term cultures of
testicular minces. Additionally, testosterone-circulating levels were
enhanced 23 h postinjection (112) only in those animals previously
selected for having spontaneous high levels of circulating LH. The
authors suggested that the effects of thymulin upon testosterone
secretion occur via the action of LH on Leydig cells. Although further
studies are obviously necessary to better dissect the role of thymulin
in reproductive physiology, the data discussed above generally favor
this hypothesis. It should be pointed out that the existence of direct effects of thymic hormones upon other endocrine glands that are physiological targets of the hypothalamus-pituitary axis, such as thyroid and adrenals, has not yet been studied.
Recent work has shown that thymulin can also modulate some peripheral
nervous sensory functions, such as those related to pain sensitivity.
In vivo injections of thymulin at high doses significantly
reduced the hyperalgesia (related to both mechanical and thermal
nociceptors) induced by intraplantar injection of endotoxin in rats and
mice (113). Interestingly, when applied at much lower doses, this
peptide instead generated hyperalgesia, an effect paralleled by a
significant enhancement in the intrahepatic production of IL-1ß
(114). Such paradoxical effects are in keeping with previous data
showing that low doses of thymulin enhance IL-1ß secretion by
peripheral blood cells, whereas, at high concentrations, thymulin
suppresses its release as well as that of IL-2, IL-6, and TNF-
(115). More recently, the cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in
the thymulin-induced hyperalgesic effect have been further
investigated. In the peripheral nervous system, the involvement of
capsaicin-sensitive primary afferent neurons has been revealed.
Intraperitoneal injection of capsaicin (known to destroy afferent
nervous fibers) significantly abrogated the stimulatory thymulin effect
on pain (116). Additionally, spinal cord neurons appear to be involved,
since thymulin induces sustained expression of c-fos (a
marker of spinal cord neuron activation) in those neurons known to be
involved in nociception (117). It should be noted, however, that, in
spite of these convincing data, the molecular basis for thymulin action
on neurons is not complete, since thymulin receptors in neurons have
not yet been determined.
Some data also indicate that other thymic hormones may exert a
modulatory role in the central nervous tissue, including an effect on
behavioral functions. In vivo injection of a thymopentin
analog in rats was shown to counteract the stress response to
experimentally induced social defeat (118), as measured in the elevated
plus-maze apparatus, a recognized animal model of anxiety (119).
Although the mechanism(s) involved in this thymopentin-mediated event
were not characterized, direct action of the thymic hormone analog on
the cholinergic innervation of the hypothalamus with consequent
inhibition of CRF release was suggested (118). Such a putative direct
anxiolytic effect of the thymopentin analog is further supported by
previous data showing that injections of thymopentin normalize the
numbers of benzodiazepine and
-aminoisobutyric acid receptors
in the hippocampus after stress (120). It is also noteworthy that
neonatal thymectomy modulates the densities of nicotinic cholinergic
receptors in skeletal muscle and brain (121).
For further details on the relationship between thymic hormones and the neuroendocrine system, including behavioral adaptive responses, see Refs. 122, 123 .
| V. Proliferation of Thymic Cells Is Hormonally Influenced |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A recent work suggested that TEC growth might also be under the control of thymic hormones. It was shown that thymopentin induces DNA synthesis in human TEC lines, either alone or in conjunction with FCS (126). Further studies using the complete thymopoietin molecule, in conjunction with similar assays using other thymic hormones, are necessary, however, to establish the concept of thymic hormone control of TEC growth.
Data are also scarce concerning the effects of steroid hormones on TEC proliferation. An apparent decrease in the proliferation rate was seen in a rat TEC line after treatment with progesterone, estrogens, or androgens, an effect probably mediated by protein kinase C (127). A similar inhibitory effect was seen with cortisol (128).
Much less is known about the in vivo effect of these hormones on TEC growth. However, it was shown that injections of metaclopramide, which promotes hyperprolactinemia, increased the number of solid epithelial islands in adult rat thymuses (129).
In vivo, Scheiff and co-workers (130) provided morphometric evidence that thyroid hormones were also able to induce TEC proliferation. Nevertheless, we and others observed no significant in vitro growth effect of T3 using the model of a murine TEC line (66, 131). The reason for these apparently contrasting results is likely to lie in the distinct evaluation methodologies as well as the in vivo vs. in vitro situations.
B. Modulation of thymocyte proliferation by hormones and
neuropeptides
In vitro thymocyte proliferation can be stimulated by
supernatants of TEC cultures, whereas supernatants derived from
fibroblast cultures have no effect. This thymocyte proliferative
activity of TEC-derived supernatants was almost completely abolished by
the presence of antithymulin monoclonal antibodies, but was enhanced
when TEC were treated with T3. By contrast, in
the same study, T3 did not directly influence
thymocyte proliferation, as ascertained by short-term thymidine
incorporation (132).
More recently, similar proliferative effects were seen using
supernatants from PRL- or GH- treated TEC cultures (133, 134).
Additionally, as depicted in Fig. 6
, bottom panel, GH itself synergized with anti-CD3 in its
stimulatory effect on thymocyte proliferation (135). This is in keeping
with recent data showing that transgenic mice that overexpress GH or GH
releasing hormone exhibit overgrowth of the thymus (136).
|
Further hormonal mediators are involved in the general control of thymocyte proliferation. For example, mitogen-induced human thymocyte expansion was blocked in the presence of anti-LH-RH serum, suggesting that intrathymically produced LH-RH may act as a costimulatory factor for thymocyte growth (140). At least in some experimental conditions, PRL also appears to be effective in directly stimulating thymocyte proliferation by enhancing IL-2 production and IL-2 receptor expression (141). This is keeping with data suggesting that PRL may play the role of a T cell growth factor, since it induces gene expression of cyclins D2 and D3 in the rat thymic lymphoma cell line Nb2 (142).
Proliferation of cultured human thymocytes was also directly stimulated in vitro by met-enkephalin, whereas VIP promoted an inhibitory effect, as compared with control untreated cultures, in both conditions of spontaneous and of phytohemagglutinin-induced mitogenesis (143). Similarly, somatostatin prevented concanavalin A-induced rat thymocyte proliferation (144). Another neuropeptide, CGRP, also inhibited mitogen-induced thymocyte proliferation, an effect that was abrogated in the presence of its antagonist CGRP837 (145).
Using the model of fetal thymus organ cultures, we recently
demonstrated that expansion of thymocytes could be stimulated by
insulin (146). Yet, since this is a complex heterocellular model, it
remains to be determined whether the proliferative insulin effects are
direct on the thymocytes or are mediated through microenvironmental
cells. Tables 2
and 3
summarize the vast series of in
vitro experiments concerning modulation of TEC or thymocyte
proliferation by hormones and neuropeptides.
|
|
Injection of T3 also promoted a consistent increase in thymocyte numbers with enhancement of spontaneous ex vivo [H3]thymidine incorporation (66).
Administration of synthetic TRH was also shown to enhance bromodeoxyuridine uptake by thymic cell suspensions (152). More recently, the same group showed in the rat model that such an effect could be seen in vivo, provided TRH was injected in the morning. In addition to confirming the previous data, these results reflect a time of day dependency for a physiological effect of TRH on thymocyte proliferation (153). Female rats continuously treated with leuprolide, an LH-RH agonist, exhibited a consistent increase in thymus weight (154), while in vivo injections of met-enkephalin in mice also enhanced thymus weight and cellularity (155). The latter finding is in keeping with the above in vitro stimulatory effect of this opioid on thymocyte proliferation.
Finally, intrathymic implants of the pineal gland derived from young mice, into age-matched recipients, led to a remarkable long-term maintenance of thymic size and the cortico-medullary architecture in the latter, thus preventing physiological age-related thymus atrophy (156). This suggested an effect of melatonin, either favoring proliferation and/or partially preventing apoptosis. In keeping with these findings, melatonin injection partially prevented stress-induced thymic atrophy (157). More recently, the mechanism by which melatonin could exert such an antiapoptotic role was revealed, with the demonstration that melatonin down-regulates the expression of glucocorticoid receptor (158).
By contrast, hormones such as sex steroids appear to provide an inhibitory tonus on thymocyte proliferation (reviewed in Ref. 159). Castration in young adult male mice promoted a rapid wave of thymocyte proliferation in vivo, particularly in cortically located cells bearing the immature phenotypes CD4-CD8- and CD4+CD8+ (160). This is in keeping with previous findings that castration in old rats led to enhancement of thymus weight, an effect that was abrogated by androgen treatment of castrated animals (161).
Taken together, the data summarized above clearly indicate that distinct hormones and neuropeptides can convey positive and negative signals for thymocyte proliferation.
| VI. Hormonal Modulation of Intrathymic T Cell Differentiation |
|---|
|
|
|---|
in its
role of inducing IL-2 production (163), and substance P stimulated IL-2
synthesis by the mouse thymic lymphoma cell line EL-4 (164). By
contrast, VIP, PACAP27, and PACAP38 exerted an in vitro
inhibitory action on the production of some thymocyte-derived
cytokines, including IL-2, IL-4, and IL-10 (165, 166). Altogether,
these findings provide consistent evidence for a hormone/neuropeptide
balance in the control of cytokine production by thymocytes.
B. Changes in the T cell differentiation markers and TCR Vß
repertoire
As detailed above, hormones and neuropeptides can affect thymic
functions related to thymocyte differentiation. Thus, such
differentiation could also be a target for neuroendocrine control.
Implants of GH3 pituitary cells in aging rats increased total thymocyte
numbers and the percentage of CD3-bearing cells, with a parallel
decrease in the CD4-CD8-
double-negative thymocytes, which normally accumulate in the aging rat
thymus (147, 167). The role of GH in thymus development was further
supported by findings in GH-deficient dwarf mice. In addition to
the precocious decline in thymulin serum values (80), there was
progressive thymic hypoplasia with decreased numbers of
CD4+CD8+ double-positive
thymocytes. Such defects could be restored by prolonged treatment with
GH (168).
Injections of T3 promoted an increase, both in relative and absolute numbers of thymocytes bearing the CD44 marker (66), which is an ECM receptor of the proteoglycan family, with specificities for hyaluronate and to a lesser extent fibronectin and collagen. By contrast, administration of high doses of glucocorticoid hormones yielded a profound decrease in the percentages of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, with a relative increase in CD4-CD8- as well as CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ cells (169, 170). In vivo treatment of mice with estradiol also promoted a depletion in the absolute numbers of CD4+CD8+, CD4+CD8-, and CD4-CD8+ thymocytes, with a decrease in the proportion of double-positive cells and an increase in the percentage of double-negative as well as single-positive mature cells (171). A striking loss of the very immature CD3-CD4-CD8- cells was further demonstrated (172). Interestingly, the estrogen-induced thymic involution appeared to occur independently of glucocorticoids, since it was seen in adrenalectomized animals (170). In this same study, the proportions of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes in adrenalectomized estrogen-treated mice, although significantly lower than in control animals, were higher than those in hormone-treated mice not subjected to adrenalectomy.
Although considerable work is available concerning the
neuroendocrine control of T cell differentiation markers,
the influence of hormones and neuropeptides on shaping the
intrathymically generated T cell repertoire remains poorly studied.
However, the few data available point to such an influence. Mice
treated with estradiol exhibited a selective increase in the
percentages of CD4-CD8-
TCR+ thymocytes expressing Vß6, Vß8, or
Vß11 but not Vß3 gene products (173), thus promoting an imbalance
in the generation of the TCR repertoire of the double-negative
TCR+ cell lineage. Interestingly, an enhancement
of IL-1
mRNA was seen in parallel with the increase in
Vß8+ cells, in keeping with previous data
showing that this cytokine exerts a mitogenic effect on
Vß8+ thymocytes (173). More recently, release
of autoreactive T cells bearing the Vß3 or Vß11 phenotypes, with
autoreactivity to hepatocytes, was seen in mice injected with a single
dose of estradiol (174).
In rat lymphoma-derived Nb2 cells, PRL induced in vitro gene
expression of the TCR
chain, whereas the TCR ß chain gene was
suppressed (175), suggesting that the intrathymic PRL content may drive
T-cell differentiation pathways. In keeping with this hypothesis, it
has been demonstrated, not only in the Nb2 cell line but also in human
thymocytes, that in the absence of TCR ligation PRL induces rapid
phosphorylation of multiple TCR/CD3 complex proteins, including the CD3
-chain and the ZAP-70 tyrosine kinase, both essential for TCR
function (176). However, recent data argue against the above
hypothesis, since PRL receptor knockout mice apparently develop a
normal thymocyte differentiation pathway, at least in terms of CD3,
CD4, and CD8 markers (177, 178).
As detailed below, very elegant data strongly suggest that intrathymically produced glucocorticoids influence the generation of the T cell repertoire in the thymus by modulating positive and negative selection of thymocytes.
C. Hormone-mediated apoptosis in thymocytes
One of the best studied effects concerning the hormonal control of
intrathymic cell death is that mediated through glucocorticoid
hormones. When applied in relatively high doses, these substances
trigger an apoptotic cell machinery in differentiating thymocytes,
particularly cells bearing the immature
CD4+CD8+ phenotype. The
molecular basis of such a glucocorticoid hormone-induced biological
response is now known in detail and is used as a paradigm for studies
of apoptosis in various cell types (reviewed in Ref. 179). Briefly,
glucocorticoids activate calcium-dependent endonucleases that
eventually cleave DNA, with the formation of oligo-nucleosomes. A
series of findings suggest that such events are potentiated by cAMP
(180) and depend on the recently isolated transcription factor SRG3
(181). They do not require p53 tumor suppressor gene expression, which
has been shown to be necessary for triggering apoptosis in thymocytes
by contact with TEC or after radiation (182, 183). Oligonucleosomal DNA
fragmentation is preceded by the enzymatic degradation of lamin B1, a
protein involved in the nuclear lamina architecture (184).
Interestingly, glucocorticoid-induced thymocyte apoptosis also
modulates cytoplasmic processes, including thiol oxidation in
mitochondria (185), activation of the protease calpain (186), and
decrease in the intracellular K+ concentration
(187). The need for glucocorticoids to bind to the corresponding
receptor to induce apoptosis in thymocytes has been definitely
established by the demonstration that thymocytes from glucocorticoid
receptor null mice do not undergo apoptosis after the respective
hormonal treatment (188). In a recent study, it was further shown that
glucocorticoid-dependent apoptosis in thymocytes is mediated by
transactivation of the glucocorticoid receptor (189). This was
approached by constructing a point mutation in the glucocorticoid
receptor gene, able to abolish DNA binding-dependent transactivation,
and further generating mice expressing this mutant gene. Thymocytes
from these animals were resistant to dexamethasone-induced apoptosis,
thus showing that DNA binding of the glucocorticoid receptor is a
prerequisite for glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis.
Although the mechanism of glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis in thymocytes is relatively well known at the molecular level, a paradox remains to be understood: low doses of glucocorticoid hormones antagonized TCR-mediated apoptosis in thymocytes (190, 191) and partially rescued thymocytes from apoptosis induced by in vitro treatment of fetal thymus organ cultures with anti-CD3 antibodies (192). As further discussed below, this may be relevant for a physiological role of these substances in positive selection of the T cell repertoire. Thus, understanding the molecular control of these balancing effects demands further investigation.
Although less studied, sex steroids also appear to affect thymocyte
apoptosis. For example, injections of estradiol in rats promoted
cortical thymocyte depletion (193), with an increase in apoptosis
(ascertained by caryopyknosis) and a decrease in mitotic indexes
(194, 195, 196, 197) (see Table 2
).
A natural condition for studying the influence of sex steroids on thymocyte apoptosis is pregnancy, during which the thymus undergoes progressive and extensive involution with loss of CD4+CD8+ cells, partially due to apoptosis (198). Interestingly, this progressive thymic atrophy of pregnancy inversely correlates with the rise in circulating progesterone (199). Other hormones such as pituitary hormones and glucocorticoids could also be involved in this process.
Androgens, such as testosterone, also induce thymocyte death in vivo, by a mechanism independent of the glucocorticoid and estrogen receptors (200), but which requires specific androgen receptors since the effect is prevented by treatment with the antiandrogen drug flutamide. Since the levels of androgen receptor mRNA are 6-fold higher in TEC than in thymocytes, it was postulated that the induction of thymocyte apoptosis by androgens is mediated by TEC-derived products (200). The acceleration of thymocyte apoptosis by androgens was recently confirmed in vitro using thymic organ culture (201).
Studies in mice revealed that estrogen treatment also causes a dramatic
reduction in thymic size and cellularity. All CD4/CD8-defined T cell
subsets were reduced, particularly the
CD4+CD8+ double positive
cells. Examination of the
CD3-CD4-
CD8- subset revealed a striking loss of
developmental progression of the early precursor cells, since in
treated animals, this compartment was composed almost entirely of the
earliest population,
CD44+CD25-, with depletion
of cells in the remaining maturational stages,
CD44+CD25+,
CD44-CD25+, and
CD44-CD25- (202). It
should be recalled that in these studies, apoptosis was not
specifically checked with any of the present available tools.
Intriguingly, in the same work, the authors showed that estrogen
deprivation by oophorectomy did not enhance T cell development. Such a
paradox is further apparent in recent findings that estrogen receptor
knockout mice exhibit lower thymic cellularity compared with normal
or heterozygous littermates (203). In these animals, despite the
reduced cell numbers, thymocyte maturation stages were apparently
normal, as revealed by CD3, CD4, CD8, CD25, and CD44 labeling.
Nevertheless, their sensitivity to in vivo estradiol
treatment was distinct from wild or heterozygous age-matched
counterparts. While estrogen receptor null mice
underwent thymic
atrophy with estradiol treatment (thus similar to control animals), the
phenotypic differences in thymocyte subpopulations such as loss of
CD4+CD8+ cells, seen in
usual conditions of estradiol treatment, were not detected in mutant
mice. These findings point to a dichotomy of estradiol in terms of
influence on thymocyte numbers and differentiation. In fact, in the
same work, chimera experiments elegantly demonstrated that the
sensitivity to estradiol in terms of thymic atrophy was dependent on
the expression of the null mutation in the thymic microenvironment
rather than in thymocytes.
Protection from apoptosis may also be under neuroendocrine control. Dihydroepiandrosterone, for example, is apparently able to counteract at least in vivo thymocyte apoptosis induced by pharmacological doses of glucocorticoid hormones (204, 205).
Very few data are so far available concerning the role of pituitary hormones in modulating thymocyte apoptosis. Using the rat lymphoma Nb2 cell line, it was demonstrated that the apoptotic effect of dexamethasone was inhibited in a dose-dependent manner by PRL or GH (206), raising the hypothesis that a similar effect may occur with normal thymocytes. In fact, as regards PRL, this hypothesis fits with the data discussed above, showing that this hormone can trigger phosphorylation of TCR-related proteins (207).
The VIP also appears to play a role in protecting thymocytes from apoptosis induced by dexamethasone treatment in vitro. It inhibits the typical DNA fragmentation induced by glucocorticoids and increases cell survival, both effects being mediated through the VIP receptor (208).
The pineal neurohormone melatonin also appears to partially prevent apoptosis of rat thymocytes in vivo and in vitro, as defined by morphological criteria and DNA fragmentation seen in agarose gel electrophoresis (209). Similar findings were obtained in aging mice, where thymus atrophy was partially prevented by long-term melatonin treatment or pineal grafting (210). As mentioned above, this antiapoptotic effect of melatonin is likely to be, at least in part, due to down-regulation of the glucocorticoid receptor (158).
These data indicate that neuroendocrine-mediated regulation of thymocyte apoptosis does exist, facilitating or preventing the cells to enter a programmed pathway of cell death. They favor the notion that negative vs. positive selection of the T cell repertoire within the thymus may be under the control of a neuroendocrine homeostatic axis involving various hormones and neuropeptides. Consequently, it should be important to define to what extent such neuroendocrine circuits influence shaping of the intrathymically generated T cell repertoire.
| VII. Is Thymocyte Traffic Under Neuroendocrine Control? |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A second example is dexamethasone and hydrocortisone enhancement of the in vitro migration of bone marrow-derived progenitor cells into the thymus (213). Additionally, in vivo treatment of rats with estradiol enhanced permeability of cortical blood vessels (214), which may facilitate the entry of pro-thymocytes. However, this issue has not yet been experimentally approached.
It has been reported that the lack of maternal glucocorticoids in the progeny of adrenalectomized pregnant rats accelerates early colonization of the thymic primordium by lymphoid progenitors (62, 63). As previously discussed herein, this is probably related to the earlier maturation of the thymic microenvironment seen in this particular experimental condition.
B. Modulation of thymocyte traffic in TNCs
Intrathymic lymphocyte traffic also appears to be under
neuroendocrine control. Spontaneous as well as phorbol ester-induced
in vitro mobility of thymocytes was shown to be inhibited by
VIP and the two pituitary adenylcyclase-activating polypeptides
(PACAP27 and PACAP38), an effect paralleled by a rise in cAMP
concentration (215). Whether these neuropeptides change the expression
of membrane receptors related to cell migration remains to be
determined.
Considering that ECM plays a role in intrathymic cell migration (17), and since various hormones could up-regulate the expression of ECM ligands and receptors (56, 66), we investigated whether thyroid and pituitary hormones could be involved in TEC-thymocyte interactions related to cell migration. One key interaction is the heterotypic adhesion of thymocytes to epithelial cells. As discussed above, we demonstrated that these hormones up-regulate TEC-thymocyte adhesion, as ascertained by direct counting under the optical microscope or by ELISA using CD90 (the Thy.1 antigen) as a membrane marker for thymocytes (56, 66). With regard to PRL and GH, the hormonal specificity of this effect was confirmed since respective antihormone antibodies could block it, totally or partially. We also noted that the GH-enhancing effects were prevented by anti-IGF-I or anti-IGF-I receptor antibodies. The involvement of ECM-mediated interactions was further demonstrated since the hormone-enhancing effects on TEC-thymocyte adhesion were also abrogated by antibodies with specificities for fibronectin, laminin, and their respective receptors, VLA-5 and VLA-6 (56, 216).
We further attempted to modulate a direct cell migration process,
namely the entrance of thymocytes into and their exit from TNCs. In a
first set of experiments (Fig. 7
), we
showed that thymocyte release from TNC complexes was accelerated if
these complexes were treated in vitro with
T3. Most importantly, when TNCs were harvested
from T3-treated mice, thymocyte release was also
faster than in controls (66). More recently, we observed that
when TNC-derived epithelial cells were treated with the thyroid
hormones and cocultured with fetal thymocytes, the ratio of
reconstitution of lymphoepithelial complexes was enhanced (our
unpublished results), indicating that the entrance of thymocytes into
TNC is also hormonally regulated. Further in vitro studies
revealed that both thymocyte release from TNC and TNC reconstitution
were consistently increased if cultures were subjected to PRL, GH, or
IGF-I (56).
|
ß to the spleen occurred earlier than in control fetuses
(63), suggesting that release of mature thymocytes is controlled, at
least in fetal life, by glucocorticoids. One direct strategy to evaluate thymocyte exit in adult animals is analysis of the so-called recent thymic emigrants. It is well established that intrathymic injection of fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) randomly labels the cell membranes of many thymocytes. This allows recovery of the FITC+ cells that have recently exited the thymus (217, 218). We observed, 16 h following a single intrathymic injection of T3, a consistent increase in the numbers of FITC+ cells in lymph nodes (219). Additionally, using a similar protocol, we noted that GH is also able to modulate the homing of recent thymic emigrants, enhancing the numbers of FITC+ cells in the lymph nodes and diminishing them in the spleen (220).
An in vivo model in which immature CD4+/CD8+ T cells were detected in peripheral lymphoid organs (thus reflecting an abnormal thymocyte exit) is that of transgenic mice with impaired corticosterone receptor function by partial knockout of the glucocorticoid receptor, secondary to endogenous expression of the corresponding antisense RNA (221). These animals showed disruption of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis, bearing abnormally high circulating levels of ACTH and corticosterone (222). The intrathymic levels of glucocorticoid receptor mRNA were 50% lower, and the ability of thymus extracts to bind hydrocortisone was reduced to one third of that in normal mice (221). In this respect, it is interesting to note that intrathymic expression of the antisense was restricted to thymocytes since the construct applied used the promoter from the thymocyte-specific thyrosine kinase lck.
Abnormal leakage of CD4+CD8+ cells was also detected in lymph nodes of the Snell Bagg dwarf mouse (168). This phenomenon progressed with age and paralleled the cortical thymocyte depletion found in dwarf mice. In those animals with dramatic loss of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, the percentages of CD3+CD4+CD8+ cells in the lymph nodes reached 50%. Importantly, both CD4+CD8+ thymocyte depletion and the abnormal presence of CD4+CD8+ cells in the periphery were restored after daily GH injection (168).
Lastly, it is noteworthy that release of immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes may also be under the influence of sex hormones. Adult rats treated with estradiol benzoate exhibited CD4+CD8+ in the spleen, which was related to increased vascular permeability of cortical blood vessels (223).
Taken together, the three models summarized above indicate that a disturbance in distinct neuroendocrine compartments may result in a partial imbalance of the process of thymocyte exit, allowing immature cells to emigrate from the organ. Considering the autoreactive potential of CD4+/CD8+ cells found in peripheral lymphoid organs from neonates of certain mouse strains (224), it is conceivable that a neuroendocrine-driven imbalance resulting in abnormal traffic of immature thymocytes toward peripheral lymphoid organs may favor the development of some autoimmune diseases.
It is worth emphasizing that the question of whether the neuroendocrine control of thymocyte migration occurs partially through the modulation of thymic microenvironment-derived chemokines has not been tested in any model and certainly represents a promising field for original investigation.
| VIII. Expression of Receptors for Hormones and Neuropeptides by Thymic Cells |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Receptors for sex steroids have also been demonstrated in animal and human thymus. Pioneer studies by Grossman and co-workers (236, 237, 238) showed, by binding assays, that specific receptors for estrogen, progesterone, and androgen are present particularly in thymic preparations obtained from nonlymphoid cells. Other groups confirmed the presence of androgen and progesterone receptors in TEC-enriched fractions (239, 240, 241, 242). In one study, a quantitative RT-PCR approach for detecting androgen receptor mRNA in the thymus showed 6-fold more mRNA in the TEC than in the thymocytes (243). Immunocytochemically based flow cytometry analysis of freshly isolated thymocytes revealed androgen receptor expression in all classes of CD4/CD8-defined thymocyte subsets, with the highest levels observed in the CD4-CD8- subset, including the most immature cells (244).
With respect to progesterone receptor, direct binding of peroxidase-coupled ligands onto thymus sections (245), as well as immunocytochemistry, revealed the colocalization of progesterone receptor-positive and estrogen receptor-positive cells with TEC-specific cytokeratin staining (246).
The expression of estrogen receptor in thymocytes was determined though binding assay (247), as well as by immunoblotting and flow cytometry (248). According to previous histochemical analyses obtained with human thymic specimens, the binding is located in the reticulo-epithelial stroma rather than the thymocytes (249).
More recently, a novel form of the human estrogen receptor, the ERß form, was cloned, and the corresponding mRNA was found in the thymus (250).
Initial observations indicated that thymocytes exhibit specific binding sites for thyroid hormones (251). Nuclear T3 receptors (NT3-R) were identified in both TEC and thymocytes by immunochemical approaches using a specific anti-NT3-R monoclonal antibody, revealing a 57-kDa protein similar to the NT3-R originally described in the liver. Although flow cytometry analysis defining the expression of NT3-R as a function of the degree of thymocyte differentiation is still lacking, in situ immunocytochemical labeling clearly showed that most thymocytes express this receptor (252).
Expression of NT3-R by the murine thymic epithelium was also determined in various TEC preparations including TNC and TEC lines. Interestingly, NT3-R expressed by TEC seems to be functional since the epitope recognized by the anti-NT3-R monoclonal antibody (mAb) was transiently down-regulated by treatment of TEC cultures with T3 (252). More recently, the presence of NT3-R was also demonstrated in cultured human TEC (our unpublished data).
B. Expression of PRL and GH receptors by thymocytes and TEC
Receptors for various pituitary hormones have also been defined in
distinct thymic cell types. Taking the PRL receptors as an example, we
first showed that they are expressed on TEC in situ and
in vitro, as defined by immunocytochemistry, immunoblotting,
and Northern blotting. Their functional activity was evidenced by
modulation of both thymulin production and TEC growth with appropriate
agonistic doses of anti-PRL receptor antibodies (253). Additionally,
PRL receptors were expressed by most thymocytes, independently of their
CD4/CD8-defined maturation stage. The receptor density on cell
membranes was enhanced after in vitro concanavalin A
mitogenic stimulation (254, 255). Interestingly, high levels of
circulating PRL, as occur in lactation, enhance the levels of PRL
receptors in thymic cells, as revealed by binding assay and
semiquantitative RT-PCR (256).
Expression of GH receptor by cultured human TEC was initially shown by means of binding assay (257) and more recently by immunocytochemistry and RT-PCR (258). This is in keeping with in situ immunocytochemical data in the avian thymus, showing colocalization of the GH receptor with epithelial cells, defined by cytokeratin labeling (259). Additionally, in situ hybridization studies in the rat thymus suggested epithelial labeling for the GH receptor mRNA (260).
GH receptor expression in murine thymocytes was particularly seen in the CD4-CD8- immature subset (261). Similar findings were made in human thymocytes in which GH receptor expression was mainly restricted to the very immature differentiation stage defined by the phenotype CD34+CD2+CD3-CD4-CD8- (258), suggesting that the direct effects of GH on thymocytes precede events related to the selection of the T cell repertoire. It should be noted, however, that in bovine fetal thymus, GH receptor was found in both CD4+ and CD8+ single positive thymocytes (262). Such differences can be ascribed to species specificity, the fact that the latter study was conducted in early stages of thymus development, and/or sensitivity to the distinct reagents used for detecting the GH receptor by flow cytometry.
Both the receptor and GH binding proteins were found in the thymus of mammalian and avian thymuses (259, 260).
C. Receptors for neuropeptides in thymic cells
Intrathymic expression of receptors for various
neuropeptides has been shown in thymocytes, with fewer studies carried
out in TEC and other components of the thymic microenvironment. This is
the case for oxytocin and vasopressin receptors, determined on
thymocyte-derived membrane preparations by means of ligand binding and
PCR (263, 264). GH-RH receptors have also been shown in rat thymocytes
by means of binding assay and direct coupling of the radioactive ligand
onto electrophoresed thymocyte-derived extracts, revealing two protein
bands (43 and 27 kDa) similar to those in pituitary gland-derived
preparations (265), whereas the TRH receptor has been shown in thymus
extracts by RT-PCR (266). The somatostatin receptor family has been
identified in mouse thymocytes, as ascertained by gene expression of
the receptor subtypes SSTR2A, SSTR2B, and SSTR3 (267). Autoradiographic
analysis of radioactive ligands directly bound to human thymus sections
indicated that the family is also present in TEC (268). This was
confirmed by various methodological strategies including binding assay
and RT-PCR (125). It was also demonstrated that somatostatin receptors
in human TEC are functional since both somatostatin and its analog
octreotide significantly inhibited in vitro the
proliferation of human TEC (125).
Receptors for endogenous opioids such as ß-endorphin and met-enkephalin have been shown by means of binding assays on membrane preparations from total thymus extracts (269). These findings confirmed previous data using the same methodological approach, revealing opioid receptors on thymocyte membranes (270). The presence of such receptors in thymic microenvironmental cells remains to be determined.
The expression of receptors for other neuropeptides has also been demonstrated in the thymus. For example, the mRNA coding for the VIP1 receptor was detected in thymocytes (271), particularly those bearing the most immature phenotype, the CD4-CD8- cells (272). Interestingly, if the expression of VIP1 receptor is constitutive, thymocytes can express the VIP2 receptor only after mitogenic stimulation with anti-CD3 antibodies (215). More recently, VIP1 receptor has been identified in human TEC by means of immunocytochemistry, cytofluorometry, RT-PCR, and Southern blotting (273). This receptor is functional since it stimulates cAMP production by cultured TEC, which is keeping with the in situ radiolabeling detection of VIP receptor in both cortex and medulla of the human thymus (274).
Receptors for other members of the VIP family, such as the PACAP peptides, have been identified by binding assay (275), although the same research group did not detect PACAP 27 binding sites in thymus autoradiographs (276). Binding sites for CGRP were also detected in thymocyte membranes (145); their presence in the thymic microenvironment has not been studied so far. More recently, the CGRP receptor was demonstrated biochemically and functionally in human TEC (273). Finally, melatonin-binding sites have been detected in thymocyte preparations as well (277, 278).
| IX. Intrathymic Expression of Hormones and Neuropeptides |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A. Intrathymic production of corticosterone: role in the shaping of
the T cell repertoire
Pioneer work by Ashwell and colleagues (279) revealed that not
only do TEC bear the enzyme machinery necessary for corticosteroid
biosynthesis, but, at least in the murine thymus, corticosterone is
actually produced by TEC. More recently, two independent research
groups confirmed these results. Additionally, by transfecting a target
cell with a plasmid containing two glucocorticoid-responsive elements
plus a luciferase reporter gene, the authors showed that secretion of
TEC-derived glucocorticoids was enhanced by ACTH and blocked by the
glucocorticoid receptor antagonist RU486 as well as two blockers of
corticosterone biosynthesis, trilostane and metyrapone (280).
Interestingly, in a further recent study, it was shown that, although
the whole set of steroidogenic enzymes and cofactors for the synthesis
of glucocorticoids could be detected in murine thymic tissue, intact
thymic architecture was necessary for glucocorticoid production, since
11ß-hydroxylase was not detected in irradiated thymus or in a TEC
line (281).
Since low or moderate doses of glucocorticoids were found to prevent
anti-CD3-induced apoptosis, it was hypothesized that thymus-derived
glucocorticoids might play a physiological role in positive selection
of the T cell repertoire. Addition of metyrapone (a selective
inhibitor of corticosteroid biosynthesis) to fetal thymus organ
cultures enhanced TCR-mediated thymocyte deletion, an effect that could
be reversed by exogenous addition of corticosterone to the cultures
(279). More recently, using the same model of fetal thymus organ
cultures from mice bearing transgenic
ßTCRs, it was shown that
thymus-derived glucocorticoid hormones prevent thymocyte apoptosis only
when the TCR is capable of recognizing the self-antigen/MHC complex
with sufficient avidity to normally undergo positive selection (192).
In a second vein, transgenic mice expressing antisense transcripts for
the glucocorticoid receptor exhibited thymic atrophy particularly due
to CD4+CD8+ cell depletion
and enhanced susceptibility to TCR-mediated apoptosis (282). When this
transgene is transferred into the MRL mice that spontaneously develop
autoimmunity, there is a decrease in the TCR-Vß bearing cells that
are otherwise positively selected, and such animals then exhibit lower
autoantibody production and milder symptoms of the autoimmune disease
(283).
Although dealing with transgenic animals, these findings indicate that, under normal conditions, endogenous glucocorticoids might prevent thymocyte apoptosis after TCR/peptide-MHC interaction. In fact, similar data were recently reported with nontransgenic normal syngeneic mice (284).
However, this issue deserves further investigation, since in other studies, it was found that RU 486, an antagonist of the glucocorticoid receptor, blocks anti-CD3 induced apoptosis in newborn-derived thymus organ cultures (285). Additionally, in vivo treatment with RU 486 in mice transgenic for one particular TCR able to recognize ovalbumin also prevented thymocyte apoptosis induced by specific antigen stimulation (286).
Whether other steroid hormones, including sex steroids, are produced intrathymically remains to be determined. This is a potentially important issue, given the well established sexual dimorphism of the immune response in normal and autoimmune conditions.
B. Expression of "classic" adenopituitary hormones by thymic
cells
The expression of PRL and GH by cells of the immune system,
including the thymus, has been extensively documented. Since most of
the data were recently reviewed (287), it will be only briefly
discussed herein.
PRL gene expression has been detected by distinct research groups in thymocyte-derived preparations (288, 289). The detection of a PRL-immunoreactive molecule (290, 291) indicates that thymocytes constitutively produce PRL. However, the possible roles of thymus-derived PRL and of microenvironmental cells in intrathymic PRL production remain to be investigated.
Intrathymic GH expression was defined by detection of the corresponding mRNA by in situ hybridization and the peptide by immunocytochemistry (292); positive signals were revealed in cortical epithelial cells and in septal phenotypically-undefined cells, but not in thymocytes. This contrasted with previous detection of GH mRNA and corresponding protein in rat thymocyte-derived preparations (265, 293), and with the detection of an immunoreactive, 22-kDa, biologically active GH from human thymocytes isolated ex vivo (137). More recently, we showed the production and secretion of GH by human thymocytes isolated ex vivo as well as in primary TEC cultures, using RT/PCR and immunoradiometric assays. GH gene expression by rat thymocytes is up-regulated by GH-RH (265), in keeping with the demonstration of Pit-1/GHF-1 transcription factor (which controls GH expression in the pituitary gland) in human thymic microenvironmental cells (294). Nevertheless, it should be mentioned that, as yet, no experimental data are available concerning whether GH production and release by distinct thymic cell types are under the same Pit-1/GHF-1-dependent control mechanism in normal conditions. Studies in dwarf mice showed that GH expression by thymocytes and bone marrow microenvironmental cells does not depend on Pit-1 (295, 296). From a functional point of view, it was found that thymocyte-derived GH can enhance thymocyte proliferation through an IGF-I-mediated circuit (137).
If the production of PRL and GH by thymic cells is well documented, evidence for intrathymic expression of other adenopituitary hormones is still scarce. An immunoreactive LH peptide was extracted from human thymocytes (140), and it was shown that PHA-stimulated mitogenic response of these cells was blocked in the presence of anti-LH antiserum. Additionally, immunocytochemical findings indicate that TSH, FSH, and ACTH may be produced within the thymus, particularly by the epithelial component (297, 298). The POMC gene also appears to be constitutively expressed in the thymus, as ascertained by Northern blotting, RT-PCR, and immunocytochemistry (299, 300, 301). The latter study, performed in the chicken thymus, indicated the presence of POMC in TEC and dendritic cells.
Despite the findings discussed above, further studies are needed to define whether these pituitary hormones are actually secreted intrathymically and how they are regulated. It is interesting that the degree of intrathymic hormone production can be disrupted in some pathological conditions, as exemplified by the high quantities of ACTH detected in some carcinoid tumors (302).
C. Is there a functional autocrine/paracrine IGF-I-mediated
circuitry in the thymus?
As partially discussed above, converging data now strongly
indicate that IGF-I is involved in the effects of GH on the thymus
(reviewed in Ref. 287): 1) control of thymulin secretion and
TEC/thymocyte adhesion by GH can be prevented in vitro by
treating TEC cultures with monoclonal antibodies specific for IGF-I or
IGF-I receptor (56, 84); and 2) IGF-I alone can replace GH in
stimulating thymulin production by cultured TEC and in increasing
TEC/thymocyte adhesion (56, 84). Moreover, the enhanced concanavalin-A
mitogenic response and IL-6 production by thymocytes observed in
GH-treated aging animals (162) can be detected in animals treated with
IGF-I (303). In the same vein, it was shown that cyclosporin A-induced
thymic atrophy was restored by in vivo treatment with
recombinant GH or IGF-I (148), and that IGF-I was able to induce
repopulation of the atrophic thymus from diabetic rats (304). Taken
together, these findings strongly suggest that GH triggers or enhances
a functional circuitry in the thymus involving IGF-I and its receptor,
thus implying the intrathymic production of these molecules. Recent
findings showing that exogenous or thymus-derived GH promotes thymocyte
proliferation via IGF-I production by these cells are noteworthy (137, 305). This is in keeping with the demonstration of IGF-I receptors in
thymocytes (306, 307).
In a second vein, we recently provided immunochemically based evidence regarding the expression of IGF-I and IGF-I receptor by murine and human TEC, as ascertained by immunocytochemistry, immunoblot, and immunodot analyses. Both molecules are constitutively expressed by TEC, but their densities can be increased after GH treatment (our unpublished data). However, recent findings in experiments using ribonuclease protection assay in human TEC extracts failed to detect mRNA for the IGF-I receptor (308). At present, we cannot explain such contrasting results. They may be due either to the methodology or to the samples used for running the various assays.
In any case, it remains plausible that GH up-regulates a functional IGF-I/IGF-I receptor circuitry in both lymphoid and microenvironmental compartments of the thymus. However, the relative contribution of thymus-derived vs. pituitary gland-derived GH to the regulation of IGF-I and its receptor in thymocytes or TEC is unknown at the moment.
IGF-I is not the only member of the insulin family expressed in the thymus. Immunocytochemical evidence suggests that IGF-II may be much more expressed intrathymically than IGF-I (309). Considering that IGF-II receptors have been shown in the rat and the human thymus (306, 308, 310), together with the demonstration of various IGF binding proteins in this tissue (308), the existence of an intrathymic biological circuit mediated by IGF-II and its receptor is also conceivable.
Insulin expression has also been demonstrated in the human thymus (311, 312) and confirmed in the mouse along with other pancreatic hormones (313, 314). Particularly in the mouse, we showed that insulin expression is restricted to thymic dendritic cells (313). This was further confirmed by RT-PCR in studies using FTOC, in which insulin gene expression was not found in MHC class II-positive TEC (315). By contrast, other "classic" pancreatic hormones, such as glucagon and somatostatin, appear to be expressed intrathymically by macrophages (313). It is noteworthy that in the NOD mouse (that spontaneously develops autoimmune insulin-dependent diabetes), there is a decrease in the expression of the proinsulin genes, as compared with normal mouse strains, whereas no changes were observed in glucagon or somatostatin (316). This finding raised the hypothesis that decreased intrathymic expression of insulin might favor the escape of thymocytes potentially able to recognize insulin in the periphery.
D. Neuropeptide expression by the thymic microenvironment
One of the first demonstrations of intrathymic production of
neuropeptides was the observation of vasopressin and oxytocin, as well
as of their corresponding mRNA transcripts, in the human thymus (317).
Further work established the thymic epithelium (including TNCs) as a
source of these neurohormones both in vivo and in
vitro (318, 319, 320). Moreover, in the thymus, the biosynthesis of
oxytocin and arginine-vasopressin also results from cleavage of
corresponding neurophysins, similar to what happens in the hypothalamus
(321). Whether these hormones are actually secreted has not been
determined. Recent biochemical and ultrastructural findings suggest
that after processing, oxytocin is directly exported to the surface
membrane rather than directed to secretory vesicles (322). This finding
indicates that, at least in part, fragments of these peptidic hormones
are presented to differentiating thymocytes in the context of the MHC
molecules expressed on the TEC surface. From a conceptual viewpoint, in
addition to being paracrinally secreted, intrathymic expression of
peptidic hormones may also be related to negative selection of those
thymocytes that could potentially recognize these molecules in the
periphery of the immune system, causing antihormone T cell
autoreactivity.
In addition to "classical" neurohypophyseal hormones, neuropeptides typically found and secreted in the hypothalamus have been detected in thymic cells. Using ligand binding as well as ELISA, LH-RH was found in human thymocytes (140). It is noteworthy that the control of thymic LH-RH may differ from what occurs in the hypothalamus. As studied in rats, an increase in the LH-RH contents in the thymus after castration was found, and such an increase was prevented by testosterone replacement (323). This contrasted with the decrease in the hypothalamic contents of LH-RH in castrated animals.
The intrathymic production of CRH has also been demonstrated by several experimental approaches (324, 325, 326) and appears to be phylogenetically conserved, as ascertained by immunocytochemistry (327). In one double labeling immunocytochemical study, macrophages were incriminated as the cell source of intrathymic CRH (328). Together with findings showing the production of ACTH and corticosterone by TEC, this raises the hypothesis that a whole circuit, similar to that seen in the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis, may occur intrathymically. Nevertheless, in terms of biological responses, the existence of such a cascade and how it might be regulated has not been completely demonstrated in the thymus.
In keeping with the expression of the POMC gene is the detection of ß-endorphin in thymus extracts, as ascertained by RIA, as well as in TEC (329, 330, 331). Intrathymic opioid production apparently is not restricted to ß-endorphin, since met-enkephalin and leu-enkephalin have been detected by immunocytochemistry in both lymphoid and microenvironmental compartments of the rat thymus (329, 330, 331, 332), a finding in keeping with evidence for pro-enkephalin A gene expression in the organ (333). Somatostatin gene expression has also been identified in the rat thymus, at the levels of mRNA and translated peptide (334, 335). Recent data suggest that somatostatin is expressed in macrophages and restricted to the medulla (313, 314).
Cloning of a TRH precursor has recently been reported in the rat thymus. Prepro-TRH mRNA was initially defined by RT-PCR using specific nucleotide primers, and the amplified gene product was then sequenced. The TRH peptide itself was further revealed by reverse phase HPLC analysis (266). Unfortunately, this study did not determine which cell type is responsible for intrathymic TRH production. In any case, considering the local production of TRH together with the intrathymic expression of the TRH receptor and the fact that this neuropeptide is able to enhance BrDu uptake by thymocytes (152), it is plausible that an autocrine/paracrine physiological TRH-mediated circuit also exists in the thymus.
Lastly, intrathymic gene expression for VIP should be noted. Various methodological approaches have shown that CD4+CD8+ double-positive as well as CD4+ and CD8+ single-positive thymocytes express this neuropeptide (276). This agrees with previous findings from the same research group showing in situ immunoreactivity for VIP in many thymocytes (335). As discussed earlier, the autocrine/paracrine secretion of VIP by thymocytes, together with its role in counteracting apoptosis induced by glucocorticoid hormones, places this neuropeptide as one further player in the general process of generating the T cell repertoire in the thymus (336). This hypothesis is further supported by data indicating that VIP enhances the antigen-induced differentiation of CD4+CD8+ immature thymocytes to the CD4+ simple positive mature stage after interacting with specific antigen presenting cells (337). Similarly, enhancement of VIP production upon mitogenic and antigenic stimulation has been recently shown (338).
The intrathymic expression of various hormones and neuropeptides is
summarized in Tables 2
and 4
.
| X. Conclusions and Major Questions to Be Addressed |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
In conjunction with this point, another still unresolved question is how hormone-mediated paracrine circuits are regulated.
Since one major function of the thymus is to generate a T cell
repertoire, simultaneously bearing diversity but not autoreactivity, it
is crucial to have precise knowledge of the extent to which such a
process is under neuroendocrine control. Phenotypic analysis of the
Vß and V
gene rearrangements in thymocytes derived from fetal
thymus organ cultures subjected to distinct hormones or neuropeptides
will be of interest. We anticipate that the use of different models of
knockout mice as well as animals in which hormone-specific transgenes
are coupled to thymus-specific promoters may be useful in further
determining the relative role of each hormone or neuropeptide in the
general process of shaping the T cell repertoire. In this context, it
is worthwhile recalling that conflicting results are likely to occur
when a role for a given hormone is approached in mice in which the
corresponding gene (or the gene for the corresponding receptor) has
been inactivated. This is apparently the case of PRL or PRL receptor
knockout mice, which apparently develop an efficient immune system,
with a normal thymocyte differentiation profile (177, 178). This
clearly indicates that PRL/PRL receptor-mediated interaction is not
crucial for thymus development. Yet, such data should be viewed with
caution, as these mice never had functional PRL or PRL receptor. As in
several other redundant systems, it is possible that further biological
pathway(s) replace(s) the one triggered by PRL-mediated interactions.
Perhaps a better model would be a genetically engineered animal in
which the receptor can be activated or de-activated by gene
manipulation in adult life. In chickens deprived of major
neuroendocrine centers by surgical removal of embryonic prosencephalon,
thymocyte development ceases with accumulation of immature
CD4-CD8- thymocytes
within the organ (340). This picture is strikingly reversed by
embryonic pituitary gland engraftment or by supplying recombinant PRL,
thus emphasizing that PRL may be active, particularly in relation to
thymocyte differentiation.
In a second vein, several aspects of thymus physiology have not yet been studied in PRL receptor knockout animals. One example is cell traffic, e.g., thymocyte traffic. We have recently noted that, in spite of a normal CD4/CD8-defined differentiation pattern, the expression of fibronectin receptors by thymocytes from GH receptor null animals is altered compared with the corresponding age-matched wild-type mice, suggesting that T cell migration may be altered in these mice (our unpublished data).
A third aspect to be recalled is the paucity of information regarding the direct effects of hormones upon the thymus in humans. Although thymulin production is definitively up-regulated by several hormones including T4, PRL, and GH (76, 84), the various aspects of intrathymic T cell differentiation in humans have not been directly assessed (reviewed in Ref. 341). Unfortunately, in one study on long-term treatment of monkeys with GH, the thymus was not analyzed (342).
If we consider that abnormal generation and/or expansion of autoreactive T cells from the thymus can be influenced by the neuroendocrine system, it will be important to develop therapeutic strategies based on the neuroendocrine-mediated manipulation of T cells when they are undergoing intrathymic differentiation.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
1 This work was partially supported by grants from Brazilian
Research Council (CNPq, Brazil) and Program for Excellency in Science
(PRONEX/CNPq, Brazil), Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
(CNRS, France), Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche
Médicale (INSERM, France), Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (FIOCRUZ,
Brazil) and Programme International de Cooperation Scientifique (PICS,
France-Brazil). ![]()
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1, thymopoietin and thymulin in
mouse thymic epithelial cells at different stages of culture: a light
and electron microscopic study. Immunology 63:721727[Medline]
1 and thymulin
concentrations: observations and rat and humans. J Neuroimmunol 103:180189[CrossRef][Medline]
. Cell Immunol 119:427444[CrossRef][Medline]
: relationship with thymic epithelial cell proliferation.
Cell Immunol 137:329340[CrossRef][Medline]
-interferon and tumor necrosis factor
. Possible role in the
modulation of intrathymic education? Thymus 13:201204[Medline]
production and may play a role in
the presentation of alloantigens in vitro.
Neuroimmunomodulation 4:1927[CrossRef][Medline]
-1 on pituitary hormone release. Neuroendocrinology 55:1419[CrossRef][Medline]
1 on hypothalamic hormone release.
Neuroendocrinology 56:674679[Medline]
production.
Evidence for a novel AVP receptor on mouse lymphocytes. J Immunol 140:21792183[Abstract]
to
in rat NB2 pre-T lymphoma cells. Biochem
Biophys Res Commun 220:958962[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Farahat, L. Rashed, N. Zawilla, and S. Farouk Effect of occupational exposure to elemental mercury in the amalgam on thymulin hormone production among dental staff Toxicology and Industrial Health, April 1, 2009; 25(3): 159 - 167. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Savino Neuroendocrine control of T cell development in mammals: role of growth hormone in modulating thymocyte migration Exp Physiol, September 1, 2007; 92(5): 813 - 817. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. S. Sutherland, G. L. Goldberg, M. V. Hammett, A. P. Uldrich, S. P. Berzins, T. S. Heng, B. R. Blazar, J. L. Millar, M. A. Malin, A. P. Chidgey, et al. Activation of Thymic Regeneration in Mice and Humans following Androgen Blockade J. Immunol., August 15, 2005; 175(4): 2741 - 2753. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Smaniotto, V. de Mello-Coelho, D. M. S. Villa-Verde, J.-M. Pleau, M.-C. Postel-Vinay, M. Dardenne, and W. Savino Growth Hormone Modulates Thymocyte Development in Vivo through a Combined Action of Laminin and CXC Chemokine Ligand 12 Endocrinology, July 1, 2005; 146(7): 3005 - 3017. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Lombardi, D. Burzyn, J. Mundinano, P. Berguer, P. Bekinschtein, H. Costa, L. F. Castillo, A. Goldman, R. Meiss, I. Piazzon, et al. Cathepsin-L Influences the Expression of Extracellular Matrix in Lymphoid Organs and Plays a Role in the Regulation of Thymic Output and of Peripheral T Cell Number J. Immunol., June 1, 2005; 174(11): 7022 - 7032. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Rindi, M. Civallero, M. E. Candusso, A. Marchetti, C. Klersy, R. Nano, and A. B. Leiter Sudden Onset of Colitis After Ablation of Secretin-Expressing Lymphocytes in Transgenic Mice Experimental Biology and Medicine, September 1, 2004; 229(8): 826 - 834. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Savino, D. A. Mendes-da-Cruz, S. Smaniotto, E. Silva-Monteiro, and D. M. S. Villa-Verde Molecular mechanisms governing thymocyte migration: combined role of chemokines and extracellular matrix J. Leukoc. Biol., June 1, 2004; 75(6): 951 - 961. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. C. Land and F. Darakhshan Thymulin evokes IL-6-C/EBP{beta} regenerative repair and TNF-{alpha} silencing during endotoxin exposure in fetal lung explants Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol, March 1, 2004; 286(3): L473 - L487. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
O. K. Nihei, A. C. Campos de Carvalho, D. C. Spray, W. Savino, and L. A. Alves A novel form of cellular communication among thymic epithelial cells: intercellular calcium wave propagation Am J Physiol Cell Physiol, November 1, 2003; 285(5): C1304 - C1313. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. W. David, J. Norrman, H. M. Hammon, W. C. Davis, and J. W. Blum Cell Proliferation, Apoptosis, and B- and T-Lymphocytes in Peyer's Patches of the Ileum, in Thymus and in Lymph nodes of Preterm Calves, and in Full-Term Calves at Birth and on Day 5 of Life J Dairy Sci, October 1, 2003; 86(10): 3321 - 3329. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Norrman, C. W. David, S. N. Sauter, H. M. Hammon, and J. W. Blum Effects of dexamethasone on lymphoid tissue in the gut and thymus of neonatal calves fed with colostrum or milk replacer J Anim Sci, September 1, 2003; 81(9): 2322 - 2332. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. R. Broussard, R. H. MCCusker, J. E. Novakofski, K. Strle, W. Hong Shen, R. W. Johnson, G. G. Freund, R. Dantzer, and K. W. Kelley Cytokine-Hormone Interactions: Tumor Necrosis Factor {alpha} Impairs Biologic Activity and Downstream Activation Signals of the Insulin-Like Growth Factor I Receptor in Myoblasts Endocrinology, July 1, 2003; 144(7): 2988 - 2996. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. D. Dixit, R. Sridaran, M. A. Edmonsond, D. Taub, and W. E. Thompson Gonadotropin-Releasing Hormone Attenuates Pregnancy-Associated Thymic Involution and Modulates the Expression of Antiproliferative Gene Product Prohibitin Endocrinology, April 1, 2003; 144(4): 1496 - 1505. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Ferone, R. Pivonello, P. M. van Hagen, V. A. S. H. Dalm, E. G. R. Lichtenauer-Kaligis, M. Waaijers, P. M. van Koetsveld, D. M. Mooy, A. Colao, F. Minuto, et al. Quantitative and functional expression of somatostatin receptor subtypes in human thymocytes Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab, November 1, 2002; 283(5): E1056 - E1066. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |